Dutton v. Shaffer, --- F.4th ---, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 9437 (6th Cir. 2026)
Apr 01, 2026OUTCOME: Prevailed for client
Free Speech Challenge on behalf of Kentucky judge; affirmed permanent injunction and expanded relief for client on appeal.
Covington, KY
Constitutional Lawyer at Covington, KY
Practice Areas: Constitutional, Litigation ... +3 more
OUTCOME: Prevailed for client
Free Speech Challenge on behalf of Kentucky judge; affirmed permanent injunction and expanded relief for client on appeal.
OUTCOME: Prevailed in obtaining certiorari relief for client
Prevailed in cert. grant (with remand and vacate) order from U.S. Supreme Court as part of team litigating free exercise clause claims on behalf of the New York Amish.
OUTCOME: Prevailed in appeal
Prevailed in qualified immunity appeal for client
OUTCOME: Prevailed in appeal
Prevailed in appeal, which denied qualified immunity to certain Kentucky government officials, including Kentucky's Governor.
OUTCOME: Prevailed for client
Prevailed in First Amendment free speech case, and obtained reversal of district court decision that denied preliminary injunction.
OUTCOME: Prevailed for client
Preserved preliminary injunctive relief for a class of approximately 10,000 Air and Space Force members over religious objections under RFRA to the COVID-19 vaccination requirement
OUTCOME: Prevailed in published injunction pending appeal decision for client.
Significant Free Exercise case (later cited by the U.S. Supreme Court in Tandon v. Newsom matter), involving Governor's COVID-19 restrictions.
OUTCOME: Affirmed permanent injunction
6th Circuit Judicial Free Speech
OUTCOME: Affirmed permanent injunction.
First Amendment lawsuit regarding electioneering (6th Circuit)
OUTCOME: Obtained permanent injunction forcing state to redistrict
1983 constitutional litigation (voting rights)