Caitlyn Samantha Stubbs

Caitlyn Samantha Stubbs

4.3
Rating: 9.3

Licensed for 12 years

Family Lawyer at Stafford, VA
Practice Areas: Family, Divorce & Separation, Child Custody ... +2 more

1259 Courthouse Road, Suite 105, Stafford, VA

About Caitlyn

Biography

Practice Areas

Fees and Rates

Cost

Hourly Rates

$ 350-350 per hour


Payment Methods

  • Cash
  • Check
  • Credit Card

Looking for an attorney? Avvo can help.

search module image

Search our directory

Quickly connect with top attorneys through our legal directory to get help with your legal issue.

chat module image

Avvo's live chat agents can help coordinate a consultation with a local attorney.

Chat with a live agent who can match you with the right attorney for your legal needs.

Chat with

Licenses

Licensed in Virginia for 12 years

State: Virginia

Acquired: 2013

Active

No misconduct found

Location

Rinehart Bryant PLLC

1259 Courthouse Road, Suite 105, Stafford, VA, 22554

Ad

Transform legal challenges into solutions.

Connect now to review your situation.

The Avvo Rating explained

display-bg

The Avvo Rating explained

Caitlyn Samantha Stubbs's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

4.3 /5.0

11 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (11) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 1 - 4 of 4 reviews | Staff & Support

Posted by anonymous | August 20, 2017 | Hired Attorney | Family

A great experience during a tough time

Ms. Stubbs, along with paralegal Mr. Hall, provided me with great service throughout a tough family situation. They helped to provide guidance throughout the process and helped provide peace of mind and information during a difficult time. We ended with the best possible outcome and I would absolutel...y recommend Ms. Stubbs.

Posted by Eddie | March 31, 2017 | Hired Attorney | Divorce & Separation

Separation and Divorce

I hired Ms. Caitlyn Stubbs to file for my separation and ultimately the divorce. She was deliberate in her approach and explained that the process may be complex, however, provided a variety of perspectives regarding the challenges we may face. Ms. Stubbs was proficient and always prompt when respo...nding to my requests and ensured we'd get results. In summary, Ms. Stubbs produced solutions and ensured my concerns were professionally addressed. Ms. Stubbs has earned my respect and total confidence and I've asked her to consider representing me on another issue that is not in her area of law. It was truly a pleasure working with Ms. Stubbs and her paralegal Matthew Hall, who was also proficient and professional at all times. I want to personally thank both Caitlyn and Matthew....they are stellar representatives for Livesay & Myers, P.C

Posted by Austin | October 02, 2016 | Hired Attorney | Child Custody

For my child support case

I have a wonderful daughter. She has never had any problems going back and forth between me and her mother. However her mother was only allowing me 2 hours per week on (Sunday) for the first 7 months. I was paying child support before courts had even ordered me to and trying to be as pro active in my... daughters life as possible. Again her mother would try and control every situation and deny me from seeing her. Finally I got sick of the situation and filed papers. I had a consultation with Caitlyn Stubbs and she gave me some different options. I had my first court case right after the consultation. I hadn't hired her at that point (HUGE MISTAKE). First off this is my first child and went into court for the custody hearing. I asked the judge if we could go to mediation. He ask the mother of my child what she would like to do. She proceeded with saying she wanted to take care of it that day (after to agreeing with me about mediation). So there I was not represented and not knowing completely what I could do. I ended up not getting what I asked for (since for reason in Stafford the courts don't really help the father much). A couple days later I then had my child support hearing. Again since I didn't get what I asked for with custody I wasn't at the 90 day mark so the mother had "sole custody". That then caused me to have to pay about 700 a month in child support. I pleaded with the judge saying I couldn't afford it I work 60 hours a week as it is. Obviously the judge didn't care. I walked right out of the court room and appealed the case. I went back to Caitlyn and hired her. After hiring her and allowing her to take over my case, it was the best descion I could have made!! We were able to go to "term day" and get my next hearing in circuit court. I just had my hearing I NOW have a little over 50% custody of my beautiful daughter and now pay 200 a month in child support which is a HUGE help. I honestly can't thank Caitlyn Stubbs and Matthew, her paralegal enough. I highly recommend this great team! They kept me up to date on everything I needed to know during the whole process. Please don't hesitate to talk to them because they can do wonders for you as well!!

Posted by anonymous | June 15, 2016 | Uncontested Divorce

Decent Lawyer with Horrible Assistant

My experience with Caitlyn was for an Uncontested Divorce. My spouse and I had seemingly agreed to many items and had drafted our own Property Settlement Agreement. Going through the process with Caitlyn's assistant Nicole ("Nikki") was a nightmare. In the beginning I only had 1 over the phone consul...tation and spoke with Caitlyn. She gave me great insight into Family Law matters and explained the process of how to file an uncontested divorce. However when I started the process, I mainly dealt with just Nikki. The first issue arose when my spouse emailed me his notarized signed copy of the PSA, and I forwarded it to them. My copy was the original hard copy that was turned in to them in person. It was days before I heard back if they received both and could confirm they were able to move onto the next step. Finally I heard back from Nikki in an email only saying "We have to have the hard copy signed paperwork from your spouse, have him resign and bring it to us". Now if any of you are like me and my spouse- we were not on very good speaking terms. Plus, he is just slow at "getting things done" in general. So it had already taken me 3 weeks to get him to sign the first one, now I had to go back and ask him to find his original paperwork, bring it to me or mail it, or bring it in to them....which I knew he wouldn't bring it to my lawyer so I had to wait for him to give it to me. That set us back another week. Had I known from the beginning, obviously that time would not have been lost. There was no instruction about specifics and what needed to be done in what manner. Just fee agreements and intake paperwork for the firm as a whole. So then the paperwork was all put together and my date to file for divorce based on my 1 yr of separation was 4/29 and the paperwork was filed May 6th. Not too far off, which was pleasing. I knew a case number should be assigned fairly quickly so after a couple days I emailed asking if we had a case number yet. The entire process on avg for an uncontested divorce should have taken 2 months max, by the way. It was then almost another week, going on 2 I believe until I had a response at all from the firm if we had a case number...absurd. Finally the paperwork was mailed out to my spouse. He ended up going out of town on vacation the day his paperwork to be signed came in the mail. So that delayed it another week from him even signing it. At this point my spouse wasn't speaking to me at ALL barely (and we have a minor child so it was very complicated) and he would not answer me after his vacation if he signed his divorce paperwork. So after about 3 weeks of him receiving it, and hearing nothing from him or the attorneys office, I emailed the firm (Nikki) asking if they had received my spouses signed paperwork. Again.....4 days go by and I have no response. None. I sent an email again and needed to set up a consultation for custody court purposes with Caitlyn.....this would have been a 3rd consultation, still had not retained yet. After 4 days of not hearing I sent another email asking for the consult & checking again about status of divorce.....its going on 1.5 months with 3 steps left in the process all about 1.5 weeks long each step....so this uncontested divorce was dragging. I still heard nothing from Nikki- and Caitlyn was always copied & never responded either...finally Nikki called me with an excuse that she was waiting for approval from management for 3rd consult. Meanwhile my spouse still wasn't signing the paperwork and in that phone call Nikki finally told me they didn't get anything. At this point I was furious with the firm and their lack of communication and feeling neglected. I felt like Nikki always ignored my emails and she would lie saying that "she sent me a reply" but I never got anything. I tried 2 times speaking to management and left a message with the manager, Becky, but never heard back from her either. DO NOT USE Caitlyn if she still has Nikki...otherwise Caitlyn was decent.

See All Client Reviews

Caitlyn Samantha Stubbs's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse Caitlyn
Sarah Catherine Collins headshot
Sarah Collins

Unknown lawyer | Apr 05

Relationship: Co-worker

"Ms. Stubbs works hard, knows the law, and is a strong advocate for her clients."

Jennifer S. Varughese headshot
Jennifer Varughese

Family lawyer | Mar 29

Relationship: Co-worker

"Ms. Stubbs is a skilled, competent advocate for her clients. Her clients' positive reviews are a good indicator that Ms. Stubbs is a great attorney. I'm happy to give her my endorsement."

Caitlin Higgins headshot
Caitlin Higgins

Family lawyer | Oct 11

Relationship: Co-worker

"I highly endorse Ms. Stubbs. She is a knowledgeable family law attorney, especially in the areas of divorce and custody. Ms. Stubbs is a dedicated attorney who will fight to obtain the best possible results for her clients."

H. Eugene Oliver III headshot
H. Eugene Oliver

Family lawyer | Aug 03

Relationship: Co-worker

"Caitlyn is a knowledgeable attorney who is dedicated to making sure her clients receive the best possible outcome to their cases."

Laila Raheen headshot
Laila Raheen

Divorce and separation lawyer | Aug 03

Relationship: Co-worker

"Ms. Stubbs is a great attorney practicing Family Law. She works hard for her clients and is highly skilled and knowledgeable in the area of Family Law. I highly endorse this lawyer."

Amanda Stone Swart headshot
Amanda Stone Swart

Family lawyer | Aug 03

Relationship: Co-worker

"Ms. Stubbs is an excellent attorney. She is a strong, yet compassionate, advocate for her clients. I highly recommend her."

David J. Marquardt headshot
David Marquardt

Family lawyer | Aug 02

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Ms. Stubbs is an extremely knowledgeable and respected divorce and family law attorney. She is thorough and understanding, while also being a passionate advocate for her clients. I give her my highest endorsement."

Benjamin N. Griffitts headshot
Benjamin Griffitts

Family lawyer | Apr 23

Relationship: Co-worker

"Caitlyn is a skilled and passionate attorney. I would not hesitate in recommending her for your family law needs."

Jonathan Patrick McHugh headshot
Jonathan McHugh

Family lawyer | Mar 20

Relationship: Co-worker

"Caitlyn Stubbs is a dedicated, passionate and skilled advocate. She fights hard for her clients and has great court experience. I give her my highest endorsement."

Matthew Howard Smith headshot
Matthew Smith

Family lawyer | Mar 19

Relationship: Co-worker

"I highly endorse Ms. Stubbs. She has a good knowledge of the law and fights for her clients."

Carolyn A. Eaton headshot
Carolyn Eaton

Family lawyer | Mar 19

Relationship: Co-worker

"I highly endorse this lawyer. Caitlyn Stubbs is a talented attorney who uses her skills, knowledge and experience to be an excellent advocate for her clients. I would recommend her to anyone in need of a good family law attorney."

Sarah Marie Welch headshot
Sarah Welch

Family lawyer | Mar 10

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Ms. Stubbs is a very kind, approachable and compassionate attorney. She is always prepared for court and takes the time to explain all steps of the legal process to her clients."

Cassi Rae Baumgardner headshot
Cassi Baumgardner

Family lawyer | Mar 02

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Caitlyn is a highly talented and knowledgeable attorney. I have seen her practice in court and would highly recommend her to any one looking for a skilled and compassionate lawyer."

Danielle Irene B. Snead headshot
Danielle Snead

Family lawyer | Feb 03

Relationship: Co-worker

"Ms. Stubbs knowledge about family law and her dedication to both the practice of law and her clients makes her a great attorney. I would recommend her to anyone in need of a family lawyer."

Benjamin Hale Carafiol headshot
Benjamin Carafiol

Family lawyer | Feb 02

Relationship: Co-worker

"Caitlyn is a knowledgeable and compassionate attorney, using these skills to act on behalf of her clients. I strongly endorse Caitlyn for any and all family law matters."

Stephanie Michelle Sauer headshot
Stephanie Sauer

Family lawyer | Jan 26

Relationship: Co-worker

"Caitlyn is a strong personality who is determined to do the best job possible for her clients. I highly recommend this attorney."

James D. Livesay Jr. headshot
James Livesay

Divorce and separation lawyer | Jan 25

Relationship: Supervised lawyer

"Ms. Stubbs is an outstanding family law attorney. She combines a love of the courtroom with a deep knowledge of family law, in pursuing the best results for each and every client. I can't recommend Caitlyn highly enough to anyone facing a custody, divorce or other family law case in the Fredericksburg area."

Kevin Randall Myers headshot
Kevin Myers

Divorce and separation lawyer | Jan 25

Relationship: Supervised lawyer

"An outstanding divorce attorney, Ms. Stubbs receives my highest possible endorsement."

View All Endorsements
Brandi R. Howell headshot
Brandi Howell

Divorce and separation lawyer

Aida Farahani headshot
Aida Farahani

Immigration lawyer

Melannie H. Dino headshot
Melannie Dino

Family lawyer

Shirin Afsous headshot
Shirin Afsous

Divorce and separation lawyer

Sarah Grace Patras headshot
Sarah Patras

Family lawyer

Brianna Denise Salerno headshot
Brianna Salerno

Family lawyer

Anne Bogdon Prentice headshot
Anne Prentice

Family lawyer

Caitlin Higgins headshot
Caitlin Higgins

Divorce and separation lawyer

Sarah Catherine Collins headshot
Sarah Collins

Divorce and separation lawyer

Karen Michelle Sherie Williams headshot
Karen Williams

Immigration lawyer

Laila Raheen headshot
Laila Raheen

Unknown lawyer

Amanda Stone Swart headshot
Amanda Stone Swart

Unknown lawyer

Benjamin Hale Carafiol headshot
Benjamin Carafiol

Divorce and separation lawyer

Danielle Irene B. Snead headshot
Danielle Snead

Child custody lawyer

Pia Janine Miller headshot
Pia Miller

Family lawyer

Cassi Rae Baumgardner headshot
Cassi Baumgardner

Criminal defense lawyer

Nicole H. Naum headshot
Nicole Naum

Criminal defense lawyer

Experience

Rating:  9.3 (Superb)

Honors

2019

Virginia Rising Star, Super Lawyers

2018

Virginia Rising Star, Super Lawyers

2018

Top 40 Under 40, The National Advocates

2017

National Academy of Family Law Attorneys, Top 10 Under 40 Attorney Award

2016

2016 Top Contributor Award, Avvo

2013

Graduated Cum Laude, Thomas M. Cooley Law School

2012

Trial Skills Certificate of Merit, Thomas M. Cooley Law School

2012

John W. Hanks Award, Delta Theta Phi

2011

Client Counseling Competition Gold Certificate, Thomas M. Cooley Law School

Work Experience

2018 - 2019

Senior Associate, Livesay & Myers, P.C.

2015 - 2018

Associate, Livesay & Myers, P.C.

2014 - 2015

Associate, Law Offices of J.M Reynolds, PLLC

Associations

2016 - Present

Fredericksburg Area Bar Association

Member

2015 - Present

U.S. Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit

Admitted to Practice

2014 - Present

Virginia Bar Association

Member

2014 - Present

U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Virginia

Admitted to Practice

2014 - Present

U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Eastern District of Virginia

Admitted to Practice

2013 - Present

Virginia State Bar

Member

2014 - 2015

Prince William County Bar Association

Member

2014 - 2015

Old Dominion Bar Association

Convention Committee

Sample of Legal Cases

Grandparent Custody Case

Custody to Grandparents

Child Support Case

Child Support Award for Mother

See More Legal Cases

Education

2013

Thomas M. Cooley Law School

JD - Juris Doctor

2009

Shippensburg University

BS - Bachelor of Science

Speaking Engagements

Languages

English

Activity

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution