Skip to main content

Robert Eugene Feagley II

Litigation Attorney at Indianapolis, IN

4.9   16 reviews
  • Licensed for 19 years
    State IN
    Acquired 2004
    Active in Good Standing No misconduct found

We have not found any instances of professional misconduct for this lawyer.

About Robert

Learn Robert’s areas of practice.

   Attorney Feagley earned a bachelor of science in political science with a minor in business administration from the University of Southern Indiana. During his undergraduate pursuit, he spent a semester studying abroad at Harlaxton College in Grantham, England. He received his Juris Doctorate from the Valparaiso University School of Law. Mr. Feagley is admitted to practice in the State of Indiana including both the State and Federal Courts. Since admission to the Bar, Mr. Feagley has served as an associate on LEE & FAIRMAN, LLP's litigation team and presently acts as the firms supervising litigation counsel.

            Attorney Feagley has practiced in litigation involving small business matters, insurance subrogation, conflict of laws, and civil appeals, however his practice primarily involves personal injury litigation including serious injuries and wrongful death claims. Mr. Feagley handles all types of injury claims including auto crashes, semi-tractor collisions, boating accidents, motorcycle collisions, slip and falls, premises liability claims, product liability claims and medical malpractice claims. Mr. Feagley has practiced in counties around the state and is willing travel to the farthest corners of the state on his clients behalf. Mr. Feagley has represented plaintiffs with virtually every manner of injuries from relatively minor soft tissue claims to severe and permanent injuries including traumatic brain injuries, burns, and death claims.

      Whether at mediation, arguing before the Court or trying your case to a jury, Bob Feagley will zealously advocate on your behalf. Mr. Feagley prides himself on his absolute candor with his clients. Attorney Feagley is forthright regarding both the strengths and weaknesses of his client’s claims, which allows them to make the most informed decision possible towards maximizing their recovery.  Mr. Feagley has over a decade of experience representing hundreds of injured clients.

     Mr. Feagley's professional affiliations have included the Evansville Bar Association, the Indiana Bar Association, the American Bar Association, the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association and the Association of Trial Lawyers of America. Since 2006, he has volunteered as an arbitrator for the Better Business Bureau Dispute Resolution Programs.

     In addition to his litigation practice, attorney Feagley is also a court approved Mediator for civil cases in the State of Indiana.  As a mediator, Mr. Feagley enjoys the opportunity to assist both of the parties and their respective attorneys to come to resolution. 

     Mr. Feagley has been selected for inclusion in Super Lawyers-Rising Stars, 2009 & 2011 Editions as published in Law and Politics by the publishers of Indianapolis Monthly. 


127 E. Michigan St.
Indianapolis, IN, 46204

Similar lawyers nearby


4.9 / 5.0
  16 customer reviews
5 Star
4 Star
3 Star
2 Star
1 Star
Posted by Rebecca | February 14, 2024
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Mr. Feagley made this process as easy as it can be. Would recommend him to anyone who needs his assistance. This was my first time every having to file a lawsuit and everything went well.
Posted by Monica | October 17, 2023
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Motorcycle injury
Bob was very easy to work with and communicated effectively. I would recommend him again. He is not only a great lawyer but family oriented as well. Thanks for your help with my case.
Posted by LeTava | January 23, 2023
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
He Was Clearly MY Attorney
B. Feagly came highly recommended by a long-time colleague whom I would count as a friend. It was immediately evident why he was recommended. Right away, Mr. Feagly gave me a realistic scope of expectation. When I wanted to push the envelope, at no time did he discourage my wishes. He laid out all the possibilities, so we could determine strategy. That allowed me to trust his guidance when needed. I most appreciated his willingness to swing hard and take calculated risks. He dug in and didn't back down. At all times he made me feel that he was on MY side. Through it all, I knew he was MY attorney and not just someone trying to find a safe middle ground that made my case go away. Would recommend.
Read less
Posted by anonymous | October 13, 2022
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Satisfied Client
Robert was professional, knowledgeable, and patient. He was upfront with me about my case, and answered any question I had. My case went to mediation. During the mediation process Robert was assertive with opposing counsel. He explained things to me in detail. Thank you Robert!
Posted by Corlis | October 2, 2022
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Personal Injury
Atty Feagley was very professional, listened to my case, and most important to me, kept me informed on my personal injury case and worked hard to achieve the best personal outcome for me. This was my first time hiring a lawyer for a personal injury case. My brother in law referred me to Atty Feagley and I’m so glad he did.
Posted by Peter Kramer | July 9, 2022
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Injury claim
Bob Feagley was excellent in getting compinsation for my injury. He stayed on my case even when I thought it was lost cause. He stayed in communication with me through out my case. Will definitely use him for any of my legal matters.
Posted by Aaron | March 24, 2022
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Excellent representation
My family was in a collision last year and my wife experienced significant injuries as a result. We had never been involved in a collision and had no idea what to expect or how to proceed. Mr. Feagley was extremely professional and took the time to break things down and explain every step of the process. He worked with the insurance companies and with our medical providers and kept us updated and informed throughout the ordeal. Mr. Feagley explained our options and was able to negotiate a settlement that far exceeded our expectations. I highly recommend this knowledgeable and competent attorney and would definitely utilize his services in the future!
Read less
Posted by Audrey | March 9, 2022
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Highly recommend
I hired Mr. Feagley to help me after my car accident. He took care of everything! He obtained all my medical records, bills, dealt with the insurance companies, and led me along the way. He made everything so easy, and checked in with me throughout the course of my medical care. I felt he genuinely wanted to help me and my family after my terrible accident. I trusted his judgment when settling with the other insurance company, and he obtained more from our settlement than I ever imagined! I would recommend him to all my friends and family. During a stressful time in my life, he was kind, calm, patient, and professional. Highly recommend!
Read less
Posted by Marcia | May 3, 2021
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Having Robert for my personal injury case was the best decision ever. He stayed in constant communication with me via email and phone calls. He kept me updated and he explained my case as a whole. Both my husband and I are very grateful for Robert!!! He got our case settled and he pushed for all that he was able to. I would recommend Robert as a great attorney!
Read less
Posted by Dyshawuan | February 5, 2021
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Handle my case with care and integrity and I was very pleased with my outcome
Posted by Janee | October 30, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Accident attorney
Rob worked very diligently on my case. As I have never been in this situation before, Rob was knowledgeable and attentive to my case and was there every step of the way to keep me informed. I felt Rob genuinely cared about getting me the best outcome and went over and beyond to meet my needs long after the case was settled. I was in great hands and I could not be more pleased with his services, I am forever grateful.
Read less
Posted by Donald | July 25, 2020
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Superior Service
Mr. Feagley handled and resolved our case with such professionalism. When presented with the facts of our case, he diligently worked with us to formulate our position and bring our case to resolution. Mr. Feagley was extremely responsive to the questions that were raised as we proceeded through our personal injury claim, providing his expertise which eased any angst that might have existed. A very personable lawyer, that I would recommend to any of my associates. Thank You Mr. Robert Feagley for a “Job Well Done!!”
Read less
Posted by Ashley | February 8, 2019
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Honest and Facts Driven
Robert (Bob), I never called him Robert, but Bob was extremely thorough about my case, the facts, what I needed to provide and the process was made comfortable by him because of his knowledge and expertise. He was always very responsive and quick, he updated me as needed, and made sure I was happy with all decisions made. My case was a long one, but he ensured me that in the end I would be happy and that is exactly what I got. I would hire him again and recommend him as well.
Read less
Posted by Marsha | July 11, 2014
Feagley Feedback
Mr. Feagley was very professional. He had no problem understanding my case/claim, even though I had worked with 3 other individuals (e.g. paralegals, etc.) at this law firm prior to him taking over the file. His instructions and info conveyed in communications to me were very clear. He worked in a timely fashion and offered suggestions for how I should/should not proceed with my claim. With his help, I was able to obtain a settlement amount higher than what was initially offered to me for my injury. I felt very comfortable working with him. He clearly demonstrated his skill on personal injury claims and handled everything in an authoritative manner.
Read less
Posted by Erika | July 3, 2014
Highly Recommend
Mr. Feagley is by far one of the best attorneys that I have hired or interviewed. He proved himself trustworthy on handling things that could have potentially become an issue for myself even after my case was settled. Intelligent, organized, and superior professionalism are just a few words to describe this attorney. The care and concern of a client is invaluable; I was never treated like I was just another case number. I have referred him and will continue to do so.
Read less
Posted by anonymous | January 29, 2024
This review is from a person who hired this attorney.
| Hired Attorney
Mr. Feagley maintained professionalism at all times and worked diligently on my behalf.
View less reviews


  • Free Consultation 120 minutes
  • Contingency 33%-40%
Payment methods
Cash, Credit Card


AVVO RATING 7.9 (Very Good)

Work Experience

  • Supervising Litigation Counsel
  • 2014 - Present
  • Arbitrator
  • Better Business Bureau
  • 2007 - 2012
  • Associate on Litigation Team
  • Lee, Cossell, Kuehn & Love, LLP
  • 2004 - 2014


  • Valparaiso University School of Law
  • Juris Doctorate
  • 2004
  • University of Southern Indiana
  • Bachelor of Science
  • 2001
  • Harlaxton College
  • N/A


  • Indiana Trial Lawyers Association
  • Member
  • 2008 - Present
  • Evansville Bar Association
  • member
  • 2004 - 2005
  • Indiana State Bar Association
  • Member
  • 2004 - 2005
  • American Bar Association
  • Member
  • 2004 - 2005
View all associations

Languages Spoken

  • English

Honors and Awards

  • Rising Star
  • Super Lawyers, Law & Politics
  • 2011
  • Named in Super Lawyers-Rising Stars Edition 2009.
  • Super Lawyers
  • 2009

Attorney endorsements

Received (5)
Given (21)
Endorse Robert
Personal injury Attorney | Jul 16
Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter
"Bob is an excellent trial lawyer and recently has added mediator to his skill set. He is thoughtful, task oriented and thorough in his preparation."
Personal injury Attorney | Jul 24
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"Mr. Feagley is a highly competent attorney dedicated to getting the best possible outcomes for his clients. I have seen him take cases that other attorneys passed on and obtain satisfactory results for his clients. I have no hesitation in recommending him to any person seeking representation for a personal injury."
Personal injury Attorney | Oct 06
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"I have known Bob since the beginning of his legal career. He is a hard-working individual who handles his cases with integrity and determination. I would recommend him to anyone who is injured and looking for representation."
Personal injury Attorney | Sep 09
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"On several occasions I have called Bob for additional insight based upon his experience and success. He has always been very well regarded and his record speaks for itself. I endorse Bob as a true professional in his field."
Litigation Attorney | Sep 08
Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community
"I endorse attorney Robert Feagley. He is exceptionally skilled in litigation. I have observed him first hand in the courtroom and he is nothing less than impressive."
Criminal defense
Personal injury
Social Security & Disability
Personal injury
Medical malpractice
Criminal defense
Divorce and separation