Joshua Marc Mastison

My experience left me without confidence in my representation. The State’s initial offer was one year of corrections suspended to one year of reporting probation, plus 60 hours of community service. I explained that I wasn’t opposed to resolving the case, but the conditions presented serious prac...tical difficulties. I work 55–60+ hours per week in an underground coal mine, rotating every two weeks between day and night shifts, and receive only one PTO day per month. That limited PTO will ultimately have to be used, at least in part, for probation reporting. Adding 60 hours of community service on top of my work and reporting obligations makes satisfactory compliance extremely challenging. I therefore asked whether we could get non-reporting probation and little or no community service. Even if we couldn’t i at least expected an attempt to negotiate, I wasn’t asking for a guarantee—I simply wanted my attorney to advocate for an arrangement I could realistically comply with. His response was essentially that this was what the State offered and they weren’t going to do non-reporting probation. When I asked if there was anything else we could do, rather than discussing alternatives or a possible counteroffer, he asked, “So you want me to set it for trial?” He then warned that if we went to trial and things didn’t go my way, I could potentially spend a year incarcerated. I understand that an attorney should explain the risks of trial. What concerned me was how quickly the conversation went from my asking whether workable terms could be negotiated to trial and potential incarceration. The conversation itself was also handled in a manner I found extremely unprofessional. He didn’t pull me aside to discuss my case privately. We were standing approximately 10–12 feet apart in an open courtroom at points discussing my criminal case, employment circumstances and potential sentence where others could hear us. I found that embarrassing and unnecessary. I also had serious concerns regarding the preparation of my defense. To my knowledge, he had not even requested the surveillance footage concerning the alleged incident. When someone’s liberty is potentially at stake, I believe it’s reasonable to expect readily identifiable evidence to at least be investigated. After having time to consider everything, I asked whether reporting probation could possibly be changed to non-reporting over time if I accepted the agreement. He then told me it was always a possibility, although not guaranteed. Ultimately, I accepted the plea agreement. I didn’t accept it because my concerns had been resolved. I accepted it because after this interaction, I had lost confidence that I would have an attorney vigorously advocating for me if I rejected the offer and proceeded to trial. I cannot speak to what was in his mind or what his intentions were. I can only describe my experience and the impression his words, tone, demeanor and handling of the situation left with me. I understand attorneys cannot guarantee outcomes and prosecutors don’t have to accept counteroffers. I wasn’t asking for guarantees. I expected private communication, meaningful discussion of my options, investigation of relevant evidence, and an attorney who would advocate for reasonable alternatives. Instead, I left the courtroom feeling pressured, unheard, embarrassed and without confidence in my own representation. When answering the judges questions to wave my rights to accept the plea i wanted to say all of this throughout. But as a father and a husband i bit the bullet so to speak,because I have a family relying on me and couldn’t stomach the thought of a trial with this individual as my representation. Based on my personal experience, I cannot recommend this attorney. Choose someone else. Or who knows maybe it was just me not worth fighting for he may do an outstanding job for you. Ive never been one to gamble but of it’s your thing This Is Your Guy!

I can’t imagine choosing him as your attorney could possibly be a mistake. He handled my entire case with little to no effort on my part. Explained everything to me until he was certain I understood. Never once made me feel ashamed for needing to seek his legal representation. Ps, I didn’t actually... meet him until day of court. I’m from out of state and had a pressing time line. Above and beyond service. Worth every penny. I’d give more stars if I could. Simply put-some are trained, some have a niche. Mr Mastison seems to have a niche!

We found Mr. Mastison through Melife Legal Plans. I called for about two weeks not realizing that only he answers the phone. I finally left a vm and he did call back same day. He seemed very reluctant to meet in person, I assured him we had been fully vaccinated and would wear a mask (thinking hi...s reluctance was due to covid) He set an appt with us for two months out. He wanted us to send our previous wills to him via email I did. We took off work the day of the appt, showed up promptly at our appointment time only to find the door locked. I checked my email to make sure he had not sent an email that morning cancelling. He had not. I called and he answered and came to the door. He told us he wouldn't meet with us. He said he sent an email (which he had not) He said he wanted to be completely honest about why he didn't want to meet with us even though he had set the appt and requested our personal information. His reasoning...he had a flat tire that morning, had to borrow a family members car and had to pick his children up later. No regard for the time and money it cost us to take off work and drive there. We don't live in the same city his practice is. He said "if" we want to reschedule it would be a month out. Keep in mind we had already waited two months. I would never do business with him, nor could I in good conscience recommend him. I am very concerned about him having all of our personal information that he requested.