Here's the Florida answer........and I used to be an adjuster. Some companies will let you retain the salvage. But you'll need to turn over the...

Am I entitled to know 1) When the witness came forward 2) Who the witness is 3) Where/What city the witness is from.

I wonder who your insurer is..... Look these days insurance companies play games. And no they don't owe you anything as to who the witness is or...

Selected as the best answer

Would you call this dishonesty? Is this normal behavior from an insurer?

They didn't lie, they took their insured's word. You need a witness or video to prove your case. If injured get an attorney.

What can I file a countersuit for if I am being sued for pain and suffering from an MVA?

I agree with attorney Hoffman don't worry about this, Liberty Mutual has a duty to defend you, for free. If you want proof, read that auto policy...

What do I do now ?

I was going to answer, then saw others had. But illegal..........? Really? And how do you expect to collect? You should simply go to the police...

Do my New York PIP benefits stop if I'm incarcerated?

Good question, I'd say contact a local personal injury attorney that handles NY PIP cases.

Do I have a case? If so, what kind of attorney do I need?

You have a great case, except for one thing..............you can't prove who hit you. Close doesn't work you need to know, name, car tag, address,...

Did I do anything at the scene of this accident which could cause me to run afoul of CA's Hit and Run laws?

Yes and no. You should have stuck around until a cop arrived, now you've left yourself open to whatever that guy says happened. If you get a ticket...

Is it possible for me to be sued?

Report to your insurer, send them a copy of that letter. They will either deny, pay or defend any suit.

You have no "right". If you sued and named Dunkin you can subpoena the video. Otherwise go there and ask real nice. I'd order breakfast and talk up...