Why the letter? What happens if he doesn't show up? What do I do if he doesn't pay after I win?

You have the burden of proof. His answer is basically telling you to prove your case. So, do it and win!

You don't have an arbitration clause with the other driver do you? Then, you are under no obligation to arbitrate. This is a ploy they use. ...

What recourse should be take? Do we have a case?

I agree with Robert. Contact a lawyer to write a demand letter to your neighbors homeowners insurance company.

What type of civil attorney defends against subrogation claims? Would the same type handle the personal civil suit sure to come?

If he has no property, then a judgment against him would be worthless. Contact the other side and let then know that your son is judgment proof. ...

Selected as the best answer

Can I sue my neighbor/his insurance for my time/effort spent rectifying this situation that is a result of his negligence?

I would contact a personal injury lawyer to file a claim against your neighbors home owners insurance policy.

Is there an affordable private attorney that can help me?

You need to seek out a lawyer. Try googling legal aid for your area.

Is this true and if so what can I do?

The law is evolving in this area. So, you would most likely have to hire an insurance lawyer for advice. Use the AVVO find a lawyer tool for a...

Does a person pay taxes on a life insurance policy? Does it make a difference that it was an IRA first then an insurance policy

You should probably repost this under tax law to get a better result. I would contact a CPA.

Judge considers motion and whether respondent has provided responses to discovery requests within the rules. The judge will consider any valid and...

Can a judge give me a liability decision on my claim and that over turn what the insurance company has decided?

You sue the at fault driver. His insurance will hire an attorney to represent him in court and will pay if you win. Ask for cost of repair and for...