We have not found any cost information for this lawyer
Kathie is a Criminal Trial Specialist certified by the National Board of Trial Advocacy (NBTA), a distinction that highlights her extensive courtroom experience, advanced legal knowledge, and unwavering commitment to ethical advocacy. Earning this certification requires meeting stringent qualifications, including serving as lead counsel in numerous jury trials and passing a comprehensive examination. Kathie’s board certification is a testament to her dedication to providing outstanding criminal defense representation and ensuring the best possible outcomes for her clients. Check here whether the attorney you are considering is certified.
EMBRACING THE CHAOS
Criminal defense is not neat and tidy. Successful criminal defense lawyers in Indianapolis have to embrace the chaos. For this reason, most lawyers run away from criminal defense work. Fighting for a client who is facing the loss of their freedom and reputation is extremely nerve-wracking to say the least. It is filled with complications and contradictions. It keeps you up at night. However, in spite of the chaos of criminal defense, I can’t imagine doing anything else.
My entire career has been spent exclusively defending the accused, except for a 9-month period in 2014 when I briefly ventured into other areas of law. It was a miserable 9 months, but it helped me realize a very basic fact about myself: I am a criminal defense attorney. Period.
Joining The Criminal Defense Team, with our exciting style of aggressive, creative and strategic defense and dedication to the criminally accused was a perfect fit. For those who are dedicated to criminal defense as we are, fighting for people accused of committing crimes is simply a way of life.
There was a point in my career as a Deputy Public Defender, I endured a trial gauntlet consisting of five jury trials in a row, representing five different clients accused of committing the following crimes: murder, rape, aggravated battery, attempted murder, and burglary. I was living on little sleep, lots of coffee and with the constant anguish of knowing that how well I did my job could be the difference between freedom for my clients or spending most of their lives behind bars. That was chaos, pure and simple…..and I loved it. None of the five defendants in those cases were found guilty! Somehow, I had run through the trial gauntlet unscathed. Most importantly, each of my clients had a new lease on life.
As strange as it sounds, I love the chaos of criminal defense. I grew up in the 1970s and 1980s and to say that I did not have a very typical childhood would be a vast understatement. However, I believe it is my own tumultuous childhood helped me gravitate toward criminal defense and gave me the tools, passion and skillset to give our clients the aggressive and compassionate representation we are known for providing. My parents divorced when I was young. I lived in Maine for the early part of my life before my mother moved us 3,000 miles away to the West Coast to get me out of the destructive environment that had become our lives. She was a single mother and I was her only child and we left everything we knew behind. Shortly after I finished high school, my mother passed away after a long battle with cancer and I was on my own to finish college and start my life. My relatives were scattered all over the country, including my father, who because of his addiction issues, was largely out of my life until years later when he also fought a losing battle with cancer. When a client refers to their anxiety and frustration, I can relate. I have been there. When they tell me that they are scared, angry or confused…I get it. I’ve lived it.
I have held on to a few remnants from my chaotic past. For example, I am a fervent Boston Red Sox fan because my father loved the Sox. I hold fondly the memories created with him at Fenway Park as a child. However, I learned a long time ago that dwelling on the past does not solve problems. When we are hired, we need to understand the past (the facts of our client’s case), but also focus on the future (developing a cohesive strategy that will put our client in the best position to attain the best practical outcome). Along the way, things can get hectic. Prosecutors may not see things the same way that we do. Judges may set difficult timetables and unexpected orders. Police may lie. Witnesses may exaggerate or disappear entirely. Any number of other pitfalls may arise during the course of our representation. There will be difficult decisions to make. It’s during times like these that we do our best work.
We’re not afraid of tough choices. We take on the challenge and figure out ways to succeed, sometimes when success doesn’t seem possible. Criminal defense work is not for the faint of heart. However, for those of us that can embrace the chaos and aggressively fight for their clients in spite of it, the challenge is incredibly rewarding. My own personal journey prepared me for this life. And I’m ready to put my experience to work for you.
1
Practice Area
We have not found any cost information for this lawyer
Quickly connect with top attorneys through our legal directory to get help with your legal issue.
Chat with a live agent who can match you with the right attorney for your legal needs.
Chat withState: Indiana
Acquired: 2001
No misconduct found
1060 Villa Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46203
23 South 8th Street, Suite 50, Noblesville, IN, 46060
150 North Main Street, Franklin, IN, 46131
4 Client Reviews
Showing 1 - 2 of 2 reviews | Character & Conduct
Posted by Chellarise Mendoza | May 20, 2026 | Hired Attorney
Tried to force my case to unnecessary jury trial for Money
This Attorney was extremely Money hungry after I heard them very kind of force my to a jury trial, for more money and instead of having my best interest that hard which was unnecessary because I end up getting a diversion after all in my case was the Smith very unfortunate do not hire her she does n...
Posted by Jr | May 13, 2018 | Hired Attorney
Doesn't care about your case.
She may have been good once but that time has since passed. Says she will fight for you during the consultation and go to trial if necessary. Pretty sure she's only done 1 trial in the last 1 to 1 1/2 years. Makes you believe that your case would be better off plead out. Really doesn't care about get...
No Endorsement Data Available Yet
This attorney hasn't received any attorney endorsements recently on Avvo.
No Endorsement Data Available Yet
This attorney hasn't created any attorney endorsements recently on Avvo.
N/A
First Place National Award Winner for Continuing Legal, Sagamore Inn of Courts Barrister
2016 - Present
Lawyer, The Criminal Defense Team
2001 - 2014
Deputy Public Defender, Marion County Public Defender Agency
2017 - Present
National Board of Trial AdvocacyCriminal Trial Specialist
Member, Board of Directors
Chair, Criminal Trial Specialty Commission
Treasurer
Vice President
Member
Member
Member
2001
JD - Juris Doctor
1996
BA - Bachelor of Arts
1992
A.A.