Carey Duncan Carmichael Jr.
also known as Carmichael Law, Carmichael Law, PLLC
About Carey
Biography
Carey D. Carmichael, Jr. is the owner and manager of Carmichael Law, PLLC in Lake City, Florida. As a former Assistant State Attorney, a former Assistant Attorney General, and a former Assistant Public Defender, Carey’s primary focus has been criminal law for the last two decades. Carey became board-certified by the Florida Bar as an expert in Criminal Trial Law in 2019.
Carey graduated from Mercer University in Macon, Georgia with a Bachelor of Business Administration. After college, Carey worked full-time while attending graduate school, and in 2002, Carey earned a Master of Business Administration. Carey graduated from law school in May 2006 and was admitted to the Florida Bar in September 2006. Carey accepted a position as an Assistant Public Defender in the Third Judicial Circuit in Lake City, Florida. Carey left the Office of the Public Defender in 2011 and moved to Tallahassee, Florida; accepting a position as an Assistant Attorney General. In 2012, he returned to Lake City as an Assistant State Attorney for the Third Judicial Circuit. He held this position until the end of 2017. Carey opened and managed his private practice from 2018-2022; and returned to the Office of the State Attorney from 2022-2024.
During his time as a prosecutor, Carey was directly responsible for reviewing, analyzing, and making filing decisions on over 5000 cases. Carey prosecuted every type of case imaginable, including capital felonies, fraud, DUI manslaughter, home invasion robbery, crimes against law enforcement officers, drug trafficking, crimes against children, and many more. In addition to his own caseload and work in trials, Carey was frequently called upon to supervise and train other attorneys in trial techniques, case analysis, research, and trial practice. From 2022-2024, Carey was a supervisor with the Office of the State Attorney, and was a member of its Special Prosecution Unit, focusing primarily on the prosecution of homicides, child pornography, and child sex cases. Carey returned to private practice in 2024.
Carey served as a Commissioner on the Third Circuit Judicial Nominating Commission. He was nominated by the Florida Bar and appointed by Governor Rick Scott for a three-year term beginning in 2015. In 2018, Governor Scott reappointed Carey to the Judicial Nominating Commission for an additional term, Since 2023 Carey has been a member of the Third Circuit Grievance Committee.
Bar Memberships:
Florida – 2006
United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida - 2018
Education:
Florida Coastal School of Law – 2006 – Juris Doctor
Valdosta State University – 2002 – Master of Business Administration
Mercer University – 2000 – Bachelor of Business Administration
Practice Areas
1
Practice Area
19 years | 8,000 cases
Fees and Rates
Cost
Always
Payment Methods
- Cash
- Check
- Credit Card
Looking for an attorney? Avvo can help.
Search our directory
Quickly connect with top attorneys through our legal directory to get help with your legal issue.
Avvo's live chat agents can help coordinate a consultation with a local attorney.
Chat with a live agent who can match you with the right attorney for your legal needs.
Chat withLicenses
Licensed in Florida for 19 years
State: Florida
Acquired: 2006
No misconduct found
Location
Carmichael Law, PLLC
210 NW Marion Ave., Lake City, FL, 32055
Gallery
Ad
Transform legal challenges into solutions.
Connect now to review your situation.
Carey Duncan Carmichael Jr.'s Reviews
Showing 1 - 5 of 23 client reviews from Avvo
Posted by Jamie | August 17, 2025 | Hired Attorney
Trustworthy Winner
I have known Carey Carmichael Jr. my entire life (since I was 5 years old).He has always been an honorable trustworthy person just like his parents. He is a Winner and will fight for you! His word means something bc he was raised right! If you hire him.. you will be treated the very best!! He will wo...
Posted by Richard | May 15, 2025 | Consulted Attorney
A Bonafide 5 Star
I have happily known Mr. Carey Carmichael for 10-12 years as both an attorney and a friend. At our very first meeting, one in which I was a representative of our local Sheriff’s Office and Carey was a defense attorney for our local Public Defender’s Office, he asked thoughtful questions and appea...
Carey Carmichael
Replied last May 15, 2025Thank you, sir! I appreciate you and the review!
Posted by Elizabeth | March 17, 2023 | Hired Attorney
I’m encouraged
You are getting ready to represent my son who died as a result of a drunk driver. I believe you will be representing him as the State Attorney. It is helpful to see all of the positive reviews. Liz
Posted by Morgan | February 1, 2022 | Hired Attorney
Mrs
AMAZING!! Carey is very knowledgeable and thorough with his work. Highly recommend!
Posted by Ryan | September 7, 2021 | Hired Attorney
Great Experience
Many thanks to Mr. Carmichael and his staff for representing me. Everything turned out better than expected and they were very easy to work with. 5 star experience.
Carey Carmichael
Replied last September 8, 2021Thank you sir! We appreciate you and your business! I am glad that we could get your criminal case dismissed and that you only had to pay a civil traffic infraction.
Carey Duncan Carmichael Jr.'s Lawyer Endorsements
"I worked with Mr. Carmichael as a colleague and an opponent. His vast knowledge and experience in criminal law as both a prosecutor and defender are unmatched. Mr. Carmichael is a fierce advocate for his clients and works tirelessly to protect the rights of and achieve justice for the criminally accused. Mr. Carmichael also practices with the upmost professionalism and respect. Additionally. Mr. Carmichael dedicates significant time in giving back to the local community. Top notch member of the Florida bar."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"Carey is truly one of the best attorneys I've ever met. He is a great mentor and extremely dedicated to his work and his clients. His wealth of knowledge and constant professionalism make him an invaluable asset in the courtroom."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"Carey and I have been opposite side of quite a few criminal matters. He has a great knowledge of the criminal rules and statutes and is very easy to work with. He has worked on both sides of the fence as both a defense attorney and an ASA, so he has a lot of perspective when handling a criminal case. In every case we've had together, Carey is always very professional and ethical."
"Carey is a true professional who will work diligently to represent his clients as effectively as possible."
"Carey and I worked together, and I can say his work ethic is unmatched and he is an excellent courtroom advocate. I learned a lot about practicing law from Carey Carmichael and continue to do so. He has my highest recommendation."
"I endorse this lawyer. Cary is an outstanding attorney and cares about his clients' needs."
"I have known Carey for over five (5) years. He and I have previously worked together and have also been opposing counsel. Carey is extremely personable and a pleasure to work with on cases."
"I have known Mr. Carmichael for many years. He is a top notch litigator paying special attention to every detail and leaving nothing to chance. His comprehensive knowledge of all aspects of trial law are matched by very few."
"I endorse this lawyer. Carey is like a mentor to me. I have had the pleasure of working with him since I began with the State Attorney's Office last year. He has amazing talent in the Court room and his trial skills are top notch. He is one of the best attorneys I have ever worked with as I have worked in the legal field for over 10 years before becoming a prosecutor. I am proud to call him a colleague."
"Carey Carmichael is a wonderful attorney to work with. He is intelligent, hardworking, compassionate, and ethical. He fights for his clients."
"Mr. Carmichael is a thoughtful and intelligent attorney who is always prepared for any case that he may handle. I have known Carey since our time together in law school and have thought of him as one of the better legal minds I have had the pleasure of interacting with in and outside of our profession."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"Carey's experience in the court room and in life makes him a valuable asset to anyone in need of legal assistance."
"I endorse this lawyer. I have known Carey to handle the defense and prosecution of criminal matters and have found him to be both ethical and thorough."
"Mr. Carmichael knows what he is doing and handles his cases in a very professional manner. He offers a wealth of legal knowledge to any case and is an excellent attorney. I would recommend his services to anyone seeking counsel in the North Florida area."
"Carey is an excellent attorney and has a strong knowledge of the law. I fully endorse and recommend him without hesitation."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"I endorse this lawyer."
Unknown lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Immigration lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Criminal defense lawyer
Unknown lawyer
Experience
Honors
2023
Appointment - Third Circuit Grievance Committee, Florida Bar
2019
Board Certification - Criminal Trial Law, Florida Bar
2018
Governor's Appointment, Third Circuit Judicial Nominating Commission
2015
Governor's Appointment, Third Circuit Judicial Nominating Commission
Work Experience
2015 - Present
Board Member, Third Judicial Circuit of Florida Judicial Nominating Commission
2012 - Present
Assistant State Attorney, Office Of The State Attorney, 3rd Judicial Circuit Of Florida
2011 - 2012
Assistant Attorney General, Office Of The Attorney General Of Florida
2006 - 2011
Assistant Public Defender, Office Of The Public Defender - Third Judicial Circuit of Florida
Associations
2012 - Present
Third Circuit Law Enforcement Officers AssociationMember
2007 - Present
Third Judicial Circuit Bar AssociationMember
2006 - Present
Florida BarMember
2005 - Present
Academy of Florida Trial LawyersMember
2004 - Present
Association of Trial Lawyers of AmericaMember
2003 - Present
American Bar AssocaitionMember
2007 - 2011
Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers - Third Judicial Circuit ChapterFounding Member
Sample of Legal Cases
Guilty of a lessor of simple child abuse
Not guilty at trial
Education
2006
Juris doctor
2002
Master of Business Administration
2000
Bachelor of Business Administration
1998
Associate of Arts
Speaking Engagements
2019
Criminal Trial
2018
Criminal Trial
Languages
English
Activity
Legal Answers
Legal Guides
Legal Answers
What does charge status : bond DECR mean
13 Mar 2012
What does vop advisement mean?
16 Mar 2012
What can someone face for being charged with principal to armed burglary if they have no record?
06 Mar 2012