Jay Robert Seigel

PRO

Jay Robert Seigel

4.7
Rating: 8.0

Licensed for 16 years

Family Lawyer at Sarasota, FL
Practice Areas: Family, Real Estate

1800 Second Street, Suite 884, Sarasota, FL

Virtual Consultation Available

Free Consultation

About Jay

Practice Areas

2

Practice Areas

Family 80%

Including Divorce & Separation; Parenting Plans; Child Support

80%
Real Estate 20%

20%

Fees and Rates

Cost

Free Consultation

$0 first 30 minutes

Retainer

Sometimes


Payment Methods

  • Cash
  • Check
  • Credit Card

Awards

Client's Choice
Client's Choice
2025 2020 2019

Licenses

Licensed in Florida for 16 years

State: Florida

Acquired: 2009

Member in Good Standing

No misconduct found

Location

Law Office of Jay R. Seigel, P.A.

1800 Second Street, Suite 884, Sarasota, FL, 34236

jayseigellaw.com/

Jay Robert Seigel's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

4.7 /5.0

36 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (36) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 11 - 11 of 11 reviews | General Knowledge

Posted by anonymous | July 29, 2021 | Alimony

Not Professional Unfortunately

Jay is representing my wife and it is clearly a conflict of interested on his part. If he was professional he would have told my wife there is a conflict of interest and would have offered her another attorney to represent her but instead he took her retainer and then my info was deleted from the sy...stem at Matt Kowtko office where Jay also has a office. This is clearly a conflict and unprofessional. I contacted Matt after reaching out to two attorney's and telling them my situation and they both advised me to contact Matt and he would be the best person to have represent me. So I called and set up an appointment with Matt and met with him for about a hour talking about my situation with my wife who has been the one supporting our family for 14 years financially while I raised our kids and took care of the house. I also remodeled the house and started a small business that I could do around the kids schedule. I told Matt a lot of very personal stuff about our marriage. He told it sounds like she is getting ready to make a move, I was worried about the kids and the house and her just taking everything from me because she became unhappy about her being the one supporting the family. She told me she didnt want that role anymore and wanted out. After talking with Matt, he advice me that she can't just decide to change the roles like that and that I should not leave the house if asked too, also the kids would be 50/50 so she couldn't take the kids away, and she couldn't just quit working or supporting us that she would have to continue and if we did get divorce there was Alimony that would be possible, so she cant just decide she no longer wants to support us. I call Matt right away and want to get representation from him and was told after looking me up that I would have to go with one of his associates because he wasn't taking on anymore cases. So I talked to a colleague for a hour about what was going on and she backed up everything Matt said and that I had a good case and she couldn't just walk out of all her finical responsibility to the family. My wife told me she didn't want to use attorney's so I said ok I would like to do it peaceful as well, but she wasn't being honest about a lot of stuff my brother an Attorney said dude call the Attorney dude she is trying to manipulate you and sure enough the next day I am served with divorce paper on Saturday I called the Attorney on Monday and all the sudden they have no record of me and I am not in their system. I am like I have to been I just called you and you looked me up right away. She said nope no records of you and I said that is not possible I spoke with 2 attorneys in that office now about my whole case. She asked me what my wife's name was I told her and she said we are representing her, I was very shocked and said that is not possible and she confirmed it. then a few minutes later I get a call from the attorney and she said we cant represent you because of a conflict of interest, I said you have to be kidding after all this I said you cant represent her then because that is a conflict of interest she said you are probably right and said she couldn't say any more. but told me to call Angela Tobaygo and attorney that could help me. So for this reason I would not recommend this law firm at all very shady practices.

Jay Seigel

Replied last October 19, 2022

It is a unique situation when an attorney from one firm, gets a negative review from a person who was never a client of that firm. It seems you contacted Kowtko Law Group, PA, who I provide services for in an "of counsel" capacity. When they learned I had either consulted or previously represented an adverse party to your case, through the Law Office of Jay R. Seigel, PA, they decided in an abundance of caution to refer you to another well-respected attorney in the area.

See All Client Reviews

Jay Robert Seigel's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse Jay
Rafael Ayala Villalba headshot
Rafael Villalba

Family lawyer | Oct 13

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I endorse this lawyer. Jay is an exceptional advocate for his clients. I have had the pleasure to work alongside Jay on several cases. I have watched him prepare for trial, deliver legally succinct, impactful, and effective arguments. I observed him cross examine opposing parties making the squirm on the stand and fumble over their words. I got the privilege to watch ecstatic clients embrace him thanking him for unbelievably favorable outcomes he helped them obtain. Not only is he an extremely effective attorney, he is one of the most highly ethical and scrupulous attorneys I have had the privilege to work with."

Daphane Clements-Stevens ` headshot
Daphane Clements-Stevens

Family lawyer | Jan 11

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer."

Nia Sharan headshot
Nia Sharan

Unknown lawyer | Nov 30

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Jay is proficient in family law but in many other legal areas as well. His knowledge and intelligence of the law is a litigating force to be reckoned with. Jay also has a dynamic personality with a keen understanding of people and life so is able to bring a human element and approach to cases and those he represents. He is a great attorney bottom line."

William Matthew Kowtko headshot
William Kowtko

Foreclosure lawyer | Jun 24

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. I have worked with him on cases and consulted with him regarding specific areas where I do not practice. His advise has always been highly on point and very beneficial in answering my specific needs. I would refer matters to Jay without question."

Derek B Simms headshot
Derek Simms

Insurance lawyer | Feb 26

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I endorse this lawyer."

Raymond Christopher Palmucci headshot
Raymond Palmucci

Unknown lawyer | Dec 12

Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter

"I endorse this lawyer."

Philip Juluis Schipani headshot
Philip Schipani

Family lawyer | Nov 01

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. I have known Mr. Seigel for many years. He is a highly knowledgeable attorney. He has a high standard of ethics and cares deeply about his clients."

Debra M. Salisbury headshot
Debra Salisbury

Family lawyer | Nov 01

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I have had the pleasure of knowing Attorney Seigel for over a year in his practice of family law. Attorney Seigel is consistently well prepared in the representation of his clients for hearings, mediations, and trials. He utilizes critical thinking in his analysis of cases while approaching cases with practicality based upon the facts of the case. He makes reasonable attempts to settle a case before seeking judicial intervention. I endorse Attorney Seigel in the area of family law."

View All Endorsements
Derek B Simms headshot
Derek Simms

Agriculture lawyer

Experience

Rating:  8.0 (Excellent)

Honors

1998

Oral Argument in Law Award, Northwestern School of Law at Lewis and Clark College

Work Experience

2016 - Present

Attorney, Law Office of Jay R. Seigel, P.A.

2009 - 2016

Attorney, Phelan Hallinan Schmieg, LLP

Associations

Florida Bar

Member

Sarasota County Bar Association

Member

Education

1998

Northwestern School of Law at Lewis & Clark

1992

Arizona State University

BA- Communications; Magna Cum Laude

Languages

English

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution