No Photo

David James Steele

4.5
Rating: 1.0

Licensed for 22 years

Divorce and separation Lawyer at Indianapolis, IN
Practice Areas: Divorce & Separation, Family, Child Custody, Child Support

3021 East 98th Street, Suite 105, Indianapolis, IN

This lawyer was disciplined by a state licensing authority in 2015
See Details

About David

Practice Areas

4

Practice Areas

Divorce and Separation 25%

For the past decade, I have handled some 1,500 cases, including everything from divorce to child custody matters, child support, post dissolution matters and anything else related to family law. Please see my profile for a complete listing of reviews from former clients. That will aways be the best way to judge an attorney. I return every phone call, I push every case aggressively and I will never overbill a client. Period.

23 years | 1,500 cases

25%

Fees and Rates

Cost

Free Consultation

$0 first 60 minutes


Payment Methods

  • Cash
  • Check
  • Credit Card

Looking for an attorney? Avvo can help.

search module image

Search our directory

Quickly connect with top attorneys through our legal directory to get help with your legal issue.

chat module image

Avvo's live chat agents can help coordinate a consultation with a local attorney.

Chat with a live agent who can match you with the right attorney for your legal needs.

Chat with

Licenses

Licensed in Indiana for 22 years

State: Indiana

Acquired: 2003

Disbarred

Lawyer disciplined by state licensing authority in 2015

Location

Steele Legal Group

3021 East 98th Street, Suite 105, Indianapolis, IN, 46280

Ad

Transform legal challenges into solutions.

Connect now to review your situation.

The Avvo Rating explained

display-bg

The Avvo Rating explained

David James Steele's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

4.5 /5.0

47 Client Reviews

Showing 16 - 20 of 26 reviews | Case Results

Posted by P.K. | August 29, 2013 | Divorce & Separation

WITHOUT A DOUBT, THE BEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN THE ENTIRE STATE!!!

SIMPLY PUT, DAVID STEELE IS THE BEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN INDIANA!!! David was my last hope in a 20-month long ordeal where my ex willfully dragged her heels to complete the divorce simply because she knew I wanted to do it expeditiously. I needed someone who was totally no-nonsense, aggressive, and ef...ficient to bring closure to this so that both sides could escape this toxic situation and move on with our lives. In addition to dealing with this type of personality, I was also faced with an opposing attorney who appeared to endorse and embrace her using every legal tool available in order to drag out this case for as long as possible. When I hired David, he immediately made clear in no uncertain terms to the opposing side that he would not let this charade continue, and he didn't. In advance of and at my mediation, he demonstrated his constant pledge to me that he would have my back, and he totally did. He made sure that I was protected in every way, and I was COMPLETELY SATISFIED with the successful outcome of the mediation, and I finally have closure to this long nightmare that has haunted me. I came away with EVERYTHING that I desired. David has an INCREDIBLE talent for detail and strategy. Moreover, David is also the most compassionate attorney I've ever seen. My financial resources and retirement were totally savaged by having to support my ex, and I have a very very modest income due to the nature of my work and the recession. David recognized this, and was VERY gentle in his billing, making huge accommodations to assist my current financial plight. His billing was MORE THAN FAIR. I will NEVER forget his kindness and compassion. His principles, contrasted with what I witnessed with opposing counsel, are uncompromising in wanting to do the right thing and to do it with unwavering quality. His being on the state bar ethics committee is also supportive of that. Highly principled, fair, compassionate, yet when it comes to the legal battlefield (and yes it IS a battle!), you could not ask for a more skilled, committed attorney. Quite bluntly, after my absolutely positive experience with David, who's got to be this state's preeminent divorce attorney, I would be scared as hell if I was an attorney and saw David at the opposing table. I read every word of these 23 reviews, every one of which gave him an A+ in all 5 categories and then I read the one unfavorable review from someone below. I have come to know David very, very well as he had my back the whole time and I can't believe that anything is true in that review. Read the facts that EVERYONE ELSE has shared of their experience. Anyone who doesn't think this man is a superior attorney is just plain wrong or totally confused. I'll say it again: DAVID STEELE IS THE BEST DIVORCE LAWYER IN INDIANA BAR NONE!

Posted by anonymous | May 10, 2013 | Child Custody

I don't even know where to start - he literally saved my life

I really don't know where to start. David was the ONLY attorney who would even talk to me on the phone without wanting money first or being really rude and basically hanging up on me after 30 seconds. He called me back after I left him a voicemail. i didn't expect that after all the jerks I had tal...ked to. He talked to me for 70 minutes. I swear to God. At 6:00 at night. And never asked me for a dime for spending over an hour with someone who just called him. And at that point, I didn't know what to think. Was he a little crazy? Was he this desperate for a client...why would he go to such phenomenal lengths to help me? It wasn't until later, when I became a client, I realized that he is one of the biggest lawyers in Indy, if not the whole state. And once I got to know him and I saw what he did to my husband's attorney in court, it is ABSOLUTELY not a surprise to me. And trust me - he's exceptionally busy. He often called me as late as 10:00; i mean, he was always working and he still made me feel like I was his only client and that his whole company hinged on whether or not he won. And by winning I mean getting me custody of my two girls. I would have died if I lost them. I simply would have died. And he did all this while his phone, his receptionist's phone, his paralegal's phone and his associate lawyer's phones were ringing off the hook. And in court...I just don't know how to describe it. He was so much better at what he does than the other lawyer, it just made the man look silly. My husband was losing his sh%$ the entire time because it was so obviously not going his way and david just got cooler and calmer as it went on and that just drove him more nuts. Which then rattled his attorney. And David was unflappable.. He even started smiling really subtly at my husband at his table when no one was looking. it was straight out of a movie. trust me - he deserved everything david gave him. I don't know what else to say. I've never once logged onto the internet to review anything or post anything. But david got me my girls by working harder and smarter and honestly just caring more than anyone else. and he did it all for the original retainer as he promised he would try to do though he couldn't guarantee it. I paid $3,000 to start and while I don't know exactly how lawyers work, I know that at his hourly rate, we went WAY WAY over $3,000. But he knew I was absolutely broke because my husband left us high and dry and I had to borrow the money of my aunt and uncle. He always acted like I had money left on my retainer and I know it was because he didn't want to make me feel like a charity case. And the frustrating part is there was absolutely no way on God's earth I can adequately thank him. What do you do for someone who rescued your life? and in such a cool and almost fun way (he's absolutely hilarious, by the way - you will feel comfortable with him in about 30 seconds)? So I tried to write something on his website to at least try to say thank you but there's no way to thank him on his site but I found this link. Then I read all the other people he helped and it's just amazing. every one of us had the same experience. He seriously is the #1 divorce/custody lawyer in Indiana. There's no question. Does anyone else have reviews like this? Anywhere? David - I know you don't read these but if you ever do, know that I am crying as I write this and I will never be able to thank you enough. You saved me. You saved my daughters and only you and I know what you saved them from. Thank you.

Posted by Jeff | January 17, 2013 | Divorce & Separation

A Man of His Word, Brilliant Attorney

It was immediately clear that David's main concern was winning. It was not money. Every other lawyer I called only talked money. This was my first time using the legal system and I was nervous and clueless. David couldn't have been more patient and I doubt he could have been more knowledgable. I...t was very obvious he has been doing only this for ten years. He got everything possible for me out of my divorce which wasn't exactly amicable. He did it while keeping everything friendly and never charged me a dime over my initial retainer. He could have run my bill up but instead, he kept doing things without charging me. I mean, he seriously did not charge me for about every other phone call or email. He said in the beginning that he would respond to every email and every phone call. I did not expect him to be quite that serious. Every single time I called, he called back. Every time I wrote an email, he wrote back. Every time something happened, he called to tell me. It honestly got to the point where my now ex-wife called ME to find out what was happening because she knew my lawyer told me immediately and she could never get a hold of her lawyer (who she paid more for, by the way). God, that was satisfying! I just can't recommend David enough. And judging by the other reviews I read, neither can any of his other clients.

Posted by Ashley | November 08, 2012 | Child Custody

Outstanding Knowledgeable Lawyer! He's a winner!

I contacted David Steele along with probably 20 other lawyers about a child custody case. I couldn't get hardly ANY attorneys to even email me back with even a direction on where to go with my case without paying at least $1000 before even talking at all. Not only was he one of the ONLY attorney...s to contact me back, he emailed me at 1am on his own time explaining EVERYTHING that had to do with my case. Along with emailing me, I also talked to him via phone where he gave me his personal cell phone which lawyers just do not do unless they truly care. We emailed back and forth almost 30 times before I ever agreed to even come in to meet with him and he never asked for a dime for all the free consultations. After agreeing to meet with him, he didn't charge me at all for the whole in person consultation either. He told me absolutely everything I wanted to hear when it comes to being a mother fighting for a child. He gave me a great discount as far as a retainer & he has done everything in his power to save me money. I almost paid a " cheap " attorney that I had found which he talked me out of because he knew it was someone trying to take my money and nothing else. He absolutely fought for everything that I wanted when it came to custody, visitation, child support, etc,. and of course he won. He didn't agree to sign anything or take the easy way out to be lazy; he absoutlely worked his butt off to get me what I wanted. It was all about making ME happy. I have had NOTHING but wonderful experiences with Mr. Steele. He's VERY personable & he kept me up to date almost daily on my case whether it was through email, phone, or in person. I absolutely adore him and have referred him to many others. I'd go back to him for any issue that I have. Any amount of money that I paid was WELL worth it and the amount I did pay was absolutely reasonable. He spent so much time and effort on my case, making me happy, & winning. I'd never use anyone else! If you're looking for a winner, David Steele is absolutely your man!

Posted by Marion T Waldrop | November 05, 2012 | Divorce & Separation

WARNING^^^^ Do Not call him unless you are serious about WINNING !

I contacted David Steele one day to ask questions about a highly unusual divorce and custody case and I mean this is one for the record books. I just wanted some answers and what I got was above and beyond anything I could have hoped for. He immediately gave me his full attention and wanted the facts.... I have interviewed with 5 attorneys only to have them take a 300 dollar counsultation fees and tell me that they had too large of a case load to even talk to me anymore. They wished me luck, took my money and sent me out the door feeling worse then I did when I walked through it. NOT David Steele!!! He made me feel like I was the only client that he had. He cares about winning NOT Money! Since I have hired him I have seen nothing but action and results. Not only was he interested in my case first and MONEY LAST, but he charged half of what the attorneys that I interviewed were going to charge me, that is if they had been even interested in being hired. I bet I don't tell another lawyer joke for years! Mr. Steele was very professional and interested in helping me and his staff is EXCELLENT as well. I thought he was just being courteous or maybe a joke when He gave me his cell phone number and told me that he would call me back. So I threw away the cell number. He called me back on it less then 30 minutes after I had already talked to him. He has called me numerous times to give me updates on my case. I cant beleive it. IS THIS MAN FOR REAL? Answer to that question is undoubtebly a YES! He's real! HE'S A ROCK STAR! If Eric Clapton was an attorney, then he would be David Steele, THANK YOU MR. STEELE! I almost feel like I took money from YOU.. WARNING!!!!!! Do not contact David Steele unless you are serious about WINNING!

See All Client Reviews

David James Steele's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse David
Justin Thane Bowen headshot
Justin Bowen

Litigation lawyer | Sep 06

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"Having worked with Dave Steele on several matters, I can attest to his intellect and legal accumen. Although I have not personally observed him in the court room, he is without question one of the most outgoing and approachable people I have ever met, and I am certain this translates into great results with both his clients and in front of the court. I am certain Dave would be a fine choice as a litigator on any matter. Congratulations on your success Dave!"

Kristin E. Hobbs headshot
Kristin Hobbs

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 27

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. David J. Steele is a top notch attorney. His responses in public forums such as AVVO showcase his experience, expertise, and a deep understanding and knowledge of the law. Any person in need of an attorney will be greatly served by this superior attorney."

Carol A. Lawson headshot
Carol Lawson

Divorce and separation lawyer | Dec 02

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. David is a true and passionate advocate for his clients."

Peter Joseph Lamont headshot
Peter Lamont

Divorce and separation lawyer | Dec 02

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. He has earned the respect and trust of fellow lawyers and clients."

Jacob Shad Mason headshot
Jacob Mason

Divorce and separation lawyer | Dec 02

Relationship: Other

"I endorse this lawyer."

Ronna L. DeLoe headshot
Ronna DeLoe

Divorce and separation lawyer | Dec 01

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I wholeheartedly endorse this lawyer. He is an excellent attorney in the matrimonial/family law field."

Florian Eqrem Tabaku headshot
Florian Tabaku

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 30

Relationship: Other

"I endorse this lawyer. Mr. Steele provides clear and helpful advice. He is knowledgeable and cares about his clients."

William Thomas Schemmel headshot
William Schemmel

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 28

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. His AVVO answers demonstrate significant experience and expertise in family law."

Gilbert Richard Hoy Jr headshot
Gilbert Hoy

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 28

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Attorney Steele is a superb divorce lawyer. Excellent reputation and results."

Joseph Franklin Pippen Jr. headshot
Joseph Pippen

Family lawyer | Nov 27

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Attorney Steele has a superb rating on AVVO and is a credit to AVVO and the legal community for his volunteer efforts helping the community understand legal issues."

Jeremy Judson Cobb headshot
Jeremy Cobb

Unknown lawyer | Nov 27

Relationship: Other

"I've carefully reviewed Mr. Steele's qualifications and answers. He breathes insight and compassion into a profession that badly needs both."

Matthew Thomas Majeski headshot
Matthew Majeski

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 27

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse Counsel Steele. He provides valuable and helpful advice to the Avvo community and would make a great choice for family law situations."

Tolulope O. Kuteyi headshot
Tolulope Kuteyi

Unknown lawyer | Nov 27

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer."

Benjamin I. Hirsch headshot
Benjamin Hirsch

Unknown lawyer | Nov 27

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. David Steele's advice on this site has been spot on. It is to the point, easy to understand and he clearly grasps the issues."

Chong Hae Ye headshot
Chong Ye

Unknown lawyer | Aug 22

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer."

Tatiana Kadetskaya headshot
Tatiana Kadetskaya

Unknown lawyer | Jun 28

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Excellent lawyer. Well respected."

Matthew Erik Johnson headshot
Matthew Johnson

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 10

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Outstanding lawyer in the community."

Brian Brenn headshot
Brian Brenn

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 09

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"David is a wonderful attorney, very talented and client-driven. I would highly endorse him."

James P. Frederick headshot
James Frederick

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 07

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Mr. Steele and I do not practice in ANY of the same areas of law. We somehow crossed paths on a particular Avvo question and have communicated a couple of times, since. What I have noticed in my interactions with David is he is not your typical lawyer. That is a good thing, because people often despise "typical lawyers." If you review David's profile, his philosophy and his client reviews, you get a sense that not only is David not typical, but he is exceptional, in who he is and what he does. The kind of work that he does is difficult. He is often meeting with people who are at their very worst. You can tell from the reviews that David not only helps them through that, but that he also gives them a whole new outlook on lawyers and the law. How many lawyers can you say that about? For these reasons and because I really admire the man's philosophy and his bio, I am very happy to endorse David and his services. James Frederick"

View All Endorsements
Peter Joseph Lamont headshot
Peter Lamont

Unknown lawyer

Jacob Shad Mason headshot
Jacob Mason

Unknown lawyer

Ronna L. DeLoe headshot
Ronna DeLoe

Unknown lawyer

Florian Eqrem Tabaku headshot
Florian Tabaku

Unknown lawyer

William Thomas Schemmel headshot
William Schemmel

Unknown lawyer

Matthew Thomas Majeski headshot
Matthew Majeski

Unknown lawyer

Jeremy Judson Cobb headshot
Jeremy Cobb

Unknown lawyer

Joseph Franklin Pippen Jr. headshot
Joseph Pippen

Unknown lawyer

Gilbert Richard Hoy Jr headshot
Gilbert Hoy

Unknown lawyer

Tolulope O. Kuteyi headshot
Tolulope Kuteyi

Unknown lawyer

Benjamin I. Hirsch headshot
Benjamin Hirsch

Unknown lawyer

Kristin E. Hobbs headshot
Kristin Hobbs

Unknown lawyer

Carol A. Lawson headshot
Carol Lawson

Litigation lawyer

James P. Frederick headshot
James Frederick

General practice lawyer

Burton A. Padove headshot
Burton Padove

Car accident lawyer

Matthew Erik Johnson headshot
Matthew Johnson

Criminal defense lawyer

Brian Brenn headshot
Brian Brenn

Discrimination lawyer

Justin Thane Bowen headshot
Justin Bowen

Divorce and separation lawyer

Experience

Rating:  1.0 (Extreme Caution)

Professional misconduct

This lawyer was disciplined by a state licensing authority in 2015.

Disbarment issued in IN, 2015

updated on 12/01/2015

This is the most serious penalty for a lawyer. If this attorney is currently practicing law, you should contact the the Indiana State Bar to understand the reasons for this disbarment.

Interim suspension issued in IN, 2015

updated on 11/19/2015

This means the attorney temporarily lost his or her license to practice law while the State investigates whether the attorney should be disciplined. The suspension typically expires when the investigation is resolved.

Honors

2006

President, Howard County Bar Association

Work Experience

2011 - Present

Owner, Steele Legal Group, LLC

2009 - 2010

Attorney, Nice & Steffey, LLP

2005 - 2009

Deputy Prosecuting Attorney, Howard County Prosecutor's Office

2005 - 2009

Owner, Steele Law Office

2003 - 2005

Attorney, Russell, McIntyre, Hilligoss and Welke

Associations

2006 - Present

Indianapolis Bar Association

2003 - Present

Indiana State Bar Association

2003 - Present

Indiana Trial Lawyers Association

2009 - 2011

Indiana State Bar Association, Legal Ethics Committee

2003 - 2007

Howard County Bar Association

Past President

Sample of Legal Cases

David Steele

Receiving $1.2 million settlement in January

David Steele

$350,000 settlement

Dental Malpractice

Received $235,000 settlement

See More Legal Cases

Education

2003

University of Denver Sturm College of Law

JD - Juris Doctor

1998

Ball State University

BS - Bachelor of Science

Activity

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline
    This lawyer was disciplined by a state licensing authority in 2015
    Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution