Overall Rating
This is an aggregated review score of Avvo and Lawyers.com reviews.
This is an aggregated review score of Avvo and Lawyers.com reviews.
5.0 /5.0
50 Client Reviews
Free Consultation
$0 first 45 minutes
PRO
Michael J. Catallo
also known as Mike Catallo, Mike
Virtual Consultation Available
Free Consultation
About Michael
Biography
Michael J. Catallo is a Senior Attorney at Rella & Associates. Mr. Catallo has been practicing law for over 10 years and has earned a reputation for aggressive litigation on behalf of injured workers in New York and Federal Workers’ Compensation, New York City and New York State disability Retirement matters, and General Municipal Law 207 disability benefits. Additionally, he has successfully represented countless applicants in Social Security Administrative hearings. Mr. Catallo’s disciplined style has yielded positive results for claimants in the Workers’ Compensation arena, including six figure settlements, and favorable permanency awards. He actively pursues disability retirement, as well as 207-c and 207-a benefits on behalf of the clients he represents, including all aspects of litigation, as well as filing Article 78s and Appellate Briefs. He proudly represents the hard working people of New York, including Correction Officers, Police, Officers, Firefighters, Carpenters, DPW, truck drivers, teachers, and anyone that is injured while working. He was recognized as a “Rising Star” in the field of Workers Compensation in 2017, 2018, and 2019 for New York State Super Lawyers.
Mr. Catallo graduated from St John’s Law School in 2011 and Fairfield University with a degree in Bachelor Science in 2005.
A dedicated attorney that is with you every step of the way. Michael tailors his strategy based on the needs of your specific case.
A dedicated attorney that is with you every step of the way. Michael tailors his strategy based on the needs of your specific case.
A dedicated attorney that is with you every step of the way. Michael tailors his strategy based on the needs of your specific case.
Practice Areas
3
Practice Areas
Workers Compensation
50%
13 years | 1,000 cases
Social Security & Disability
30%
13 years | 500 cases
Personal Injury
20%
13 years
Fees and Rates
Cost
Hourly Rates
$ 100-500 per hour
Contingency
10%-10%
Pro bono
5 %
Retainer
Sometimes
Payment Methods
- Cash
- Check
Awards
2024 2022 2020
...
+
1
Licenses
Licensed in New York for 14 years
State: New York
Acquired: 2011
No misconduct found
Location
Rella & Associates
(914) 444-2707
Mobile
16 New Broadway, Sleepy Hollow, NY, 10591
rella-associates.com/the-firm/michael-catallo-esq/Gallery
Online Presence
Other places you can find Michael online.
Michael J. Catallo's Reviews
Showing 1 - 5 of 49 client reviews from Avvo
Posted by Nahomie | August 22, 2025 | Hired Attorney
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
BEST OF THE BEST!
I had the pleasure of working with Michael J. Catallo for my workers' compensation claim, and I cannot recommend him highly enough. From the moment I reached out, his team members were responsive, professional, and genuinely caring about my situation. What stood out the most was his deep knowledge...
Posted by Cristine | August 21, 2025 | Hired Attorney
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
5+ Review
If there was a higher rating scale, I would definitely give Michael Catallo the top score. He worked diligently on my case and always treated my case as a priority. I would recommend him to anyone looking for a top notch lawyer who will get the job done, while considering you as an individual, and no...
Posted by Yvette | October 2, 2024 | Hired Attorney
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
Professional
Mr Catello was very professional, easy to contact and was on top of things at all times. He made this stressful situation very easy. I would definitely recommend him and would definitely use him again if needed.
Posted by anonymous | June 15, 2024 | Hired Attorney
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
Reliable, Patient, Knowledgeable, Quick to Respond
Michael is an AMAZING attorney! I reached out to Rello and associates to consult with Michael specifically and I immediately felt confident in his ability to be reliable and knowledgeable, giving options to preserve the best interest of his clients. . Unfortunately I did not make it clear that I want...
Posted by anonymous | May 30, 2024 | Hired Attorney
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
Workers comp
Michael is professional and experienced. He will review your case and negotiate as much as needed to get you what you deserve.
Michael J. Catallo's Lawyer Endorsements
"I have had the pleasure of working alongside Mr. Catallo for many years, and can say with confidence that he is a premier force in the worlds of Workers' Compensation, Social Security Disability, and Disability Retirement law. Regardless of the complexity of your case, you should not hesitate to reach out to Mr. Catallo to advocate zealously on your behalf."
"Mr. Catallo is a hard and dedicated worker alays striving to obtain he best outcome for his clients. I highly recommend Mr. Catallo in the fields of Workers Compensation and State and City Disability Retirement. His knowledge is his field is vast and highly commendable."
"I have known Micheal for six years and we worked together the first two years that I lived in New York. Micheal is dedicated to his clients, very knowledgeable of the law, and goes above and beyond. You will not be dissatisfied if you hire Micheal Catallo. I would highly recommend him."
"Mike is a stellar attorney and an invaluable resource in the field of workers compensation. In the event a client, colleague or friend tells me they have a workers compensation issue, I refer them to Mike without hesitation. I strongly endorse this attorney."
"I endorse this lawyer. Mike Catallo is a terrific advocate for his clients. He is very knowledgeable of the Law and advocates zealously to get the best possible result!"
"Michael Catallo is a dedicated attorney who zealously represents his clients in getting the benefits they are legally entitled to. If I needed the services of a workers' compensation attorney, I would retain him without hesitation. He is a boon to the legal profession and specifically the practice area of worker's compensation. He has the highest ethics not only professionally but personally. I recommend him without any reservation."
David Tomack
Workers compensation lawyer
Elan Millhauser
Workers compensation lawyer
Heather Nappi
Personal injury lawyer
Gregory Saracino
Litigation lawyer
Joseph Buono
Criminal defense lawyer
Peter Morris
Personal injury lawyer
Emily Kahn
Estate planning lawyer
Experience
Honors
2024
Client's Choice, Martindale-Hubbell®
2023
Rising Star, New York Super Lawyers
2022
Rising Stars, New York Super Lawyers
2022
Client's Choice, Martindale-Hubbell®
2022
Rising Star, Super Lawyers
2021
Rising Stars, New York Super Lawyers
2021
Rising Star, Super Lawyers
2020
Rising Star, New York Super Lawyers
2019
Rising Star, New York Super Lawyers
2018
Rising Star, New York Super Lawyers
2017
Rising Star, New York Super Lawyers
2017
Client's Choice, Martindale-Hubbell®
2012
Certificate of Appreciation, Nassau Suffolk Law Services
Work Experience
2018 - Present
Senior Litigation Associate, Rella & Associates
2016 - 2018
Senior Associate, Bartlett LLP
2012 - 2016
Associate, Bartlett, McDonough, Bastone & Monaghan, LLP
2012 - 2012
Volunteer Attorney, Nassau Suffolk Law Services Committee, Inc.
2011 - 2012
Outside Counsel, Scott Guardino PLLC
2010 - 2010
Externship, New York Division of Human Rights
Associations
2022 - Present
Injured Workers Bar AssociationMember
2019 - Present
New Professionals Network GroupFounder/Member
2019 - Present
Westchester Bar AssociationMember
2011 - Present
St. John's Law Alumni AssociationMember
2005 - Present
Fairfield University Alumni AssociationMember
2015 - 2019
New York State Bar AssociationMember
2012 - 2018
New York State Academy of Trial LawyersMember
2011 - 2012
Nassau County Bar AssociationMember
Sample of Legal Cases
3/4 disability pension approved
3/4 Pension secured for my client
Matter of HC-14-0321 vs. New York State Retirement System
secured 3/4 disability benefit at the hearing level for client
In the Matter of Thomas Cavallo v. Thomas P. DiNaoli
performance of duty remanded back
In the Matter of Greg Loia v Thomas P DiNapoli
3/4 accidental disability remanded back to to system for further processing
Mount Vernon 207a benefits
Won 207a2 benefits at hearing level
Hc12-0305 matter of X vs retirement system
Performance of duty granted at hearing level
Matter of Town of Greenburgh
RE secured
MATTER OF New York State Corrections
82% lwec found
HC-11-0224
client received disabilty retirement
Education
2011
St John's University School of Law
JD - Juris Doctor
2005
Fairfield University
BS - Bachelor of Science
2001
Roslyn High School
High School
Speaking Engagements
2023
Current State of Disability Retirement
Workers' Compensation, Social Security and Disability Retirement
2020
Westchester Bar Association
202 Annual Bar Meeting/Gathering Attendee
2020
A Primer on disability benefits
Workers' Comp, New York State Retirement Social Security, 207-C benefits
2019
New York Police And Fire Retiree Association
9-11 disability benefits
2019
Disability Primer
Workers' Compensation and Disabilty retirement discussion
2018
PBA
Multiple Topics in Workers' Compensation
2016
Social Security Disability
A Primer on Social Security Disability
2016
PBA
207-a and 207-c benefits
2014
PBA
New York State Disability Retirement
Publications
2020
Westchester County Bar Newsletter
Updates in Workers' Compensation Law
2019
New York Police and Fire Retiree Association, Inc. Newsletter
Recent Developments in 9-11-2001 Disability Matters
2019
New York Police and Fire Retiree Association, Inc. Newsletter
Additional Developments in 9-11 Disability benefis
2019
New York Police and Fire Retiree Association, Inc. Newsletter
The interplay of Different Disability Benefits
2018
New York Police And Fire Retiree Association, inc. Newsletter
Recent Developments Regarding Accidental Disability Retirement
2011
St. John's The Forum
Writer and Editor in Chief
Languages
English
Spanish
Activity
Legal Answers
Legal Answers
Q&A
I need to get the NYSIF doctor to give me 3 dates of availability to testify? He refuses to talk to me .I have no Attorney , I
06 Apr 2020
Q&A
Ratings?
21 Feb 2020
Q&A
What does notice of proposed conciliation decision mean? And on the back of the page I saw objection notice too.
21 Feb 2020