Erika M. Smitherman

Erika M. Smitherman

3.9
Rating: 9.4

Licensed for 25 years

Family Lawyer at Columbus, OH
Practice Areas: Family, Child Custody, Divorce & Separation

471 East Broad Street, Suite 1800, Columbus, OH

About Erika

Biography

Practice Areas

Fees and Rates

Cost

Hourly Rates

$ 200-450 per hour


Payment Methods

  • Cash
  • Check
  • Credit Card

Looking for an attorney? Avvo can help.

search module image

Search our directory

Quickly connect with top attorneys through our legal directory to get help with your legal issue.

chat module image

Avvo's live chat agents can help coordinate a consultation with a local attorney.

Chat with a live agent who can match you with the right attorney for your legal needs.

Chat with

Licenses

Licensed in Ohio for 25 years

State: Ohio

Acquired: 2000

Active

No misconduct found

Location

Smitherman Law Group, LLC

471 East Broad Street, Suite 1800, Columbus, OH, 43215

Ad

Transform legal challenges into solutions.

Connect now to review your situation.

The Avvo Rating explained

display-bg

The Avvo Rating explained

Erika M. Smitherman's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

3.9 /5.0

14 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (14) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 1 - 4 of 4 reviews | General Knowledge

Posted by anonymous | December 19, 2025 | Hired Attorney | Divorce & Separation

Unless you're wealthy, RUN from them

If you do not have the funds to pay for every single phone call, email, or question you have and not get answers to any of them, DO NOT HIRE this so-called family lawyer. I was supposedly given a "friend discount" for my retainer due to a different attorney I trust and used the only other times I've ...needed legal guidance. I only spoke to Erika 1 time outside of the consultations I paid ($300 each totaling $600) and the second one I only talked to her for 5 minutes or so. I just had my first hearing on Wednesday, and my husband's attorney got everything he asked for and everything Erika asked for was denied. She and her paralegal are now asking for more money despite me having to stay in the same place with my husband despite her basically telling me I'd have exclusive rights being my husband has triggered many trauma issues that have made me suicidal and other things that I had worked so hard to get over. I was close to firing her months ago because I wasn't receiving answers to my emails and phone calls. Kellee, the paralegal, emailed me back every 4 to 10 emails or so and they'd include a bill. I wish I was even slightly exaggerating, but I'm not! THEN... during the trial, Erika wasn't able to answer some of the most important things that I had reached out to her about - the proposal my husband sent me, asking for mediators (I have asked my husband for this since the first year we were married!!), but... I thought I don't want to ruin our relationship, so I better not fire her yet. Other than marrying my husband, hiring her and not going with my gut to fire her, are THE WORST MISTAKES I'VE MADE in my 50 years on this planet!

Posted by Andrea | May 25, 2017 | Hired Attorney | Lawsuits & Disputes

She was stellar!

I couldn't have asked for a better experience. She was kind, professional, and very knowledgeable of the law. I wanted my case dismissed due to lack of jurisdiction and that's exactly what happened. She was absolutely stellar. I wouldn't hesitate a minute using her again. She is compassionate A...ND competent...two qualities rarely seen together. What more can I say.... she is a total class act and came through for me. I will ways be grateful for her defense.

Posted by Ed | March 19, 2017 | Hired Attorney | Divorce & Separation

Wonderful lawyer and a great person

Erika helped me navigate through my recent dissolution. Her confident, knowledgeable and compassionate approach helped relieve my anxiety about the process. She and her team made the process quick and painless. I didn't even have to go to the courthouse to complete the process. I would highly rec...ommend Erika and her team to everyone going through a divorce/dissolution.

Posted by William and Angela | December 31, 2013

Excellent Quality!

We were referred to Attorney Smitherman by a friend who used her services in the past. Attorney Smitherman was very honest and upfront from the very beginning. She advised us exactly what to do and what to expect during the proceedings. Everything turned out great in the end. What a wonderful exp...erience to have an attorney who actually has knowledge of the system and cares about what happens.

See All Client Reviews

Erika M. Smitherman's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse Erika
Rainer Erich Steinhoff headshot
Rainer Steinhoff

Family lawyer | Sep 25

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Ms. Smitherman is a knowledgeable and caring attorney."

Thomas Mark McCash headshot
Thomas McCash

Divorce and separation lawyer | Dec 15

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I've had the opportunity to work with Erika on two matters, one as opposing counsel and one as a Guardian ad Litem. She's willing to work toward amicable resolution of cases without the need for protracted litigation or discovery demands to be cost effective for her clients. At the same time, she's more than capable of fighting hard for her clients when the need arises. It was a pleasure working with her in finding workable and effective results for both our clients and their young children."

Christopher Lewis Trolinger headshot
Christopher Trolinger

Family lawyer | Sep 01

Relationship: Co-worker

"Erika provides her clients with dedicated, sophisticated, and compassionate legal representation. Her extensive experience in the courtroom makes her an asset to her clients."

Charles Christopher Alley headshot
Charles Alley

Family lawyer | Mar 14

Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter

"I endorse this lawyer. Recently, I had the pleasure of working with Erika on a child custody matter. Our clients had numerous issues which required extensive communications between Erika and I. Erika is professional, courteous and thorough. While being easy to work with, she is a very strong advocate for her clients. I have great respect for both her extensive knowledge of the law and her abilities as a quality attorney."

Matthew Robert Langhals headshot
Matthew Langhals

Divorce and separation lawyer | Mar 10

Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter

"Erika and I worked on a dissolution over the last several months. Erika was kind, professional and a pleasure to work with. She was knowledgeable on the law and also utilized a great deal of common sense. Common sense seems to be less and less common these days, so it was certainly nice to work with someone of Erika's character."

Holly Patricia Regoli headshot
Holly Regoli

Family lawyer | Dec 30

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Erica is knowledgeable in the area of family law and always diligent in her representation of clients,"

Blythe Melissa Bethel headshot
Blythe Bethel

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 11

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I endorse this lawyer. Erika is extremely diligent and tireless in her approach to her cases. She is very knowledgeable about the law, and has an excellent working relationship with Court personnel."

Michelle Jeanette Askins headshot
Michelle Askins

Family lawyer | Nov 11

Relationship: Co-worker

"Attorney Smitherman is an excellent lawyer who takes the time to really learn and understand what her client's goals are in each case. She never makes promises she cannot keep, and is always 100% honest about what her clients should expect throughout the litigation process."

Ryan Michael Shafer headshot
Ryan Shafer

Divorce and separation lawyer | Nov 11

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"Erika is a dedicated and experienced domestic lawyer who understands the complex legal issues in domestic cases. She is constantly fighting for favorable results for her clients in the most professional manner. I am proud to endorse Erika Smitherman"

Brian David Joslyn headshot
Brian Joslyn

Family lawyer | Nov 11

Relationship: Worked for lawyer

"Erika is truly an amazing attorney. Erika clearly knows anything and everything there is to know about family law. But the most important trait of Erika is that she truly cares about her clients. She is a true advocate that fights for every inch inside and outside of the court room. It's it very frustrating seeing other lawyers that just don't care about their clients or their needs. With Erika I know she cares about her clients and their legal issues. Besides the legal knowledge she possess, her care and concern for clients is what separates her from other family law attorneys."

Benjamin Rees Nyhan headshot
Benjamin Nyhan

Family lawyer | Nov 10

Relationship: Co-worker

"I endorse Erika for any family law related matter. Erika has a proven track record of successfully representing her clients from the beginning stages of a divorce and/or custody matter all the way through trial. She provides excellent representation to her clients."

Ronald Roman Petroff headshot
Ronald Petroff

Family lawyer | Nov 06

Relationship: Co-worker

"I endorse this lawyer as a diligent and fearless advocate. Attorney Smitherman is not afraid to go to trial if her reasonable offers of settlement are rejected. I would hire her for any family law case, but particularly high conflict custody cases"

View All Endorsements
Thomas Mark McCash headshot
Thomas McCash

Family lawyer

Michelle Jeanette Askins headshot
Michelle Askins

Family lawyer

Ronald Roman Petroff headshot
Ronald Petroff

Family lawyer

Benjamin Rees Nyhan headshot
Benjamin Nyhan

Family lawyer

Ryan Michael Shafer headshot
Ryan Shafer

Criminal defense lawyer

Brian David Joslyn headshot
Brian Joslyn

Criminal defense lawyer

Experience

Rating:  9.4 (Superb)

Honors

2025

Top 10 Family Law Female Attorney, Best of the Best Attorneys

2018

Alumni Outstanding Service Award, Capital University Law School

2016

AVVO Excellent Family Law Attorney, AVVO

2016

10 Best Family Law Attorneys, American Institute of Family Law Attorneys

2016

Superb Family Law Attorney, AVVO

2015

Excellence and Dedication to Her Profession, National Association of Professional Women

Work Experience

2025 - Present

Owner, Smitherman Law Group, LLC

2016 - Present

Adjunct Faculty, Capital Law School Paralegal Program

2013 - 2025

Partner, Petroff Law Offices, LLC

2011 - 2013

Of Counsel, McNair Petroff, LLC

2009 - 2011

Staff Attorney for Judge Elizabeth M. Gill, Franklin County Court Of Common Pleas, Division Of Domestic Relations & Juvenile Branch

2007 - 2009

Court Appointed Special Advocate, Franklin County Domestic & Juvenile Court

2003 - 2007

Assistant Chief Legal Counsel, Ohio Auditor of State

2000 - 2003

Assistant Attorney General, Ohio Attorney General

Associations

2017 - Present

New Albany Women's Network

Member

2014 - Present

Lawrence Negotiation Competition-Moritz College of Law at The Ohio State University

Judge for Competition

2012 - Present

Women Lawyers of Franklin County

Member

2000 - Present

Columbus Bar Association

Member

2000 - Present

Ohio State Bar Association

Member

Sample of Legal Cases

Parenting Coordination Acts As Buffer to Contentious Parents

Client maintained shared parenting, an equal time schedule and residential parent status.

Relocation Not In Child's Best Interest

Client Awarded Custody

Confidential

Full Custody for Client

Father Granted Sole Custody

Sole Custody to Father

See More Legal Cases

Education

2000

Capital University Law School

JD - Juris Doctor

1997

The Ohio State University

BA - Bachelor of Arts

Speaking Engagements

2016

Guest Lecturer

Family Law

2015

Lunch With A Lawyer

Becoming a Laywer, Local Practice as an Attorney, Family Law Issues

2015

Local Fire Departments

Pension, Division of Property Orders in a Divorce or Dissolution, and Civil Protection Orders

2015

Canal Winchester High School

Career Development as n Attorney

2014

Rotary Clubs of Central Ohio

Family Law; Divorce, Dissolution, Child Custody

Languages

English

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution