Geoffrey Howland Schotter

Every Lawyer Turned Me Away—Except Geoffrey Schotter. When my employer, New York State, broke me under extreme conditions, pushing me into an acute mental health crisis, Geoffrey Schotter was the one who stepped in. I had already reached out to multiple attorneys. Every single one turned me awa...y. Not because my case wasn’t real, but because it was too difficult, too risky, too untested. Geoffrey was the last lawyer I contacted before I was ready to represent myself. He was my last hope. And, as it turned out, he was the most important one. He didn’t just take my case. He examined every detail, anticipated every counterargument, and built something undeniable. He refused to let my suffering be dismissed as “just part of the job.” Beyond Representation: A Relentless Pursuit of Justice What sets Geoffrey apart is that he doesn’t just argue a case, he builds it with precision. Every possible counterargument? Anticipated and dismantled. Every potential weak point? Reinforced before it could be challenged. By the time we got to summation, there was no shaky ground left to stand on. And he didn’t just take one route; he gave my case multiple paths to victory. A clear argument for my claim as a work-related accident. A strategic foundation for establishing it as an occupational disease. A preemptive dismantling of any claim that my breakdown was a lawful personnel action. Each argument stood on its own, but together, they created something undeniable. Sharp, Focused, and Completely Unapologetic Geoffrey can be snappy, short, frustrated, and even frustrating at times. But that’s what it takes to push the law forward. When you’re forcing the system to acknowledge its failures, when you’re fighting for something that hasn’t been fought before, there’s no time for hesitation or unnecessary pleasantries. He operates at a level of focus, intensity, and precision that makes lesser arguments collapse before they even begin. He doesn’t waste words. He doesn’t waste time. He gets to the point, and the point is razor-sharp. If you’re looking for a lawyer who will soften the truth or go through the motions, he’s not your guy. But if you want someone who will force the opposition to answer for every single thing they overlooked, dismissed, or ignored; who will push through legal barriers most attorneys wouldn’t even think to challenge; this is the lawyer you need. Staying Three Steps Ahead of the Opposition Geoffrey didn’t just respond; he dictated the pace. The defense barely had room to move because he forced them to confront their own failures in a way they couldn’t ignore. He took their best possible arguments and preemptively turned them against them. And it wasn’t just about me. He made sure the court saw the bigger picture: the systemic failure, the pattern of harm, the need for change. This case was never just about compensation. It was about holding a system accountable for what it had done to its workers. The Lawyer You Call When You Refuse to Be Dismissed This isn’t just about winning a case. It’s about fighting for what’s right in a system that hopes people like me give up. Geoffrey didn’t just refuse to let me give up; he made sure I had the legal firepower to fight back. I walked into this case expecting to fight alone. Instead, I found someone who fought with me for justice, for accountability, and for every worker who has ever been told that suffering is just part of the job. The work of protecting healthcare workers, public servants, all of us is far from finished. The fight does not end in the courtroom. The law does not evolve without those who challenge its limits. Geoffrey Schotter is not just a lawyer; he is proof that the battle for workers’ rights is still worth fighting.

Geoffrey Schotter was referred to me by several individuals whom stated successful outcomes. I have a complicated case against many Defendents and New York State and despite the deep pockets that N.Y.S. has to hire the best, Mr. Schotter continues to prevail on all of our Motions. We are now at the c...onclusion of the matter, having survived Summary Judgment and are well prepared and confident for trial. This guy WINS!

I recently had the pleasure of working with Scotter and Millican Law Firm, and I couldn't be happier with the service I received. Mr Schotter was professional, knowledgeable, and attentive to my needs throughout the entire process, even when I felt like giving up. Mr Scotter kept me informed and ...involved at every step; his expertise helped to achieve a successful outcome in my case. I highly recommend Schotter and Millican Law Firm to anyone in need of legal representation. He truly went above and beyond for me, and I am extremely grateful for his help.

I can not sing high enough praise for Geoffrey and the work he did on my workers compensation case. My case was 6 years old and had been basically kicked aside from a previous attorney. Within a couple of months, he had a new hearing date and got everything set where it should be. And now, he settled... it in less than a month for more than I asked for. If you need an attorney that will fight, win and truly care for your case, Geoffrey is the man! Schotter Millican, LLP returned every phone call, answered every question and truly made me feel like I was there only client. If I ever have another issue, Geoffrey Schotter will be my attorney.