I am writing this for myself and fiance as she wishes to remain anonymous. I will preface this by saying that both Mr. Dekker and Mr. Armuth are respected attorneys in Lafayette which my own reputation is no longer so sterling but I guarantee this is all 100% accurate and true.
My fiance hired Mr. D...ekker for a criminal matter in Tippecanoe County. She was impressed as he had done research on her case and was very prepared even at their initial meeting. He was professional and charged a reasonable fee. She was pleased with his representation in this case. She unfortunately also was charged in Clinton County for an unrelated issue and again hired Mr. Dekker. This time he stated that the evidence was all circumstantial and he could easily get her acquitted. In the end, he did not deliver and keep his promise and she ended up pleading guilty and getting probation. When a PTR was then filed in the same case, Mr. Dekker filed a motion to withdraw so quickly that my fiance did not have time to reach out to his office to hire him again. I did this myself and told his staff I would be paying the fees for my fiance. I was given an agreed upon my but my credit card declined due to issues at Captiol Ones end. While I sorted this out, I was contacted by his office and now told the fee was more than doubled and he wanted full payment plus what my fiance still owed all up front. I declined and hired another attorney who was willing to work with me. I realize if my credit card had gone through, I would have been stuck and forced to pay the additional money. His office staff was polite but clearly only concerned about getting paid and did not respond to other inquiries.
After my fiances first initially good experience I attempted to hire Mr. Dekker for my own misdemenour case. I had to wait over six weeks to see him. Unlike my fiance, he clearly did not look at my case at all prior to the morning of our initial meeting at which point he believed he had a conflict of interest as he was "friends" with my ex-wife. His office did try to call me but I was already at his office by that time. When I arrived, Mr. Dekker came out and shook my hand and said he could not represent me as he was friends with my ex. I truly don't understand why this was a conflict as my case had nothing to do with her but clearly do not want to hire an attorney who believes there is a conflict. While I clearly doubt his judgement for being "friends" with a pathologic liar and adulterer like my ex, I respect a man who come out to meet face to face. I did not respect, however, that he was quite rude and dismissive and could not put a coherent sentence together. Hey, if you are going to be a jerk then let your staff take care of it. Perhaps Mr. Dekker is "friends" with my ex as she came illegally from Mexico where Mr. Dekker had to study unable to get into a school in the USA. As a past president of the Kappa Sigma fraternity years ago, of which Mr. Dekker was a member at another school, Mr. Dekker clearly does not embody the ideals of that fraternity. He apparently only wants to work with and impress women, though why they swoon over a man who thinks a bow-tie is the height of fashion.
Connor Armuth was a court appointed attorney for my fiance in Carroll County. She was initially please as he was a partner of Mr. Dekker. I completely understand why an attorney would not be motivated to work that hard when his client is not paying his fees, but he still has an obligation to do his job. Her case was extremely defensible but only with extreme difficulty did she convince him to go to trial. Again, she had a warrant issued for violated her bond/release (even though she had paid no money) and all Mr. Armuth would suggest was to turn herself in and sit in county jail. No attempt to contact the prosecutor or the court to dismiss the warrant. I hired another attorney who filed a motion and had this warrant dismissed quickly and easily. My fiance has filed an official complaint.