WAYNE MUTUAL INSURANCE Co. v. Mills, et al. 1996 WL 936780
Jul 31, 1996OUTCOME: reversed and remanded
1996 WL 936780 Court of Appeals, 9th District Wayne County, Ohio Insurance Coverage Declaratory Judgment Action
Mentor, OH
Car accident Lawyer at Mentor, OH
Practice Areas: Car Accidents, Divorce & Separation ... +2 more
OUTCOME: reversed and remanded
1996 WL 936780 Court of Appeals, 9th District Wayne County, Ohio Insurance Coverage Declaratory Judgment Action
OUTCOME: The court finds the applicant's contributory misconduct was causally related to the collision; however, his conduct was not substantial pursuant to the standard set forth in Spaulding.
On May 17, 1990, in Stark County, Ohio, the applicant, William R. Leach, suffered personal injury as a result of being struck by a motorcycle driven by an intoxicated offender, John Seabolt, while he w ... as jaywalking. The Attorney General for the State of Ohio investigated the applicant's claim and argued that it be denied pursuant to R.C. 2743.60(F) because the applicant engaged in contributory misconduct. However, I argued that pursuant to In re Spaulding (1991), 63 Ohio Misc.2d 39, 42, 619 N.E.2d 1199, 1201, "for an award of reparations to be denied, rather than reduced, as a result of contributory misconduct on behalf of the victim or applicant pursuant to R.C. 2743.60(F), there must be a showing of substantial contributory misconduct." (Emphasis added.)