John Karl Rinehardt

PRO

John Karl Rinehardt

5.0
Rating: 9.8

Licensed for 39 years

Personal injury Lawyer at Ontario, OH
Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Car Accidents, Trucking Accident ... +7 more

2404 Park Ave. W, Ontario, OH

Virtual Consultation Available

Free Consultation

About John

Biography

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Experience You Can Count On

Practice Areas

10

Practice Areas

Personal Injury 55%

55%
Animal and Dog Bites 5%

5%
Brain Injury 5%

5%
Car Accident 5%

5%
Motorcycle Accident 5%

5%
Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect 5%

5%
Slip and Fall Accident 5%

5%
Spinal Cord Injury 5%

5%
Trucking Accident 5%

5%
Wrongful Death 5%

5%

Fees and Rates

Cost

Free Consultation

$0 first 60 minutes

Contingency

33%-40%

Awards

Client's Choice
Client's Choice
2024 2015

Licenses

Licensed in Ohio for 39 years

State: Ohio

Acquired: 1986

Active

No misconduct found

Location

Rinehart Law Firm

2404 Park Ave. W, Ontario, OH, 44906

Rinehardt Law Firm

8351 N. High St, Ste 251, Columbus, OH, 43082

Online Presence

Other places you can find John online.

John Karl Rinehardt's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

5.0 /5.0

22 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (22) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 6 - 10 of 22 reviews

Posted by Brian | June 09, 2019 | Hired Attorney | Personal Injury

Excellent Attorney

I looked long and hard for an attorney that would help me with my case. Searching, I came across Rinehardt Law Firm and saw they had great reviews and worked on personal injury cases. Once speaking with Attorney Rinehardt and explaining my case to him he immediately listened to what I had to say, e...xpressed he felt I had a case and started working on it. His team of attorneys worked for the next three and half years on my case. I never had to call, unless I had a question, they would keep me informed of any new developments or things I needed to do. While working with Attorney Rinehardt we were able to get further treatments and procedures performed to get a better grasp of my condition. Once we had an MRI we had conclusive evidence to what my injury was, where it was and what could have caused it. All I can say is I have never sued anyone or been sued so I had no idea what to expect. Attorney Rinehardt helped me by explaining things in a way I could understand and made a stressful situation a more confident one. I had to do a lot of things for this auto insurer, missing work for appointments they set up to providing sensitive information I personally did not feel was pertinent to the case, but this was all part of the process. Nothing about the three and half years I spent in a lawsuit with this auto insurer was easy. The auto insurer did everything to make my life miserable but the Rinehardt Law Firm made sure that I stayed focused, they kept me educated on what to expect before entering an arbitration hearing, meditations and what to expect if we ended up at trial. All things that someone like myself needs to help alleviate some of the anxiety of the unknown. This journey was long, it was rough and it honestly seemed like it would never end but persistence pays off and that is why I am so happy I went with Rinehardt Law Firm. Everyone on their team is so amazing and they were all so nice to me, so accommodating with scheduling appointments and getting procedures arranged to meeting me in Columbus. This is an amazing law firm they are more about the person than the company and looking out for your needs, like family. I could not find that here in the city of Columbus from the several reviews I looked through and I wanted someone like Attorney Rinehardt who I felt comfortable speaking with in person or on the phone. Now in the those three and half years Attorney Rinehardt has opened a wonderful location here in Columbus and I believe he will help a lot of people, he has a very kind heart BUT, is extremely tough when fighting for you and has a great deal of education and experience dealing with personal injury claims. Attorney Rinehardt's experience is just another reason why I went with his law firm he showed a level of confidence and skill set that personally I felt was above and beyond when meeting with the opposing lawyers. He did not fold or show any sign of weakness while interacting with the opposition and this is an important quality when you are fighting for another person. Personally if, and I hope it never happens, I ever have another personal injury and need an attorney to fight for me I will not hesitate to call the Rinehardt Law Firm to work my case. I am happy I found them and I am also so happy they took my case and got me the results I wanted. This is an A++ business!

Posted by Candy | June 05, 2019 | Hired Attorney

Car Accident

I was beyond happy with the Rinehardt Law Firm. They were quick to answer any question I had ( and there were many) and their follow through was amazing. Every staff member was informative and helpful. I would highly recommend the Rinehardt Law Firm.

Posted by Terry | September 14, 2016 | Hired Attorney | Car Accidents

THE BEST

I hired the Rinehardt Law Firm to represent me due to an auto accident. Throughout the settlement process John and his staff were very professional, gave clear communication and direction. I was really impressed with how well I was treated. I felt like a VIP. John and his staff are a professional,... hard working group of people that cared about me and my outcome. If you are looking for the best, look no further. I highly recommend the Rinehardt Law Firm.

Posted by Terrel | September 17, 2015 | Hired Attorney | Lawsuits & Disputes

The Best Around

John and his entire staff did an amazing job staying in contact through out the entire time. They're all well known and come highly recommended. Each and everytime I had a question, it was answered immediately or at the most earliest convenience! I enjoyed the uplifting conversations of reassurance w...hen I ran into an emotional wall of frustration. If you're looking for a legal team who isn't afraid of war, John Reinhardt and his team are the way to go! THANKS FOR EVERYTHING AND GOD BLESS!!

Posted by Nichole | September 16, 2015 | Hired Attorney | Personal Injury

Outstanding law firm

My husband and I were involved in motorcycle accident that caused muskeg serious injuries. All of the staff at Rinehardt law firm were absolutely incredible!! John, his wife and the rest of the staff went above and beyond to settle our claim. They were with is every step of the way and I couldn't be ...more pleased with the outcome. They were with us through one of the hardest trials we've faced and they treated us with nothing but compassion. I would recommend this law firm to everyone!

See All Client Reviews

John Karl Rinehardt's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse John
J. Jeffrey Heck headshot
J. Heck

Personal injury lawyer | Aug 05

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"John is a top-notch attorney. He is highly respected in the legal community and an excellent advocate for his clients."

Melanie Sue Fahey headshot
Melanie Fahey

Personal injury lawyer | Aug 06

Relationship: Worked for lawyer

"John works tirelessly for his clients, and his professional demeanor and compassionate representation are top notch. In the courtroom, John is focused, articulate, and persuasive. He exhibits an exceptional level of integrity and fair play, even under demanding and high pressure circumstances."

Rachel Alexandra Rinehardt headshot
Rachel Rinehardt

Personal injury lawyer | Jan 17

Relationship: Co-worker

"It is with great respect and admiration that I endorse John Rinehardt. John exemplifies the highest standards of legal practice in the field of personal injury law. His profound understanding of the legal system, combined with his unwavering dedication to justice, has not only shaped our firm's success but also deeply influenced my own professional journey. John's leadership is characterized by integrity, strategic acumen, and a genuine commitment to client advocacy. He has a remarkable ability to mentor and inspire those around him, fostering a culture of excellence within our team. His tireless work ethic and compassionate approach to client representation make him a true pillar in our legal community. I wholeheartedly recommend John Rinehardt to anyone seeking a knowledgeable, experienced, and ethical personal injury attorney."

James Kenworthy Wagner headshot
James Wagner

Personal injury lawyer | Sep 12

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I practice law in Mansfield, Richland County, Ohio and in my work have occasion to know John and his excellent legal representation in the field of personal injury. I have referred many of my own clients to John in these matters because I consider John to be the best. He has consistently accomplished outstanding results for those whom I have referred. If I were to be injured, John is the attorney I would hire."

Michael Lee Inscore headshot
Michael Inscore

Car accident lawyer | Aug 14

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I've known John Rinehardt for many years and he is an accomplished car accident lawyer."

Gary Alan Piper headshot
Gary Piper

Car accident lawyer | Aug 14

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer."

Jeffrey Ned Kramer headshot
Jeffrey Kramer

Car accident lawyer | Dec 16

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Highly competent, very experienced personal injury advocate. Fearless and effective client advocate."

Victor Peter Kademenos headshot
Victor Kademenos

Car accident lawyer | Oct 20

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I have known John for many years. He is ethical, knowledgeable, kind, and a passionate advocate for his clients. I would highly recommend him."

Kristin Eileen Brown headshot
Kristin Brown

Personal injury lawyer | Sep 26

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer."

Hillary Gail Rinehardt headshot
Hillary Rinehardt

Personal injury lawyer | Jun 18

Relationship: Co-worker

"I endorse this lawyer."

View All Endorsements
Rachel Alexandra Rinehardt headshot
Rachel Rinehardt

Personal injury lawyer

Jon Patrick Schaefer headshot
Jon Schaefer

General practice lawyer

Frank Leslie Benham III headshot
Frank Benham

Business lawyer

Gordon Matthew Eyster headshot
Gordon Eyster

General practice lawyer

Melanie Sue Fahey headshot
Melanie Fahey

Personal injury lawyer

Andrew Neal Bush headshot
Andrew Bush

Business lawyer

Stefanie Lynn Cooper headshot
Stefanie Cooper

Mediation lawyer

J. Jeffrey Heck headshot
J. Heck

Personal injury lawyer

Joshua James Brown headshot
Joshua Brown

Bankruptcy and debt lawyer

Michael Lee Inscore headshot
Michael Inscore

Medical malpractice lawyer

Jeffrey Ned Kramer headshot
Jeffrey Kramer

Business lawyer

James Lee Childress headshot
James Childress

Commercial real estate lawyer

Deborah L Mack headshot
Deborah Mack

Bankruptcy and debt lawyer

Richard Henry Otto headshot
Richard Otto

Family lawyer

Victor Peter Kademenos headshot
Victor Kademenos

Workers compensation lawyer

Hillary Gail Rinehardt headshot
Hillary Rinehardt

Personal injury lawyer

James Kenworthy Wagner headshot
James Wagner

Probate lawyer

John David Donaldson headshot
John Donaldson

Workers compensation lawyer

Gary Alan Piper headshot
Gary Piper

Insurance lawyer

Jeffrey Scott Ream headshot
Jeffrey Ream

General practice lawyer

Experience

Rating:  9.8 (Superb)

Honors

2022

AV Preeminent Rated, Martindale-Hubbell

2021

AV Preeminent Rated, Martindale-Hubbell

2016

AV Rated Preeminent, Martindale-Hubbell

2016

Super Lawyer, SuperLawyers

2015

Clients' Choice Award, AVVO

2015

Client Distinction Award, Martindale-Hubbell

2015

Member, Million Dollar Advocates Forum

2015

Member, Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum

2015

Board Certified, National Board of Trial Advocacy

2012

Super Lawyer, SuperLawyers

2012

Top Attorneys in Ohio, Columbus Monthly

2012

PRR BV Distinguished Attorneys, Martindale-Hubbell

Work Experience

2001 - Present

Owner, Rinehardt Law Firm

2007 - 2012

Attorney Advisor, Volunteer High School Mock Trial

1986 - 2001

Attorney, Inscore, Rinehardt, Whitney and Enderle

Associations

2014 - Present

Multi Million Advocates Forum

Member

2012 - Present

Million Dollar Advocates Forum

Member

2001 - Present

National Board of Trial Advocacy

Board Certified Member

1987 - Present

Ohio Association for Justice

Member

1987 - Present

American Association for Justice

Member

1986 - Present

Ohio State Bar Association

Member

Sample of Legal Cases

Wrongful Death

case resolved for $1.8 million

Auto/Truck Collision

case resolved for $3.1 million

Newcomer v. Meadows

gross verdict for soft tissue injuries of $60,000

Workplace Injury

case resolved for $1.2 million

Townsend v. Dollar General

gross verdict of $819,000 upheld on appeal

Workplace Injury

case resolved for $1,047,750

Walker v. Erie Insurance

verdict of $397,664 for plaintiff and $40,000 for plaintiff's spouse for loss of consortium plus prejudgment interest

McNeil v. Kingsley

verdict of $350,000 plus prejudgment interest. Judgment upheld on appeal.

Shifflet v. Newman Technology

$794,590 jury verdict

See More Legal Cases

Education

1986

Ohio State University

JD - Juris Doctor

1983

The Ohio State University

BA - Bachelor of Arts

Speaking Engagements

1998

Richland County Bar Association seminar

Trying a Personal Injury case

Languages

English

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution