Skip to main content

Amy L. Menzel

Criminal defense Attorney at Neenah, WI

4.9   51 reviews
  • Licensed for 17 years
    State WI
    Acquired 2006
    Status
    Good Standing No misconduct found

We have not found any instances of professional misconduct for this lawyer.

About Amy

Learn Amy’s areas of practice.

I went to Law School so I could have a career focused on helping people.  I treat each case as though I were representing a close friend or family member. 

 After Law School, I worked as a prosecutor for 5 years and gained invaluable courtroom experience.  I particpated in approximately 30 jury trials and hundreds of other contested hearings.  I have worked hard to earn the respect of judges and other attorneys. 

 I am confident that my knowledge and legal experience will lead to a good outcome for my clients.

Awards

Client's Choice 2020,2018,2017,2016
Client's Choice
2020 2018 2017 + 1 ...

Photos and videos

Contact Amy

Hammett, Bellin & Oswald LLC
Hammett, Bellin & Oswald, LLC
3650 West Spencer Street
Appleton, WI, 54913
Hide locations

Reviews

4.9 / 5.0
  51 customer reviews
Client's Choice 2020
Client's Choice
Client's Choice is an Avvo award granted to attorneys with a significant number of client reviews over 4 stars in a given year.
Posted by Kade | April 3, 2022
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
An absolute lifesaver!
Several months ago I was slammed with a hefty speeding ticket after attempting to pass an unsafe driver on the highway. I was ordered to pay $250 and had a 6 point mark on my license, which would likely lead to even greater losses due to my insurance. Amy was a truly amazing help throughout the whole process; not only did she handle the entirety of the court processions and remove that stressor, she also managed to negotiate a total negation of the ticket as long as I took a short drivers safety class for a considerably cheaper $70 fee. Without her, I would’ve been at a complete loss, and I can’t thank her for her services enough!!
Read less
Posted by anonymous | February 15, 2022
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Easy and to the point.
Amy is amazing at what she does and is full of knowledge. The results she came out with were amazing and I am forever greatful for the work she did for me! If more than 5 stars was an option i would select it.
Posted by Matt | June 14, 2021
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Best quality you can get
15 months from start to finish. That’s what it took for my case. At first glance I don’t believe any attorney, if given the chance to look at my case would of thought it’d become an issue. I hired Amy Menzel through a recommendation of word of mouth. After the initial consultation. She gave me a outlook of possibilities. All of which ultimately would be determined by how I handled myself in this domestic case. I should add that my case began in December of 2019. Due to COVID, the pace of or lack there of almost seemed to come to a stop. The hearings were stretched out. All of a sudden everything was done over the phone or web conference. This in my opinion created a handy cap of sorts due to the D.A’s lack of familiarity with my case. It seemed as if they were going over the same issues during every new hearing. The positive information I was attempting to show them sort of got lost in the traffic jam of the court due to the pandemic. With the amount of time Attorney Menzel dedicated to my case because of the aforementioned issues. I started to view this case as if it was almost for charity considering the extreme amount of extra time it took. At no point from start to finish did attorney Menzel ever make me feel secondary. Anytime I sent a question out through email or phone. I would get a quick response. She never promised me a magic deal where all the charges I had pending would simply disappear. But that she could greatly reduce the damage. When it was all said and done I’m at the opinion that I got the absolute best deal anyone in my position could have asked for. I strongly feel that my representation from attorney Menzel exceeded all of my expectations and I would recommend her to anyone and everyone who is in need of her expertise. A++ job. She’s a very smart, classy and all around genuine lady to work with. Thank you for everything!
Read less
Response from Amy Menzel June 17, 2021
Thank you for the kind words! I am glad that everything eventually worked out.
Posted by Matt | December 21, 2020
This review is from a potential client who consulted with this attorney.
| Consulted Attorney
Highly recommended for felony pardon.
Amy Menzel from Hammett, Bellin & Oswald assisted with my felony pardon case which was granted in November 2020. I cannot thank her and her staff enough for the life-changing assistance they gave me. They made the entire process easy and kept me thoroughly prepared for the pardon advisory hearing. They are all very professional and knowledgeable. If you are in need of a law firm to assist you with filing a request for a pardon, I would highly recommend Amy Menzel at Hammett, Bellin & Oswald.
Read less
Posted by Kristin | October 20, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Creative Solutions
Attorney Menzel compassionately listened to the details of my son's case. She worked with the DA to come up with a very creative solution that worked for all parties and provided the best possible outcome for my son. I appreciate how she handled the case.
Posted by Josh | June 19, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Thank you!
Last December, I found myself in a less than ideal predicament. A place very unfamiliar to me. From day one, Attorney Menzel was first class. Putting my mind at ease and helping me every step of the way. She played out all possible scenarios, but stayed positive the entire time. If I ever had questions or concerns, she was always there to respond. Extremely professional and knowledgeable. I’m definitely happy that I was referred to Attorney Menzel and don’t believe I would’ve made it through this process without her. It’s a bit cliché to say, but it will be the best money you will ever spend! It was for me. Thank you Attorney Menzel!
Read less
Posted by Artie | May 6, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Mr.
Amy Menzel made my legal problems disappear! Before I hired Ms. Menzel, I was facing multiple charges/citations and fines related to property damage, intoxication, and disorderly conduct. Ms. Menzel was able to negotiate with the DA and I only had to pay a fine and property damages. No charges, no community service, no court appearances, nothing on my record, and I didn't even get a ticket. Ms. Menzel and her staff were extremely professional, and dealt with my problem quickly and discretely. I would highly recommend her to anyone who needs a defense attorney. The service provided was excellent, and I am very satisfied with the outcome.
Read less
Posted by anonymous | May 5, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Clear, Considerate, Fantastic Attorney
From first phone call to in office consult was quick. With a very serious criminal complaint possible, Amy explained what could happen, and where I was in the process. From there, future meetings were productive and helpful to clarify and calm nerves. In between, Amy worked tirelessly for the best possible outcome of my case. Her creative thinking changed my outlook from the worst to, "I am so thankful I hired Amy Menzel to be my attorney!"
Read less
Posted by Adam | March 11, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
A Bad Situation Turned Wonderful
Ms. Menzel was an absolute pleasure to work with. She made my wife and I feel like more than the average manila folder in the cabinet. She treated us like people and like a friend. She returned my phone call for a consult without delay and met with me about my plight the following day. Given the nature of my case, there was a lot at stake ranging from complete loss of credential and thus employment to the destruction of home life as I knew it. She listened to what I had to say, talked about the specifics as she asked questions and then developed a strategy. Amy took me from a phone call through to completion of a criminal jury trial without any loss of my civil liberties. Her attention to detail and concern for my case and well being was above reproach. During our conversations, she never withheld options or possible outcomes. Whether Amy had good news or bad, she was very forthright with the information she needed to present. Straight to the point, upfront, honest, and compassionate I would describe her as. If I were ever in need of her services again, I would absolutely return as a client of hers. I would and will recommend her to anybody I know in need of her services.
Read less
Posted by Chris | March 9, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Atty Amy Menzel
My lawyer, Amy Menzel is amazing! She essentially gave my life back to me. In what was basically an uphill battle, she was able to have my charges reduced in a timely manner. She always kept me up to speed on everything that was happening with my case, and while my situation was quite complex, she never hesitated to push on to get the results we all needed. We are grateful for Amy and her firm!
Read less
Posted by Matt | December 6, 2019
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
5/5 Would recommend!
I would strongly recommend Amy Menzel to anyone seeking the best of the best. Amy was very good at communicating me even outside of business hours with answers to any questions I may of had. She was very thorough in explaining every step of my court appearances and when explaining things she was very patient with me. From start to finish I am super pleased with her and her services. Worth every penny!
Read less
Posted by Vichai | November 29, 2019
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
BEST LAWYER OUT THERE!!
Attorney Menzel have helped me out so much and have helped me stayed out of jail from having potentially 40 years down to just 3 years worth of probation. She's a lawyer that cares for you and wants to work with you to help you out the best she can. The law firm and everyone in it was very polite and respectful towards me and I felt comfortable at all times being there. I would recommend this place to anyone who is in need of a lawyer.
Read less
Posted by Steve D. | June 6, 2019
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
I truly could not have asked for more from a lawyer!!!
I had never been accused or charged with any criminal offense, so you can probably guess that I was 100% inexperienced, concerned, nervous, and every other fitting word you can think of. I actually forgot to send my written side of the story for her to better understand, in order to give her the best possible chance to have a positive outcome from the District Attorney's office. I felt I was innocent of any wrongdoing, and that perhaps the police may have even violated some of my rights ( which I didn't know enough about the laws to accurately make a firm assertation at the time). Amy listened, understood, and contacted the DA's office. When she heard back from them, they made an offer to lower it to a city citation. She remembered that I could lose my business insurance, so she contacted them. They understood that I am not a potential threat to anyone, and dropped the charges and citation completely. She was more efficient and concise than I could have imagined!
Read less
Posted by Priscilla | November 20, 2018
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Open and honest
Amy has been great! She was always up front and open about everything pertaining to my case. When I hired her, DA Pete Hahn wanted me to sit 3 years and an additional 3 years on probation. This was absurd considering my crimes and Amy agreed and fought to show the court who I was. Amy was always available and very thorough and I appreciate her more than she probably knows.
Read less
Posted by Joshua | September 11, 2018
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Very professional
Hired Mrs. Menzel to help with a sentence modification. She was able to get the modification done in one hearing with a Judge that I didn’t feel would go in my favor. Mrs. Menzel is very professional and knows how the judges are and plans accordingly. I really wish I had hired her when I was dealing with my case back in 2015. If your looking for an attorney that will fight for you and get the best results, I would personally recommend Mrs. Menzel. Well worth the money and it’s the standard rate for any attorney and will be well spent money to have her fighting for you.
Read less
Posted by anonymous | April 12, 2018
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
oconto county case
If you want a very intelligent, detailed attorney who will fight for your rights, care for you truly like you are their family member hire attorney Menzel. She helped me through a terrible time in my life. She got me the best plea deal I could possibly get. I had a previous attorney who was competent; however, Attorney Menzel wad by far the best attorney I had an experience with. She is a former ADA for outagamie county and KNOWS how the DA thinks. You will not be disappointed. Thank you again. Overall, great experience!!
Read less
Posted by Danny | April 6, 2018
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Great Criminal defense lawyer
Amy and her staff have been nothing short of amazing in handeling my sons complex case. Their results have exceeded our expectations and the staff’s attention to detail is supurb. They are quick to respond and always curtious. I recommend Amy to anyone in need.
Posted by Zac | April 4, 2018
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Zac Wittman
We brought on Amy after a bad experience with a DA. Amy helped so much without needing to involve me too much. It was great that she had a team that was always in contact if she was not able.
Posted by anonymous | January 2, 2018
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Exceeded our Expectations
My son put himself in a bad situation and was charged with a felony. From the moment I made the initial phone call to Amy, I felt relief and knew she was going to do everything she could to help my son. She was professional, always answered our calls/emails promptly and gave great advice throughout the 5 month process. She is very knowledgeable and confident in her position and this kept us all feeling hopeful. The outcome was by far better than we ever imagined. He is now able to resume a normal life and pursue his college education. My family cannot say enough about Amy Menzel and we will definitely recommend her to anybody in need!!
Read less
Posted by Uhi | November 22, 2017
This review is from a potential client who consulted with this attorney.
| Consulted Attorney
Professional and Respectful.
It was my first time facing criminal charges and Amy helped shed some light on my situation by giving me what any sane law abiding citizen who comes in for a consultation wants, which is a reality check about the realistic outcome of my case. She is professional and approachable. She gave me the hope and the advice about what I can do at this point to achieve a better outcome given how I chose to continue with my case and the results turned out to be favorable. Highly recommend to anyone for defense attorney, legal advice, and/or initial consultation.
Read less
View less reviews

Cost

Rates
  • Retainer Sometimes
Payment methods
Cash, Check, Credit Card

Resume

AVVO RATING 9.5 (Superb)

Work Experience

  • Associate Attorney
  • Hammett, Bellin, & Oswald, LLC
  • 2012 - Present
  • Assistant District Attorney
  • Outagamie County District Attorney's Office
  • 2007 - 2012

Education

  • Marquette University Law School
  • Law
  • 2006
  • Lawrence University
  • BA - Bachelor of Arts
  • 2003

Legal Cases

  • Criminal Case
  • Misdemeanor Convictions with probation and no jail time
  • Restraining Order / Injunction
  • Injunction Dismissed

Associations

  • Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
  • 2012 - Present
  • Wisconsin Association for Justice
  • 2012 - Present

Languages Spoken

  • English

Honors and Awards

  • Top 40 under 40
  • National Trial Lawyers Association
  • 2014

Speaking Engagements

  • Adjunct Instructor
  • Criminal Law and Constitutional Law
  • N/A

Attorney endorsements

Received (11)
Given (12)
Endorse Amy
Criminal defense Attorney | Nov 26
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"I endorse this lawyer. I went to undergrad with Amy and reconnected with her when she went into private practice. She has a wealth of courtroom experience but also has an incredible ability to connect with her clients. Amy and I frequently appear together on a local radio show aimed at education with respect to the law. Amy is knowledgeable and honest and compassionate, which are ideal qualities to make her a very competent and effective lawyer."
Criminal defense Attorney | Feb 07
Relationship: Co-worker
"Amy is a great Criminal Defense Attorney. She's had experience on the other side of the table, so you know she can see both sides of a case. Amy works hard to get great results and you would be lucky to have her work on your behalf."
Litigation Attorney | Dec 21
Relationship: Co-worker
"I endorse Amy Menzel. In working with Amy over the past several years, I have seen that she is a zealous advocate for her clients who always searches for the best ways to achieve their goals. Amy is an excellent attorney and an excellent advocate for her clients' interests."
Criminal defense Attorney | Jul 14
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"Attorney Menzel is an exceptional attorney. She maintains professionalism and gives her client's outstanding legal services. I highly recommend this attorney."
Litigation Attorney | Jul 01
Relationship: Worked for lawyer
"Amy is excellent in the courtroom. She balances a strong sense of fairness with an aggressive courtroom presence. I'd highly recommend her."
Criminal defense Attorney | Feb 25
Relationship: Supervised lawyer
"Amy spent several years in the district attorney's office before going into private practice. Thus, she has specialized knowledge that many lawyers cannot and will not ever obtain. She is dedicated to achieving the best results in all her cases, whether they be criminal defense or personal injury. She is highly respected by peers and judges, and her clients can be confident that Amy will provide superior representation."
Criminal defense Attorney | Feb 12
Relationship: Supervised lawyer
"I endorse this lawyer. Attorney Menzel is a bright young star in the legal community. Her trial skills are excellent, and her communication skills with clients are even better. She is an excellent choice for any criminal case."
Criminal defense Attorney | Dec 26
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"Attorney Menzel is a fearless trial lawyer. Her poise, intelligence, and litigation skills are reflected in the work she does. Her experience as a prosecutor greatly benefits her clients. I strongly recommend attorney Menzel."
Criminal defense Attorney | Nov 25
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"Amy has the tenacity and legal expertise to get amazing outcomes for her clients. She has shown time and again her willingness to spend time with clients, getting to understand them, which in turn allows for top of the line representation. She is an excellent attorney."
Criminal defense Attorney | Sep 09
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"I endorse this lawyer. I worked with Amy for a number of years. I have watched her develop the necessary skills to advocate successfully for her clients. She is passionate about her client's cases and will work tirelessly on their behalf."
Criminal defense Attorney | Jun 25
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"Attorney Menzel work very diligently to effectively resolve cases in the manner that satisfies her clients whether that means jury trial, bench trial or a resolution short of trial. She has vast knowledge of criminal law, as she spent several years working as an assistant district attorney which makes her the perfect person to have on your case."
View more endorsements
Criminal defense
Criminal defense
Immigration
Personal injury
Car accident
Criminal defense
Criminal defense
Criminal defense
Criminal defense
Neenah Criminal defense Lawyer Amy L. Menzel
Amy L. Menzel
Criminal defense Attorney
Neenah, WI
Licensed for 17 years