Skip to main content

About me

Over more than a quarter century of law practice, Nancy has tried many cases, including jury and bench trials, arbitrations, and appeals to the appellate and supreme courts of Indiana. She has concentrated her practice on individual rights, representing both plaintiffs and defendants. She has represented numerous clients in landlord-tenant disputes, contract matters, and business and commercial litigation. In addition, she has fought for individual victims in personal injury claims, medical malpractice, and discrimination disputes.Nancy has also served as Town Attorney for Schererville, has sat on the City of Gary’s Commission on the Status of Women, and worked in the Lake County Prosecutor’s office.

Nancy is married and the proud parent of two children (including one who is a law professor at Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago). Outside the legal world, Nancy has been a volunteer for American Cancer Society, Southlake Mental Health, and Everybody Counts (an advocacy organization for the disabled). She has been named in the Who’s Who in American Colleges and Universities and is a Founder and member of the Womens’ Executives’ Council of Lake County. Nancy has also taught Business Law as Adjunct Professor at Indiana University Northwest.


Photos and videos

4025081 1327279932

4025081 1327279659

4025081 1327279466

Practice areas


  1. Divorce: 30%
    34 years
  2. Criminal Defense: 20%
    34 years
  3. DUI & DWI: 20%
    34 years
  4. Car Accident: 20%
    34 years
  5. Personal Injury: 10%
    34 years



Free consultation (30 minutes)

Payment types:

Cash, Check, Credit card

Attorney endorsements

2 total 

Are you an attorney? Endorse this lawyer

  • Michael David Babcock

    I endorse this lawyer. Very knowledgeable and fair. An asset to our local legal community.


    Michael Babcock Personal Injury Attorney
    Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

  • Julie Stephens

    I have worked with Nancy on a number of cases and she is always professional and courteous while advocating for her clients. She is well liked amongst her peers.


    Julie Stephens Child Custody Attorney
    Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter


INActive In Good Standing198101/08/2016
We have not found any instances of professional misconduct for this lawyer.
Avvo contributions
Legal answers
Award nameGrantorDate granted
Outstanding Woman in the Field of Government and Law.Congressional Record2002
Ameli Leadership AwardWomen's Exceutive Council2002
Outstanding SupportAmerican cancer SocietyN/A
Work experience
TitleCompany nameDuration
Public DefenderLake County Indiana Public Defender's Office2012 - Present
AttorneyLake County Indiana Clerks Office2010 - Present
OwnerNany Moore Tiller and Associates1981 - Present
Adjunct ProfessorIndiana University Northwest1990 - 1991
Adjunct ProfessorIvy Tech Community College1987 - 1988
IV-D AttorneyLake County Prosecutor's Office1985 - 1987
Town AttorneyTown of Schererville1983 - 1985
Association namePosition nameDuration
Indiana Public Defender CouncilMember2012 - Present
Calumet American Inn of CourtMaster1999 - 2006
Women's Executive Council of Lake CountyFounding Member1988 - Present
Everybody CountsVolunteer Attorney1988 - Present
Lake County Womens Bar AssociationMember1982 - 2000
Indiana State Bar AssociationMember1981 - Present
Lake County Bar AssociationMember1981 - Present
Legal cases
Case nameOutcome
SMITH v. SCHOOL CITY OF HOBARTThe School's Motion for Summary Judgment is DENIED and Smith's Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED. BACKGROUND
See all legal cases 
Publication nameTitleDate
EzineBetter Understanding Indiana OWI Law2011
School nameMajorDegreeGraduated
Valparaiso University School of LawLawJD - Juris Doctor1981
Indiana UniversitySociologyBA - Bachelor of Arts1977
Speaking engagements
Conference nameTitleDate
BPW Annual MeetingPolitics and Law1989