Top Rated Setauket, NY Personal Injury Lawyers

48 personal injury lawyers serve Setauket, NY. Compare the best based on 98+ reviews and detailed profiles. Related practice areas and nearby towns in Suffolk County are listed below.

Sort by:

Best Match

Best MatchBest reviewed on Avvo Most reviewed on Avvo Years licensed: Most to least Years licensed: Least to most

Setauket Has 48 Personal Injury Attorneys with 98 Reviews

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (East Setauket)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 53 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Probate, Real Estate and more

Review: "Handled 2 personal injury and damage suits with excellent professionalism. Highly recommended. Also used his assistance for refferencial consultations. Excellent client confidentiality. Many thanks."

Rating: 6.5

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Islandia)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 41 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Health Care, Defective and Dangerous Products

View Profile

Personal Injury Lawyers in Setauket, NY

Personal injury attorneys represent clients harmed by others’ negligence—car crashes, slips and falls, dangerous properties, or defective products. They investigate accidents, gather evidence, calculate damages, negotiate with insurers, file claims or lawsuits, and litigate to obtain compensation for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future care.

The Avvo Rating explained

Let us know
how we're doing!

We'd like to hear from you!

This anonymous survey will take no more than 1–2 minutes to complete.

Your feedback will be used to improve Avvo and provide better support to people with legal needs like yours.

START THE SURVEY

Personal Injury

The Avvo Rating explained

PRO

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 41 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Car Accidents, Lawsuits & Disputes and more

Thorough preparation of your accident case, compassion. We want to help you get through this.

Rating: 9.1

Save

Call for a FREE consultation(631) 250-5456

Profile

Message

Matthew A. Glassman's Website

PRO

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson station)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 23 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Workers Compensation, Litigation

Hurt at work? We can help! Call us for a free consultation.

Rating: 10

Save

Call for a FREE consultation(516) 744-5833

Profile

Chat

Message

Heather Nicolle Kaplan's Website

Killian, Legakis & Vetere LLP
60 Route 25A, Setauket, NY

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 44 years

Practice Areas: Business, Landlord or Tenant, Personal Injury and more

View Profile

PRO

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Saint James)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 38 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Criminal Defense, Car Accidents and more

Myself and my partners have over 8 decades of experience handling injury, divorce and criminal cases

Rating: 9.2

Save

Call for a FREE consultation(631) 894-9038

Profile

Message

Frank M. Maffei's Website

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson Station)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 44 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Car Accidents, Slip and Fall Accident and more

Bio: Since 1987, I have been representing car accident, slip and fall, and general personal injury clients throughout Nassau and Suffolk county. I take pride in achieving the maximum results for my clients while leaving them 100% satisfied with the out...

Rating: 9.0

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Nissequogue)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 44 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Litigation, Consumer Protection and more

Bio: I have been a trial lawyer since 1981. I received my law degree from Southern Methodist University in 1980, after studying at Harvard (AB 1974) and Caltech. I am licensed to practice law in Texas and New York. I am admitted to practice before all ...

Rating: 7.3

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson Station)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 12 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury

Review: "Jason is very thorough and always well-prepared. He is personable and helped make my experience as smooth as possible while I was going through a traumatic personal injury case. I would highly recommend Jason! "

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson Station)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 32 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Elder Law, Family

Review: "Janet helped me through a very difficult divorce. She was responsive and supportive. She got the job done. Highly recommended."

Rating: 6.7

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson Station)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 45 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Medical Malpractice

Bio: I was born in the Bronx and grew up in Queens. I graduated from Great Neck North Sr. High School. I began working at a firm whose practice was limited to medical malpractice cases when I was still in Law School and remained there for many years, m...

Rating: 9.8

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (East Setauket)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 33 years

Practice Areas: Marriage and Prenuptials, Real Estate, Personal Injury

Review: "June was detail oriented, responsive, patient through all of our questions, and very knowledgeable in successfully navigating us through our first home buying process. I would recommend her without hesitation. "

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 47 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Criminal Defense, Real Estate and more

Bio: After graduating from Boston University Law School in 1976, Mr. Kaufman began his career with the prestigious Boston law firm Gaston, Snow Ely Bartlett, assisting in large-scale civil litigations. As trial counsel for the Massachusetts Defenders C...

Rating: 7.8

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Port Jefferson Station)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 43 years

Practice Areas: Marriage and Prenuptials, Business, Real Estate and more

Review: "Mr. whitman helped my young adult son through bankruptcy,he gave us all the information,costs,fees upfront."

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Mount Sinai)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 24 years

Practice Areas: Criminal Defense, General Practice, Military Law and more

Review: "I highly recommend Raymond Negron as a attorney. He is very passionate about what he does. He is always accessible and you never feel rushed off the phone. He handled my case as if it was his own. Thank you for all your help. "

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Coram)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 33 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Selden)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 29 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Health Care, Medical Malpractice

Review: "I retained Ms Shindel on multiple occasions ranging from contractual issues to Medical Malpractice. She was able to adapt to all of the unexpected hurtles and challenges that faced us. She is extremely honest and focuses on fact, rather than postu..."

Rating: 6.7

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Miller Place)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 35 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Residential, Real Estate and more

Bio: Davies At Law * Timothy R. Davies, Esq. * Timothy R. Davies, Davies At Law is the culmination of many years of legal services proudly practicing within the Long Island, New York legal landscape. Over thirty-three years ago in 1991 Davies, Elston, ...

Rating: 6.8

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Stony Brook)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 29 years

Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Real Estate, Entertainment and more

Rating: 7.4

Save

View Profile

Personal Injury Attorney near Setauket (Miller Place)

Personal Injury Lawyer Licensed for 38 years

Practice Areas: Family, Personal Injury, Divorce and Separation

View Profile

Babylon Bellmore Central Islip East Meadow Huntington Station Lindenhurst Massapequa Merrick Patchogue Ronkonkoma Smithtown West Babylon

See Suffolk County >

See all cities in New York >

Insurance Workers Compensation Medical Malpractice Car Accident Slip and Fall Accident

See all practice areas

Additional Resources

Additional User Resources

Below, we’ve provided users with navigation to related Personal Injury as well as common support documents.

Personal Injury Legal Questions and Information Ask a lawyer FAQ Are my messages private and secure? What is the Avvo Rating? What are reviews?

Resources for Attorneys and Law Firms

Are you or your law firm looking for new opportunities to grow? Are you looking to take control of your profiles on Avvo to ensure your data is accurate and enable users to reach you? Take a look at the resources below to get started.

How to grow your law practice with Avvo? How do I edit my claimed profile? How can I increase my Avvo rating? How do I edit my unclaimed profile?

Transparency and Trust: Understanding our Data and Reviews

We want to make sure our users have confidence in Avvo’s reviews and ratings, as well as the information we provide and moderate. Data provided on Setauket’s Personal Injury lawyers has been sourced from the lawyers themselves as well as publicly available directories such as the State Bar of New York. Lawyers who verify themselves are able to claim their profiles and provide additional information. They can also provide additional data on their practice areas and other messaging related to their practice. No content provided by Avvo on this directory page is generated by AI.

All reviews have been submitted by individuals that create an account on Avvo.com. The quality and accuracy of these reviews is paramount to Avvo, which is why we maintain internal policies and protocols. Reviews are never removed without manual review by our customer success team. Lawyers are unable to remove or modify reviews on their own.

Do you have an idea of how to make this page better or have you spotted something incorrect? Contact our support team today.

Attorney Insights

The following lists have been provided to help inform. Use the sort link that follows each list to see all results formatted in the same manner.

Licensed the longest 10

Newest to the area 10

Most Reviewed 10

Best Reviewed 10

Which Personal Injury lawyers have been licensed the longest in Setauket, NY?

John C. Digiovanna 56 years licensed
Richard Alan Zinn 54 years licensed
Wolfgang Alexander Melbardis 53 years licensed
Craig Arthur Purcell 52 years licensed
Edward Joseph Dinunzio 51 years licensed
Alan Scott Lutzer 51 years licensed
Richard J. Kaufman 47 years licensed
Patrick John Morganelli 47 years licensed
David Samuel Pollack 45 years licensed
Douglas L. Pintauro 45 years licensed

Sort lawyers by Most Years Licensed

Which Setauket, NY Personal Injury lawyers are newest to the area?

Jacqueline Nicole Rizzardi 8 years licensed
Jon Loukis Raimondo 8 years licensed
Christopher Michael Becker 9 years licensed
Jason William Hake 12 years licensed
Lisa Jeanne Borsella 19 years licensed
Yasmin Desiree Soto 22 years licensed
Kevin Ryan Glynn 23 years licensed
Heather Nicolle Kaplan 23 years licensed
Raymond Dennis Negron 24 years licensed
Daniel Lloyd Adams 27 years licensed

Sort lawyers by Most Recently Licensed

Who are the most reviewed Personal Injury lawyers in Setauket, NY?

Sort lawyers by Most Reviewed

Who are the best reviewed Personal Injury lawyers in Setauket, NY?

Sort lawyers by Best Reviewed

Setauket, NY Personal Injury Lawyers

Setauket Has 48 Personal Injury Attorneys with 98 Reviews

Wolfgang Alexander Melbardis