Free Consultation
$0 first 30 minutes
PRO
Mary Frances Higdon
Virtual Consultation Available
Free Consultation
About Mary
Biography
Ms. Higdon is licensed to practice law in both Illinois and Indiana. She has a passion for, and experience primarily in Criminal Law, and also handles juvenile cases, DCFS issues, IU disciplinary issues, orders of protection, basic estate planning, and traffic matters.
Her legal experience includes work as a Public Defender in Southern Illinois, an Associate with Youngcourt Law, and Deputy Prosecutor in Monroe County, Indiana. Ms. Higdon opened her own law office in 2011.
Quality representation you can truly trust. Former Dep. Prosecutor, I know the criminal system.
Practice Areas
6
Practice Areas
Criminal Defense
40%
20 years
DUI and DWI
30%
Ethics and Professional Responsibility
20%
Expungement
5%
Fees and Rates
Cost
Retainer
Sometimes
Payment Methods
- Cash
- Check
- Credit Card
Awards
2019 2018 2017
...
+
4
Licenses
Licensed in Indiana for 16 years
State: Indiana
Acquired: 2009
No misconduct found
Licensed in Illinois for 19 years
State: Illinois
Acquired: 2006
No misconduct found
Location
Online Presence
Other places you can find Mary online.
Mary Frances Higdon's Reviews
Avvo Review Score
80 Client Reviews
Filter Avvo Reviews (80)
Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.
Practice Areas
What Clients Mention
Case Results (41)
Advocacy (32)
Responsiveness (25)
Professionalism (24)
Recommendation (23)
Practice Area Knowledge (18)
Communication Style (17)
General Knowledge (17)
Compassion (11)
Character & Conduct (10)
Trustworthiness (8)
Cost of Services (6)
Punctuality (3)
Staff & Support (2)
Free Consultations (1)
Showing 1 - 5 of 9 reviews | Lawsuits & Disputes
Posted by anonymous | February 11, 2026 | Lawsuits & Disputes
Cares for your wellbeing and supportive
I cannot recommend Attorney Mary Frances Higdon highly enough. Facing legal issues is incredibly stressful, but Mary provided a level of service that truly went above and beyond my expectations. Not only did she provide expert guidance and go out of her way to help me navigate my situation, but she a...
Mary Higdon
Replied last February 12, 2026Thank you so much for taking the time to write this. I am happy I was able to assist! -Mary
Posted by anonymous | September 05, 2025 | Hired Attorney | Lawsuits & Disputes
Responsible, professional, reliable, quick responses, empathetic.
Mary is the best lawyer I’ve met in town! I’ve consulted and worked with multiple lawyers in Bloomington, Mary was the best. She is extremely professional, responsible, reliable and trust worthy. She responds to email and calls very timely, and she is very empathetic and thoughtful as well. I truly a...
Mary Higdon
Replied last September 09, 2025Thank-you so much for taking the time to share this!
Posted by anonymous | January 21, 2024 | Hired Attorney | Lawsuits & Disputes
Fantastic to work with
We worked with Ms Higdon for a case for my son. From the very first meeting she was very empathetic and very easy to approach. She met us and within seconds she was already guiding us. Since he had health issues it was a very delicate case to handle. But she was able to get it to our favor. She ...
Posted by RJ | March 17, 2019 | Hired Attorney | Lawsuits & Disputes
Resolution of Issue
Ms Higdon was expectional in her follow through and client service to resolve the issue amicably.
Posted by anonymous | April 23, 2018 | Hired Attorney | Lawsuits & Disputes
An absolutely amazing attorney. A rare gem.
Mary protected me from an unfair and skewed justice system. She went above and beyond in every aspect of the case. She also was a guiding force in ensuring that I didn't do anything to jeopardize my case; she did this by being so emotionally intelligent and in-tune with the anxiety and stress I was...
Mary Frances Higdon's Lawyer Endorsements
"I endorse this lawyer. Mary and I represented a man who we felt strongly was wrongfully accused of a serious crime. We were able to obtain an acquittal. Mary worked tirelessly to make sure justice was done and left no stone unturned. She will do everything she can to help you and I recommend her."
"I endorse this lawyer. Mary is very competent and hard working. You can tell her concern for her clients' best interests is sincere."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"I endorse this lawyer. Mary Higdon has it all. She has been both a former prosecutor and a pubic defender. To know both sides of the equation is a huge advantage and her clients will surely benefit. If you are in or near Bloomington don't pass up the opportunity to consult with her."
"Ms. Higdon's knowledge of law and reputation in the legal community is second to none. She always has her clients' best interests in mind. I would highly recommend her to anyone in need of legal advice."
"I highly endorse this lawyer. Our firm had an urgent and immediate need to find co-counsel on a criminal case in Bloomington, IN. Mary came highly recommended, and we are so grateful we found her. She was diligent, well-connected and extraordinarily knowledgeable about criminal laws in Indiana. She is highly rated on AVVO for a reason, and we are happy to strongly endorse her."
"Ms. Higdon is a well-respected Criminal Defense / DUI / DWI attorney. I would highly recommend her to anyone seeking a lawyer who truly cares about protecting the rights of clients and getting them the most favorable result possible. Ms. Higdon is a terrific lawyer. I endorse Ms. Higdon to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and experienced lawyer."
"I endorse this lawyer without reservation. I worked as a defense attorney opposite Ms. Higdon on many cases when she was serving as a Deputy Prosecutor in Monroe County. She impressed me on many levels. She always exhibited a strong sense of ethics, fairness, intellect, and compassion. She knew the facts and the laws pertaining to every case for which she was responsible and always maintained the highest professional standards in dealing with the bench and fellow bar members."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"Mary is a very competent and capable attorney, and I greatly endorse her."
"I've decided to endorse Ms. Higdon for many reasons. One of the main reasons; however, is because she is always looking out for her clients and colleagues. Our profession could use more attorneys like Ms. Higdon."
"Mary is a true professional. I never hesitate to refer cases to her. I know that she will handle each referral with integrity, respect and courtesy that all clients deserve. She has the knowledge, experience, and drive that it takes to win."
Stacy Uliana
Criminal defense lawyer
Katharine Liell
Criminal defense lawyer
Jacob Moore
Criminal defense lawyer
Daniel Geherin
Criminal defense lawyer
Patrick Earl
Criminal defense lawyer
Andrew Leone
Criminal defense lawyer
Steven Zachary
Criminal defense lawyer
Leneigha Downs
Criminal defense lawyer
Guy Haskell
Criminal defense lawyer
Andrew Achey
Criminal defense lawyer
Adam Kruse
Personal injury lawyer
Matthew Moushon
Personal injury lawyer
Timothy Morris
Government lawyer
Nathaniel Strickler
Litigation lawyer
Kerrie Laytin
Appeals lawyer
Michael Scarton
Unknown lawyer
Experience
Honors
2005
Public Interest Award, Southern Illinois University
2004
Scholarship, Equal Justice Works
Work Experience
2011 - Present
Owner, Higdon Law
2010 - 2011
Deputy Prosecutor, Monroe County Prosecutor's Office
2008 - 2010
Associate Attorney, Youngcourt Law
2006 - 2008
Deputy Public Defender, Jackson Co. Public Defender's Ofc
2005 - 2006
Legal Intern, Elder Law Clinic
2003 - 2004
Legal Intern, Jackson County Public Defender's Office
1999 - 2003
Bureau Chief - Victim's Assistance, Maricopa Country Attorney's Ofc
Associations
2016 - Present
Bloomington Chamber of CommerceMember
2014 - Present
Indiana University Alumni AssociationMember
2011 - Present
Indiana Public Defender CouncilMember
2011 - Present
National Association of Criminal Defense LawyersMember
2011 - Present
Monroe County Bar AssociationBoard Member
2009 - Present
Indiana State Bar AssociationMember
2006 - Present
American Bar AssociationMember
2001 - Present
Honor Society of Phi Kappa PhiMember
2001 - Present
Honor Society of Pi Alpha AlphaMember
2004 - 2005
Equal Justice WorksPresident
Sample of Legal Cases
St. v. Jay
A felony Dismissed, Plea to D felony possession of controlled substance
St. v. Beasley
C Felony battery reduced to misdemeanor.
St. v. Eicle
C Felony battery; case dismissed.
St. v. Deckard
B Felony Burglary & D Felony Theft Dismissed
St. v. Olmsted
B Drug felony reduced to D felony, misdemeanor upon successful completion of 3 mos. house arrest
St. v. Atanus
Dismissed
St. v. Clancy
Two B Felony Rape Charges Dismissed
St. v. Dugan
B Felony - Dismissed
St. v. Wagler
D felony charge - Dismissed
St. v. Deckard
B Felony Charge, Plea to B Misdemeanor
St. v. Sterkel
D felony charge - Dismissed
St. v. Jones
A felony Charge, Dismissed
St. v. Todd
A felony charge - Dismissed
St. v. Enlow
B felony charge - Dismissed
Education
2006
Southern Illinois University School of Law
Juris Doctorate
2001
Arizona State University
Masters
1994
Indiana University-Bloomington
Bachelors
Speaking Engagements
2022
Monroe County Bar Association
Monroe County Bar Association Annual Board Meeting - Participant / Attendee
Languages
English
Activity
Legal Answers
Legal Answers
Q&A
How can I show in court that the police lied on there testimonies that are on my discovery.
15 Mar 2025
Q&A
What does exclusion of confidential information mean?
22 Feb 2023
Q&A
I want to know whether or not I should be worried about the prosecutor taking the case?
06 Feb 2023