Nancy L. Cavey

PRO

Nancy L. Cavey

4.5
Rating: 9.7

Licensed for 45 years

Insurance Lawyer at Saint Petersburg, FL
Practice Areas: Insurance, Social Security, Bankruptcy & Debt, Workers Compensation

1700 66th Street N, Suite 504,, Saint Petersburg, FL

About Nancy

Biography

Need help with a Long Term Disability or Social Security Disability claim?

Practice Areas

4

Practice Areas

Insurance 49%

Long Term Disability and ERISA Law including Short Term Disability.

46 years

49%
Social Security & Disability 40%

Social Security Disability Insurance Law

46 years

40%
Bankruptcy and Debt 7%

Bankruptcy Chapter 7 and Chapter 13

7%
Workers Compensation 4%

State of Florida Workers Compensation Law

46 years

4%

Fees and Rates

Cost

Contingency

33%-40%

Retainer

Sometimes


Payment Methods

  • Cash
  • Check
  • Credit Card

Awards

Client's Choice
Client's Choice
2019 2016 2015
Silver Client Champion
AV Preeminent Peer Review Rating

Licenses

Licensed in District of Columbia for 9 years

State: District of Columbia

Acquired: 2016

Good Standing

No misconduct found

Licensed in Florida for 45 years

State: Florida

Acquired: 1980

Member in Good Standing

No misconduct found

Location

The Law Offices of Nancy L. Cavey

1700 66th Street N, Suite 504,, Saint Petersburg, FL, 33710

caveylaw.com

Online Presence

Other places you can find Nancy online.

Nancy L. Cavey's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

4.5 /5.0

43 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (43) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 1 - 5 of 6 reviews | Trustworthiness

Posted by Scot | March 23, 2022 | Hired Attorney | Social Security Disability

A great firm and solid results

When I had to retire on disability, I figured "how hard could it be to fill out the forms for my insurer and for Social Security?". I found out. When my insurer denied my initial claim, just by chance I'd had two people close to me say THAT DAY that I might have a Ph.D., but I was NOT equipped to ...go nose-to nose with agencies and companies which basically exist to find reasons to tell you "no". Searching for someone relatively local to me who seemed like the "pitbull" I realized I needed, I found Nancy's info. From the first call, I felt like Nancy and her staff had lifted this incredible weight off of my shoulders. Now, understand that you DO have to listen to Nancy (or Krysti, or Megan) and if they have a form that only you have the ability to fill out...you have to do the form. They're not magic. But they explain exactly what you have to do, what you can do, and what you shouldn't do. OK, the elephant in many people's rooms: Can you afford a lawyer? When you're dealing with disability insurance and Social Security, and you're also dealing with your disability, doctor visits, and the unknown future of having to retire, sometimes far earlier than you imagined you would have to, I can promise you that 1) you really need someone who knows this aspect of the law, and 2) if you're like me, you have a million things to get done, and done right the first time, and the critical importance of your insurance and Social Security will overload your stress system. The paperwork itself is a weeks-long full-time job IF you want any chance of winning. How much is your time worth? And honestly, you'll probably lose if you go it alone. Some of you may have heard about a friend's cousin's bestie who single-handedly took on their employer's pension disability department, their own ERISA policy, and SSDI. All at once! And won all of them! And they gave her a flying unicorn too! And a puppy! Kidding aside, It comes down to this: you work for HOURS, over MONTHS and possibly YEARS, and one tiny omission or mistake, and you see "denied" again. Again, how much is YOUR time worth, for an outcome far less certain than if you hire, for example, Nancy Cavey? There was no up-front fee, and the contingency fees were in line with everyone else (they're written into the law in the case of Social Security). What you're getting is freedom from a huge amount of paperwork that Nancy and her paralegals know how to do far better than you do. You get freedom from remembering deadlines that can kill your case entirely. And at the end of the day, it's comforting to be able to think "yeah, my insurance/Social Security is a really important thing, but my lawyer's taking care of it". And Nancy and her staff did so, obtaining my disability insurance approval. I continue to work with Nancy Cavey, as I'm but halfway along my journey -- I'll update at some later era of the earth when SSDI gets back to us. Reminds me of the Fellowship of the Rings, and the Ents. Where did the Ent-wives go? Well, if they move and make decisions as slowly as their Ent-husbands, perhaps they found a home at Social Security (You have to be a REAL LOTR nerd to get that reference [it wasn't in the movies...]). Even though I still wait to I hear from Social Security, I do hear from Megan every little while, if just to let me know where in the bureaucracy my file has been moved. I'm far, far more hopeful that this too will go OK with Nancy Cavey's firm representing me. Nice, professional, competent. Great to find all three in one place. HIRE THIS ATTORNEY. You won't regret it. (PS: good luck on the bar, L3...:)

Posted by anonymous | August 30, 2017 | Hired Attorney

Great First Impression

My initial consultation with Mrs Cavey was one to write home about. By far one of the sharpest, dedicaded, knowledable, professional, and 'straight up' attorneys Ive meet. Im confident and assured that she will get me the best result. I hired her on the spot.

Posted by Adele | November 25, 2015 | Hired Attorney | Social Security Disability

Answer To my Prayers.

One day I received a letter telling me my long term disability was no longer going to continue payment. They did this a few years after they agreed I`d need and would receive payment till 65 years of age. I went on line and found Nancy`s website,..Caveylaw.com. Her site was so helpful, it outlined ev...erything anyone experiencing this devastating news needs to know.Well, I called right away and all my questions were answered and I was given an appointment the following week. Anyone who has become disabled after a lifetime of working, knows that there is not anything more stressful and that your anxiety levels are off the charts. Your basic needs can no longer be met without an income. Then after applying for social security disability and you are denied and humiliated you just want to give up. Thats where I was at when I met Nancy. My thoughts & emotions were all over the place and Nancy knew where I was coming from. She understood and she reassured me and led me through the whole process. Anyone who is experiencing problems with social security disability or their long term disability I encourage you to contact Nancy Cavey. Nancy, without a doubt, will help you through the whole process,I know you will be glad you did.

Posted by Andrea | September 06, 2016 | Hired Attorney | Personal Injury

Do not use this lawyer!

DO NOT USE THIS LAWYER!!! I have never in my life been treated as poorly as I was with this lawyer. I was in a car accident 3 years ago that ruptured 9 of the disks in my spine. Cavey sold the caring lawyer bit well, but after our first meeting when she took on my case and I signed the paperwork, s...he never once returned my calls. Her assistants or paralegals (I'm not sure what they are) were two of the rudest, least competent women on the planet. I would call in with new medical/Doctor/hospitalization information, questions, or to check on my case and they were often short and NEVER let me speak to the actual attorney. My case should have been easily approved by round two. I had more than enough medical documentation. I lost my insurance and access to medical care about halfway through all of this. I begged her assitant to have her call me back, begged them to file for an expedited hearing, and nothing. Absolutely nothing. I get a letter from Social Security letting me know that my hearing was scheduled. I call again and no calls back, her assistants never offering anything more than like "okay, well I'll take that information and have her call you back." WHICH SHE NEVER DID!!! 10 days before my hearing, still nothing. I called again and I'm begging. I refused to get off the phone until I spoke with her. Her assitant starts screaming at me like some crazy person that I was being uncooperative and that Cavey would no longer represent me. Let me reiterate the the only time I raised my voice was to tell her that there was no reason to yell at me (at which point she hung up). I tried calling back and she kept hanging up on me. I tried to get another lawyer but no one would take my case until she waived her right to collect a fee on my case. It took me over a week to get that waiver of paper from her office. I had to make the 4 hour drive to Tampa (I have since moved) for my hearing, with no lawyer. I was granted a continuance and given a copy of my medical records that had been sent it. It was threadbare! Nothing was sent in past the first 3 months after the accident. NONE of dozen or more doctors that I had seen were even contacted. I gathered what I could from every doctor and specialist that I could remember (I get terrible migraines and a large part of my case was how hard it is for me to concentrate and remember things). I tried to gather what I hadn't lost in the mail but it was only about 60% of what should have been in there. My case is now pending while they look over at the stack of documents that I had to scramble to get together. Whatever you do, do not trust her.

Posted by anonymous | November 30, 2015 | Hired Attorney | Social Security Disability

Surprised at the lack of sensitivity

Her book is excellent. I highly recommend it. It tells you a lot about Social Security Disability if you are new to the process. However, she doesn't adhere by her own words such as she will meet with you and go over your case and decide if she will take it. That never happened. I met with her staf...f. I signed the contract and was told they would mail it to me. I did sign it but wasn't dated. That is my fault. I was overwhelmed and believed them. I had a bad experience within a few days with no return phone call until 3 days later.To this day, I have never received a copy of the contract after 3 letters sent to the attorney. I had to beg to get my records sent back to me. I never even met her and she fired me by a letter according to what her staff told her. I don't believe she even read the letters I sent to her. I truly believe her staff intercepted them and she never knew the true story. She left me without a lawyer and I was denied and am currently in appeal. I don't have a lawyer. The experience left a distrust for lawyers. Very tough out there getting disability and watch out if you have mental health issues as Atty. Cavey and her staff don't understand or have any sympathy for someone in that state. Hope this helps.

Nancy Cavey

Replied last November 30, 2015

My father who was disabled and on Social Security disability benefits and, as a result, I am full of compassion for those who are in need. I and my paralegals Teresa and Stasha, pride ourselves on helping those with mental health issues get the Social Security disability benefits they deserve. Many of our clients are referred by psychologists, psychiatrists, and mental health counselors. The Social Security disability process isn’t easy and that is why team work and the cooperation of our clients is crucial. Without violating the attorney client relationship, an initial intake was done and, because of my vacation schedule, an initial appointment with both Teresa and Stasha was held in 6 working days after the call! A contract was signed after we had an opportunity to explain the Social Security fee and answer her questions. We explain the 5 step sequential evaluation process used in every Social Security Disability claim and the claims process. We never want our clients to be overwhelmed and want to make sure all of your questions are answered! Our client was asked to complete a Disability Report-Appeal form which is required in the appeal of every denied claim. We explained that an appeal couldn’t be filed with the form. She asked questions and indicated she understood all of our answers and what had to be done. Unfortunately, 3 days later we got a message from her advising she had ripped up the form that had to be completed! We can’t file an appeal if we don’t’ have all the right information and forms. Communication is a two street and, after leaving several unreturned messages, we had no choice but to withdraw as her attorney. She was given all of her material back timely and even given the names of 3 other Social Security attorneys who might be a better fit. We do understand and love helping clients, but if they can’t help us by filing out necessary forms, we just can’t help them.

See All Client Reviews

Nancy L. Cavey's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse Nancy
E. Lynn Gibbons headshot
E. Lynn Gibbons

Insurance lawyer | Oct 27

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I have been referring clients to Nancy for long term and short term disability benefits for over 10 years. She is professional and aggressive and could write a book on ERISA claims. I highly recommend her!"

Lisa Douglas headshot
Lisa Douglas

Social Security & Disability lawyer | Jan 18

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Nancy is a pro, she really knows her stuff."

Christopher Michael Davis headshot
Christopher Davis

Social Security & Disability lawyer | Jan 29

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I endorse Ms. Cavey. She does a fantastic job for her clients, and also helps other lawyers by teaching them to serve their clients better. Ms. Cavey is very smart and dedicated to her specialty, so her clients are very well served."

Christopher Leo Petruccelli headshot
Christopher Petruccelli

Workers compensation lawyer | Jan 08

Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter

"I endorse this lawyer. Nancy is an excellent attorney who carries great knowledge and passion in her representation."

Charlotte Coker Christian headshot
Charlotte Christian

Bankruptcy and debt lawyer | Aug 16

Relationship: Other

"I first met Nancy Cavey in a group for lawyers and I learned very quickly how valuable she is to the profession. Nancy is one of the premier examples of attorneys who run their law office efficiently and professionally. Nancy has been helpful to me as an attorney and she is a lawyer who I would hire without reservation."

Gregory John Perenich headshot
Gregory Perenich

Insurance lawyer | May 12

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I have known Nancy for approximately 10 years and believe she has the intellect and experience to achieve the best results for her clients, particularly in the area of ERISA long-term disability."

Brian Marc Mittman headshot
Brian Mittman

Social Security & Disability lawyer | Mar 15

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"For over six years I have had the pleasure of knowing and working with Nancy. While we practice in different states, having an attorney in Florida who REALLY knows what she is talking about is invaluable. I have actually worked with her on workers compensation matters, long term disability and social security. The information and education she provides to her clients and prospective clients is second to none and her willingness to speak and explain needed information to other attorneys is superb. I strongly endorse Nancy Cavey!"

Scott Richard Marshall headshot
Scott Marshall

Unknown lawyer | Sep 15

Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter

"I have known Nancy Cavey for 15 years and had many cases against her. She is a fierce advocate for her clients. Her keen intellect and direct approach make her a very potent adversary. I have never known a lawyer as focused as she is. I strongly recommend her."

Charles Edward Boyk headshot
Charles Boyk

Unknown lawyer | Jun 09

Relationship: Other

"I can wholly endorse Nancy. She takes her clients step by step through the complex legal process, dedicated to providing her best service. If you're in Florida and in need of an attorney, you know who to call."

James Russell Brown headshot
James Brown

Unknown lawyer | Jun 08

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I definitely endorse Nancy Cavey as the best Social Security and Long Term Disability lawyer for you to have on your side. She is the best at taking the lead in the legal process in your time of need. Do not hesitate to call Nancy Cavey if you need a disability lawyer in Florida."

Daniel L. Buckfire headshot
Daniel Buckfire

Social Security & Disability lawyer | Jun 03

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I endorse this lawyer. Nancy Cavey has a well-deserved national reputation for her representation of injured clients in social security, worker's compensation, and disability insurance claims. Her knowledge of Long Term Disability claims is extraordinary and her track record of success against those insurance companies is second to none. Nancy and her staff provide the perfect client experience throughout the entire process. She deserves her perfect "10" AVVO rating."

Stuart A. Carpey headshot
Stuart Carpey

Unknown lawyer | Jun 02

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I have known Nancy for several years through various national legal organizations to which she and I belong. I hold her in the highest regard. She genuinely cares for her clients and is a top-notch person. I would not hesitate to refer any client of mine who resides in Florida, and who had a Social Security Disability claim, to her office. I am confident she would provide excellent representation."

Brian Augustus Beckcom headshot
Brian Beckcom

Social Security & Disability lawyer | Jun 01

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Nancy truly is an exceptional lawyer. I know firsthand that Nancy is constantly trying to improve her client's experience. I recommend her without reservation."

Timothy Justin Young headshot
Timothy Young

Social Security & Disability lawyer | May 31

Relationship: Other

"Nancy works hard to educate her clients. She is always looking for ways to improve her clients' experiences with her office. That is rare with today's lawyers."

James Robert Parrish headshot
James Parrish

Unknown lawyer | May 31

Relationship: Other

"I endorse Nancy Cavey. Having over 30 years of experience, Nancy is the premiere Long Term Disability attorney in Florida. She is always efficient and effective in her work. If you have a disability matter in Florida, Nancy Cavey is the person to call."

Lee Ippolito Jurewitz headshot
Lee Jurewitz

Social Security & Disability lawyer | May 29

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"As a fellow Social Security Benefits attorney, Nancy is an inspiration to me and how we practice in our law office. She not only obtains fantastic results for her clients but she runs her office with precision and consistently provides compassionate customer service for her clients."

Ross A. Jurewitz headshot
Ross Jurewitz

Insurance lawyer | May 29

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Nancy runs one of the best law practices--of any practice area--in the entire country. She is a nationally recognized leader when it comes to law office management and systems. Her insurance claim and disability benefits clients should consider them truly blessed to have Nancy Cavey and her team representing them. Oh, and Go Gators!"

Jeffrey H. Rasansky headshot
Jeffrey Rasansky

Social Security & Disability lawyer | May 27

Relationship: Friend

"I have known Nancy for quite some time and she is without a doubt one of the best Social Security and Disability attorneys I know. She has always been an advocate for victims and gives expert information freely to those who seek it."

Daniel J. O'Brien headshot
Daniel O'Brien

Social Security & Disability lawyer | May 26

Relationship: Other

"I endorse this lawyer. Nancy is creative, innovative and a truly talented lawyer. You cannot do better than having Nancy as your attorney."

L. Ty Wilson headshot
L. Ty Wilson

Social Security & Disability lawyer | May 25

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Nancy Cavey is in my opinion one of the leading authorities on Long Term Disability and Social Security attorneys in Tampa/St. Petersburg, Florida area. Having authored 5 books on the subject Ms. Cavey the clear leader in the areas of Long Term Disability and Social Security law. Ms. Cavey is focused and unwavering on obtaining the results her clients seek. She is a credit to the legal profession. Therefore I gladly endorse Nancy Cavey."

View All Endorsements
Donald Carl Anderson Jr. headshot
Donald Anderson

Employee benefits lawyer

Dondi R. Vesprini headshot
Dondi Vesprini

Motorcycle accident lawyer

Marcus Allen Castillo headshot
Marcus Castillo

Employment and labor lawyer

Lawrence J. Buckfire headshot
Lawrence Buckfire

Personal injury lawyer

Barbara J Gislason headshot
Barbara Gislason

Personal injury lawyer

Benjamin Weaver Glass III headshot
Benjamin Glass

Car accident lawyer

John Bisnar headshot
John Bisnar

Personal injury lawyer

Brent Adams headshot
Brent Adams

Personal injury lawyer

Charles Nicholas Internicola headshot
Charles Internicola

Litigation lawyer

Daniel J. O'Brien headshot
Daniel O'Brien

Personal injury lawyer

Jeffrey H. Rasansky headshot
Jeffrey Rasansky

Personal injury lawyer

Timothy Justin Young headshot
Timothy Young

Personal injury lawyer

James Russell Brown headshot
James Brown

Chapter 7 bankruptcy lawyer

Daniel L. Buckfire headshot
Daniel Buckfire

Personal injury lawyer

Stuart A. Carpey headshot
Stuart Carpey

Personal injury lawyer

Brian Augustus Beckcom headshot
Brian Beckcom

Personal injury lawyer

Vuk Vujasinovic headshot
Vuk Vujasinovic

Personal injury lawyer

L. Ty Wilson headshot
L. Ty Wilson

Car accident lawyer

James Robert Parrish headshot
James Parrish

Personal injury lawyer

Ross A. Jurewitz headshot
Ross Jurewitz

Personal injury lawyer

Experience

Rating:  9.7 (Superb)

Honors

2014

AV Preeminent 5.0 out of 5 Peer Review Rated, Martindale-Hubbell

2010

AV Rated, Martindale-Hubbell

2009

AV Rated, Martindale-Hubbell

2007

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

Work Experience

1984 - Present

Attorney, Law Offices of Nancy L. Cavey

1982 - 1984

Attorney, Law Office of Earlie Thompson

1980 - 1982

Attorney, Florida Department of Labor: Office of General Counsel

Associations

1984 - Present

St. Petersburg Bar Association

Member

1980 - Present

Florida Bar Association

Member

1980 - Present

Florida Bar, Workers' Compensation Law Section

Member

Workers Compensation section of the Florida Bar

Chair

American Association for Justice

Member

1990 - 2007

Florida Workers Compensation Rules and Procedures Committee

Member

1990 - 2007

Florida Bar, Workers' Compensation Law Section

Executive Council

Education

1980

William Mitchell College of Law

JD - Juris Doctor

N/A

Hamline University

BA - Bachelor of Arts

Speaking Engagements

N/A

Workers Compensation Conference

Workers Compensation

N/A

ERISA Esquire Meeting

Long Term Disability & ERISA

Publications

2009

News and Four-Fourty Report Workers Compensation Mediation

Languages

English

Activity

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution