James Edward Konstanty’s Reviews

James Edward Konstanty

Average Rating

Based on 2 reviews

Help make it easier for other Avvo users to choose the right lawyer by sharing your experience with this attorney. It's fast, simple, and safe.

Review this lawyer

Lawyers: Use the Peer Endorsements section to provide input about other attorneys.


  1. Read Between the Lines, Words and Letters

    Posted by a Litigation client,
    Overall rating
     Poor
    Trustworthy
     Poor
    Responsive
     Poor
    Knowledgeable
     Poor
    Kept me informed
     Poor
    • I do not recommend James Konstanty.
    • I hired James more than 3 years ago.
    • James handled my Litigation matter.
    • I have previously worked with 1-2 lawyers.

    There are serious problems with James Konstanty in the context of his private law practice. I provide a small sample of my experiences as his client. I learned of and witnessed others’ consistent with mine.

    Mr. Konstanty ensures that settlement talks fail and cases go to trial. For him, settlement is a loss of income. He accomplishes this by widening the gap between the parties, after the other side acts in good faith in the settlement conference to narrow the gap. Mr. Konstanty understands well the economics of settlement.

    The day before trial, Konstanty threatens to show up at trial only to make a motion to withdraw unless given much additional money at that time – even when funding remains on retainer. He throws his client out of his office if his demand is not satisfied. Delaware County Bar President had to intervene to instruct Mr. Konstanty to provide legal presentation at trial the next day.

    Rather than fulfill his professional and ethical duty to advance his client’s interests in trial, Konstanty omits from evidence all exhibits that support his client’s case, and enters into evidence duplicate exhibits to support the case of his client’s adversary. This is what Mr. Konstanty means when he threatens to “undo” his client. Konstanty denies his client the opportunity in trial to testify in their own interests and puts words in his client’s mouth that undermine their own case. Worse, when examining his client’s adversary on the witness stand, he employs the technique of leading to steer this witness to claim credit for his client’s contributions. It is not for nothing that he speaks of his demons.

    The saving grace for a defendant represented by Mr. Konstanty is that if his client loses in trial because of the legal error that the plaintiff failed to sustain the burden of proof, reversal on appeal as a matter of law can reasonably be expected. Mr. Konstanty strives to bring about this legal error. He also preserves the right of his client’s adversary to appeal any potential denial of relief, to invite the other side to appeal. He thus hedges his bets. Appeals increase his revenue, whether he is petitioner or respondent.

    Appeals by Mr. Konstanty are especially costly because at the completion of trial, he threatens again to make a motion to withdraw, if not given substantially more to file a written case Summation. He states that a second payment will have to follow the first, putting the cost of representation well over double his originally stated cost. This is before getting to an appeal. Where this demand is not met and the client tells him that they will save money and file their own Summation, he replies that the client is “so wrong.”

    Mr. Konstanty actually takes his clients to Arbitration to obtain money for their efforts. He collects all documents that he received from his client and shows the collection to the Arbitrator. Konstanty is quite the buffoon. He says to the Arbitrator that he “trusts” it is unnecessary to identify details of the professional services that he would have the Arbitrator believe he rendered. Even though Konstanty loses, next he refuses to return his client’s file unless given more money. Mr. Konstanty, as if putting forth a rational explanation, told me that if he doesn’t cheat his clients, he cheats himself.

    Mr. Konstanty devotes an inordinate amount of time to pranks. Pranks obsess his mind. For example, after telling his client the day and time of a conference, he adjourns it, but waits until after the time his client would depart for it to send an email notification of the adjournment. He acts to ensure a wasted trip. He views his pranks, most benevolently characterized, as funny, a showing of prowess. He is so warped that he thinks a client's attempt to learn when a conference will be held is cause for vengeance. Konstanty's case is sad from a clinical perspective. He doesn’t want help. His part-time county job serves the purpose of apparent legitimacy.

  2. Sociopath

    Posted by a Real Estate client,
    Overall rating
     Poor
    Trustworthy
     Poor
    Responsive
     Poor
    Knowledgeable
     Poor
    Kept me informed
     Poor
    • I do not recommend James Konstanty.
    • I hired James more than 3 years ago.
    • James handled my Real Estate matter.
    • I have previously worked with 3-5 lawyers.

    What a prospective client sees on a "free" initial consultation is not what a client gets. Mr. Konstanty makes a mockery of not only his duties as a member of the legal profession but of the legal system. It is not in him to care about the rights or interests of a client.

    Mr. Konstanty does not have a command of the law sufficient to argue the law. He does not spend the time to learn the facts of a case, even though he charges many times over nonetheless. If he omits a fact, no matter how critical to advance his client's interests, he will not cure the omission because he is too ashamed to admit an omission or that he got something wrong. Instead, he goes to extraordinary lengths to make sure that a judge knows nothing about the facts that are on the side of his client. He even tells the judge false information to ensure his client's defeat, if the client does not satisfy his demands, all in violation of his retainer agreement. He makes a joke of not living up to his retainer agreement.

    This is not someone who can help you. Retain someone else.