Skip to main content

About me

Dedicated Indiana injury attorney


A native of Indiana, Scott Faultless spent the first 18 years of his life on a farm in Greene County. After graduating from the Indiana University School of Law, Indianapolis, in 1991, he worked as a law clerk under David W. Craig. Their shared interest in protecting and defending injured people throughout their home state eventually took them in the direction of establishing their own firm. In 1999, Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC opened its doors, giving Scott and the other Founding partners the opportunity to practice personal injury law and serve the community through both legal channels and ongoing public service campaigns.


Trial experience in the Trial Courts, Court of Appeals and the Indiana Supreme Court


In more than 20 years of practice, Scott Faultless has gained considerable litigation experience at the trial court and appellate court levels. He has been named among the Top 100 Trial Lawyers in Indiana by the National Trial Lawyers Association and also selected as an Indiana Super Lawyer. He has argued cases before the Indiana Supreme Court, the Indiana Court of Appeals and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit in Chicago. In addition, he regularly goes to court with other attorneys in the firm. Scott is in charge of the appellate practice for the personal injury law firm of Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC. He enjoys a challenge and is always willing to take difficult or novel issues on appeal in order to help his clients. He is also highly qualified to protect a favorable verdict on appeal if necessary. As with everything the firm does in service of injured parties, Scott is more than willing to appeal a case in an attempt to change or clarify laws that he believes are unjust to those who suffer because of the carelessness of others.


Bringing skill and commitment to the community


A longtime resident of the Town of Fishers, Indiana, Scott is president of the Town Council, a role in which he has proudly served since 2001. He is also a member and past president of both the Fishers Chamber of Commerce and the Fishers Rotary Club. Scott is an active youth sports coach, volunteering his time to lead his children's soccer, basketball, baseball and softball teams in Fishers.


Schedule a free consultation with an Indiana injury attorney who cares


If you have been injured, Scott A. Faultless and his colleagues can help. Call us at 800-746-0226 or contact Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC online. We have several satellite offices and meeting locations. We serve clients in Batesville, Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, Anderson, Muncie and Lafayette, Indiana and will gladly set up an appointment at a location convenient to you or in your home.


Practice areas


  1. Car Accident: 45%
    25 years
  2. Trucking Accident: 45%
    25 years
  3. Motorcycle Accident: 5%
    25 years
  4. Personal Injury: 5%
    25 years



Free consultation (120 minutes)

Attorney endorsements

5 total 

Are you an attorney? Endorse this lawyer

  • Alexander Ryan Craig

    I endorse this lawyer.


    Alexander Craig Personal injury Attorney
    Relationship: Worked for lawyer

  • David Wayne Craig

    I endorse this lawyer. Scott is one of the most knowledgable attorneys I know in insurance/ injury law. He has taken cases to the Indiana Supreme Court and changed the law. He only fights for those who are injured or who have lost a loved one due to someone else's carelessness. He champions the cause of the victims and fights insurance companies.


    David Craig Trucking accident Attorney
    Relationship: Co-worker

Contact info

Craig Kelley & Faultless LLC

5845 Lawton Loop East Drive
Indianapolis, IN, 46216-1001


INActive In Good Standing199107/03/2016
We have not found any instances of professional misconduct for this lawyer.
Avvo contributions
Legal answers
Award nameGrantorDate granted
Nation's Top One PercentNational Association of Distinguished Counsel2015
Top 10 Law FirmAmerican Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys2015
Indiana Super LawyerThomson Reuters2015
Top 100 Trial LawyersThe National Trial Lawyers2015
Top 10 Client Satisfaction AwardAmerican Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys2015
Top 10 Client Satisfaction AwardAmerican Institute of Personal Injury Attorneys2014
Sagamore of the WabashGovernor of the State of Indiana2014
Litigator Award: Top 1% of LawyersTrial Lawyers Board of Regents2014
Top 100 Trial LawyersThe National Trial Lawyers2014
Top 100 Trial LawyersThe National Trial Lawyers2013
Indiana Super LawyerThomson Reuters2012
Top 100 Trial LawyersThe National Trial Lawyers2012
Top Attorneys in IndianaIndianapolis Monthly2011
Indiana Super LawyersThomson Reuters2011
Top 100 Trial LawyersThe National Trial Lawyers2011
Work experience
TitleCompany nameDuration
AttorneyCraig Kelley & Faultless LLC1999 - Present
PresidentFishers Town Council2001 - 2013
Association namePosition nameDuration
The National Trial LawyersMember2011 - Present
Association of Plaintiff Interstate Trucking Lawyers of AmericaMember2009 - Present
Indiana State Bar AssociationMember1991 - Present
Indiana Trial Lawyers AssociationMember1991 - Present
American Association for JusticeMember1991 - Present
Publication nameTitleDate
Indiana Trial Lawyers AssociationContractual Limitation Provisions in Uninsured and Underinsured Cases2014
Indiana Trial Lawyers AssociationMotorcycle Wrecks in Indiana2014
Indiana Trial Lawyers AssociationSolving the Circular Riddle Created by “Other Insurance” Clauses2012
Indiana Trial Lawyers AssociationIndiana Code §27-7-5-2(a) Mandates Underinsured Minimum Limits of $50,000 Per Person2012
The Lawyer's Log BookProtecting Your Client’s Case (in semi or other commercial vehicle wrecks)2012
Indiana Trial Lawyers AssociationWhen is a Tortfeasor’s Vehicle Underinsured?2012
Indiana Trial Lawyers AssociationFighting the Uninsured/Underinsured Carriers’ Attempt to Hide Their Identity and Role at Trial2012
West Legal Ed CenterSecuring the Commercial Motor Vehicle and Other Steps to Acquire or Preserve Evidence After a Wreck2010
School nameMajorDegreeGraduated
Indiana University School of LawLawJD - Juris Doctor1991
Indiana UniversityN/ABA - Bachelor of Arts1988
Speaking engagements
Conference nameTitleDate
Lifetime Achievement SeminarContractual Limitation Provisions in Uninsured and Underinsured Cases2014
Indiana Trial Lawyers Association SeminarMotorcycle Wrecks in Indiana2014
Mastering the Maze of Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist CoverageSolving the Circular Riddle Created by “Other Insurance” Clauses2012
National Webcast - “Trucking Tuesdays”Securing The Commercial Motor Vehicle and Other Steps To Acquire or Preserve Evidence After a Wreck2010