Trip and Fall Accident while Operating a Hand Truck at Work- Jury Verdict and Appeal of Jury Verdict amount held up on appeal
N/AOUTCOME: $433,303.00 dollars
Injury: Bucket Handle tear of the medial meniscus of the knee requiring a surgical meniscectomy; and aggravation of pre-existing tear of the anterior cruciate ligament Result: Jury awarded the plainti ... ff $373,303.00 dollars for his injuries, pain and suffering;and future pain and suffering; and awarded plaintiff’s wife $60,000.00 dollars in past and future loss of consortium. The jury verdict amount was upheld on appeal. The plaintiff, a soda fountain mechanic, was moving a soda vending machine with a hand truck in a parking lot adjacent to private apartments owned by the defendant. The plaintiff testified at trial that while walking backwards pulling a hand truck, he stepped into a pothole. Plaintiff ‘s coworker and supervisor testified that the plaintiff was using the proper method of moving the machinery with the hand truck at trial. The defendant claimed initially that the accident did not occur, or in the alternative, that the plaintiff’s injuries were pre-existing. Defendants offered $25,000.00 dollars. The jury awarded the plaintiff $373,303.00 dollars for his injuries, pain and suffering and future pain and suffering; and awarded plaintiff’s wife $60,000.00 dollars in past and future loss of consortium. The damages were upheld on appeal
