PRO
also known as Lucy McAllister, Lucy S. McAllister
Virtual Consultation Available
Lucy S. McAllister is a seasoned criminal defense attorney with over three decades of experience and a reputation for achieving exceptional results. Her background as a Pro Tem Judge in Small Claims and Municipal Courts gives her a distinct advantage in understanding the judicial process and crafting effective legal strategies. Lucy’s commitment to her clients is unwavering, and she works tirelessly to resolve legal matters promptly and discreetly, safeguarding their lifestyles and livelihoods.
With a remarkable record of over 250 Superior Court trials, Lucy’s comprehensive experience in criminal law is unmatched. Her detailed preparation, strategic approach, and relentless advocacy make her a formidable force in the courtroom. In addition to her legal practice, Lucy has shared her knowledge as an instructor in the University of San Francisco Law School’s Summer Trial Advocacy Program and has served as a community leader on boards such as the Public Interest Clearinghouse and Los Gatos Art Commission. Whether facing a first offense or a complex legal challenge, clients benefit from Lucy’s deep experience, judicial insight, and dedication to achieving the best possible outcomes. Lucy S. McAllister is the trusted advocate you need to navigate the complexities of criminal law.
3
Practice Areas
39 years | 8,500 cases
39 years | 4,000 cases
We have not found any cost information for this lawyer
State: California
Acquired: 1988
No misconduct found
Mobile
Mobile
255 North Market Street, Suite 100, San Jose, CA, 95110
lucymcallistercriminallaw.com/Mobile
Mobile
201 Spear Street, Suite 1100, San Francisco, CA, 94105
lucymcallistercriminallaw.com/
Other places you can find Lucy online.
Showing 1 - 5 of 115 client reviews from Avvo
Posted by Nancy Huskey | January 16, 2026 | Consulted Attorney
Professional in all aspects and excellent at what they do. Highly recommend for criminal representation and to me, worth every penny!
Posted by Abigail Armstrong | January 11, 2026 | Consulted Attorney
Lucy was so helpful in providing her skillful services to handle my case. She was very hands-on and willing to answer my many questions. She was also understanding and kind to work with during the process, which was really essential for me during a difficult time.
Posted by Gabriel Allan | January 10, 2026 | Consulted Attorney
Lucy was a pleasure to work with. She takes time to explain every step of the process and checks in with her clients on a regular basis. She was very professional and kept me up to date with any new updates. Her experience and recommendations were helpful and valuable. Highly recommend!
Posted by Williams Samuel | January 8, 2026 | Consulted Attorney
Was able to consult with Lucy and she exceeded my expectation. She is very knowledgeable and puts you at ease when answering all of your questions. Would absolutely recommend her to anyone.
Posted by Saimir Prifti | January 6, 2026 | Consulted Attorney
I had a very specific situation when I needed an attorney’s consultation and help. Lucy was very knowledgeable, responsive and carrying! She really listened and helped tremendously! I so appreciate it and she’s the one I’d recommend to all my family and friends.
"I endorse this lawyer. I have worked with Lucy several times and made several appearances for her. She's a very thorough, diligent, and tough defense attorney."
"I endorse this lawyer. i have watched Lucy in court advocate for her clients. I am impressed by her courtroom presence, knowledge of the facts and legal issues, and professional demeanor."
"Lucy McAllister is a hardworking attorney who is very well respected within the criminal defense community. She is highly experienced and you are in good hands if you are one of her clients."
"Lucy McAllister is a talented, aggressive, and passionate litigator. I have referred her on family law and criminal matters and she is also skilled in helping licensed professionals defend against suspension or revocation proceedings. She maintains a current and deep comprehension of controlling legal authority and she will tirelessly research to find a solution. Whether representing someone of means or representing someone without, Lucy attacks each case with the same amount of vigor. Without reservation, I highly recommend Lucy."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"Lucy is conscientious, dedicated and smart. She advocates tirelessly for her clients and gets great results. I highly recommend her."
"I have worked with Lucy on several matters, and I've referred my clients to her for various matters. She is confident, knowledgeable, savvy, and a "straight shooter". I would not hesitate to work alongside Lucy, and will continue to refer people to her."
"Lucy is a knowledgeable and experienced attorney who takes a practical approach and gets good results. Lucy is my "go to" criminal lawyer"
"I endorse this lawyer. Lucy is passionate and tenacious about achieving the best legal outcomes for her clients, particularly in a stacked system. She is a valuable weapon for anyone accused of having committed crimes. The more serious the allegations, the greater the reasons to have Lucy on your side."
"I have worked with Lucy for almost 4 years. Lucy is a thorough and passionate advocate. She serves her clients with skill and enthusiasm. It is a pleasure to work with Lucy."
"Lucy is a fine experienced attorney."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"I endorse this lawyer."
"I wholeheartedly endorse this lawyer. A brilliant attorney, highly respected in the legal community."
Family lawyer
2022
Women in Law Awards 2022, Lawyer Monthly Magazine
2018
10 Best Attorneys, American Institute of DUI/DWI Attorneys
2017
Peer Rated, Martindale-Hubbell
2017
Certified Specialist - Criminal Law, State Bar of California
2015
Top Lawyers in California, The Legal Network
2014
Top Lawyers in California, The Legal Network
2013
Top Lawyers in California, American Lawyer Media
2013
Top Lawyers in California, The Legal Network
2004
Lawyers weekly law award, International Council of Commercial Arbitration (ICCA)
1994 - Present
President, Law Offices of Lucy S. Mccalister
2004 - 2007
Fee Arbitrator, Santa Clara County Superior Court Arbitrator
2002 - 2006
Judge Pro Tem, Small Claims Court
1995 - 1997
ESQ, Stearns law group
1995 - 1996
Summer Trial Advocacy Program, University Of San Francisco Law School
1992 - 2002
Judge Pro Tem, Municipal Court Of California
2017 - Present
Public Interest ClearinghouseBoard of Directors
2000 - Present
Los Angeles County Bar AssociationAssociate Member
1994 - Present
San Francisco County Bar AssociationAssociate Member
1990 - Present
San Mateo County Bar AssociationAssociate Member
1988 - Present
Santa Clara County Bar AssociationAssociate Member
Director
Art Commissioner
1987
JD - Juris Doctor
1984
Undergraduate
2016
2016
2016
English
Legal Answers
I have 3 questions re counter charges in a domestic violence case.
25 Aug 2014
Can a non custodial parent have rights to volunteer at child school if there are no court orders in place.
19 Aug 2014
Is mediation a mandatory?
21 Aug 2014