Christopher Mathew Gilley

Christopher Mathew Gilley

also known as Gilley

4.6
Rating: 7.4

Licensed for 19 years

Criminal defense Lawyer at Anderson, IN
Practice Areas: Criminal Defense, Family, DUI & DWI, Appeals

800 Main Street, Suite 212, Anderson, IN

About Christopher

Biography

Practice Areas

4

Practice Areas

Criminal Defense 45%

Christopher Gilley served as a criminal prosecutor in Hamilton County, Madison County, and Marion County for 8 years before starting his own criminal defense practice. With Offices in both Marion and Madison Counties, Gilley law has the experience and connections to best represent your interests.

22 years

45%
Family 30%

Christopher Gilley served as a criminal prosecutor in Hamilton County, Madison County, and Marion County for 8 years before starting his own criminal defense practice. With Offices in both Marion and Madison Counties, Gilley law has the experience and connections to best represent your interests.

16 years

30%
DUI and DWI 20%

Christopher Gilley served as a criminal prosecutor in Hamilton County, Madison County, and Marion County for 8 years before starting his own criminal defense practice. With Offices in both Marion and Madison Counties, Gilley law has the experience and connections to best represent your interests.

22 years

20%
Appeals 5%

Christopher Gilley served as a criminal prosecutor in Hamilton County, Madison County, and Marion County for 8 years before starting his own criminal defense practice. With Offices in both Marion and Madison Counties, Gilley law has the experience and connections to best represent your interests.

22 years

5%

Fees and Rates

Cost

Free Consultation

$0 first 60 minutes

Hourly Rates

$ 300-300 per hour


Payment Methods

  • Cash
  • Check
  • Credit Card

Looking for an attorney? Avvo can help.

search module image

Search our directory

Quickly connect with top attorneys through our legal directory to get help with your legal issue.

chat module image

Avvo's live chat agents can help coordinate a consultation with a local attorney.

Chat with a live agent who can match you with the right attorney for your legal needs.

Chat with

Licenses

Licensed in Indiana for 19 years

State: Indiana

Acquired: 2006

Active in Good Standing

No misconduct found

Location

Garrison Law Firm, LLC

800 Main Street, Suite 212, Anderson, IN, 46016

Ad

Transform legal challenges into solutions.

Connect now to review your situation.

The Avvo Rating explained

display-bg

The Avvo Rating explained

Christopher Mathew Gilley's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

4.6 /5.0

32 Client Reviews

Showing 1 - 3 of 3 reviews | 1 star

Posted by anonymous | January 28, 2026 | Hired Attorney

Terrible work

Don’t use this guy! He is often non responsive, reckless in how he practices law, and will lie every time he can to cover his take. He is trying to practice law but is mostly ineffective not to mention expensive for someone who didn’t move anything forward. He constantly made excuses up for work ...that wasn’t done but promised to be done. His staff also doesn’t send emails back because they don’t like have any paper records of their constant mistakes. Save your money! Go with a reliable attorney but not Chris G.

Posted by David | March 01, 2021 | Criminal Defense

Ineffective and incompetent

This guy called me back asked to hear my story. But only heard a total of 30 words of my story. Told me to move onto the current issue and I explained that what Indiana statute stated and controlling authorities says. He tells me good luck with that argument and Hope's I win but doubts it. His proble...m is he didn't even look into it before deciding that he wasn't gonna take the case or at the very least look into it. Most attorneys at least look into it to see if there is something there. He didn't. Other attorneys told me my issue was real but they couldn't take me on right now, that had it not been such short notice they would have helped me. Then he didn't even want to hear the rest of my story in regards to other issues that I wanted to have him help me with. His demeanor change right away when I told him the issue at hand was. Prior to that he was I don't know nicer and more willing to help. But soon as he learned what it involoved his whole attitude and demeanor changed. Just because they say they help all manner of cases isn't true. Mine involved a cop and though I took a plea it was under duress, coercion, and forced perjury. I can actually prove it, I obtained later evidence that exonerates me and shows prosecutors, counsel and police knew it. Yet the court still denied my p.c. and because I'm no attorney I couldn't prepare the appeal right and failed because of it. I also learned my arrest and confinement was never legal or constitutional, meaning my conviction was as well. Other evidence obtained further proved my conviction/plea agreement is not legally enforceable and unconstitutional. I have evidence of corruption of the police, prosecutors, co-counsel, and the judge. Evidence the clerk of the court provided who conveniently was replaced soon after. Now I learn that the public defenders office has destroyed the case file when they are not supposed to do, prosecutors done the same biased on what was said to me by them, the clerk of the court and court reporter is refusing to give me records and recordings that is supposed to be made available. There much more but this attorney didn't care to hear me out. I called and his partner actually told me I have p.c. issues but one of the issues his partner Gilley knows more of. So he wanted me to talk to him about that one issue. But as said Gilley refused to know his facts before turning me down on that issue. Then he wouldn't even continue with the other issues his partner said were legit issues. I'm a non certified paralegal with 10 years of experience going on 11. I made sure to research and have all the statutes, rules, and authorities that concur and affirm that what issues I have and don't. Attorneys are always annoyed when someone knows what they are talking about and know law and ain't even one of them. I know more about the law then this guy. I may not know all the complex language, philosophy, and histories of law. Have access to all the forms and resources he has. But I know more of the law. He's just a mouth piece. Paralegal are the ones who do the real work and actually knows more of the law than the attorneys. Attorneys do the talking and presenting. They haven't the time to do research, investigating, and preparing and litigating in court. The only thing they actually do is the actual court stuff. So normal good attorneys will hear your story and tell you they'll look into it then get back with you. He didn't he just out right ditched me. Even his partner said my issues isn't your run of the mill issue. So he didn't know, not many do. Other attorneys I talked to looked it up and found I was right. My issue is real and told me if it wasn't such short notice they would help. Because my issue really is short notice and I knew it. But they actually took the time to look it up before making a decision. Thus guy didn't and even refused to hear my other issues I wanted to hire him for. He's trash and shouldn't be an attorney if he's gonna be that way. Don't hire.

Posted by Gary | January 18, 2018 | Hired Attorney | Criminal Defense

Unhappy Client

My son hired Chris Gilley after getting arrested. I talked to Chris and was told how much I needed to pay for his services. I made arrangements for these payments. Chris told me to call anytime with questions. When I would call for updates I was always told Chris is in court. I would leave messa...ges and request callbacks. I never received a call back or receive an update on my son;s case. Finally I told the office I would not make another payment until I heard back from Chris. I then received a callback in a couple of hours. I met Chris at the courthouse and a plea agreement was reached. I believe Chris did a great job in this negotiation and was pleased with the result. I was told there would be one last hearing to accept the agreement and my son would be released before the holidays. I received a call the next day from Chris Gilley's para legal. I was informed I would have to pay two thousand more dollars or the final hearing would be delayed. I was told if the hearing was delayed my son would stay incarcerated thru the holidays and after the new year. Chris did allow me to make payments and he attended the hearing as scheduled. I believe i could have received similar or better service from a different firm without the headaches. I did not like the threat of keeping my son incarcerated as a method of forcing me to agree to pay more money. I wish someone had told me of this additional cost before it was agreed to have Chris handle the case. I did not like the total lack of communication. Chris talked to me once and never talked to my son outside of the courthouse.

See All Client Reviews

Christopher Mathew Gilley's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse Christopher
David Seiter headshot
David Seiter

Criminal defense lawyer | Oct 20

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I have known Chris throughout his career as a prosecutor in Hamilton, Marion and Madison counties as well as his current position in private practice. Chris is a terrific trial attorney who is quick on his feet and highly intelligent. He cares about the people he represents and is passionate about representing them to the fullest."

Charles Francis Braddock headshot
Charles Braddock

Criminal defense lawyer | Apr 13

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I endorse this lawyer. He is extremely well versed in all matters of Criminal Law. I regularly consult him for his expertise when civil matters have a criminal element to them and the timing of the prosecutor in other actions. Certainly one of the best."

View All Endorsements
Jack Michael Freedman headshot
Jack Freedman

Family lawyer

Gabriel Mathew Berry headshot
Gabriel Berry

Family lawyer

David Seiter headshot
David Seiter

Unknown lawyer

Experience

Rating:  7.4 (Very Good)

Honors

2021

2021 Lawyer of Distinction, Lawyers of Distinction

Work Experience

2016 - Present

Partner, Gilley Dandurand & Summerfield law group llp

2011 - 2012

Deputy Prosecuting Attorney, Madison County States Attorney

2008 - 2011

Deputy Prosecuting Attorney, Marion County Prosecutor's Office

2006 - 2008

Deputy Prosecuting Attorney, Hamilton County Prosecutor's Office

Associations

2013 - Present

Indianapolis Bar Association

Member

2013 - Present

Hamilton County Bar Association

Member

2013 - Present

Madison County Bar Association

Member

2006 - Present

Indiana State Bar Association

Member

Sample of Legal Cases

Cynthia Worrell v. Brian Worrell, 23A-DR-224 (November 28, 2023)

Affirmed, Father kept custody and did not need to pay Mother's fees.

Brian Worrell v. Cynthia Worrell, 20A-DR-2106 (July 26, 2021)

This was one of many ultimately awarding my client, the father, custody and no order to pay mother's attorney fees.

See More Legal Cases

Education

2006

Ohio Northern University - Claude W. Pettit College of Law

JD - Juris Doctor

2003

Manchester College

BS - Bachelor of Science

Speaking Engagements

2017

Indiana surety bail agents association general meeting

Bond Reform

Languages

English

Activity

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution