Jimmy Jay Lefton

PRO

Jimmy Jay Lefton

4.6
Rating: 10.0

Licensed for 31 years

Divorce and separation Lawyer at Cincinnati, OH
Practice Areas: Divorce & Separation, Child Custody, Child Support

3074 Madison Road, Cincinnati, OH

Virtual Consultation Available

Free Consultation

About Jimmy

Biography

Looking for a Family Law Attorney that will listen and help you achieve your goals? Call me now

Practice Areas

3

Practice Areas

Divorce and Separation 60%

Assisting clients in evaluating their goals, dividing marital assets and debts, child support and spousal support, child custody and parenting time. Also assist clients after their divorce in modifying their court orders and agreements.

33 years

60%
Child Custody 20%

Assisting clients in evaluating their goals, dividing marital assets and debts, child support and spousal support, child custody and parenting time. Also assist clients after their divorce in modifying their court orders and agreements.

33 years

20%
Child Support 20%

Assisting clients in evaluating their goals, dividing marital assets and debts, child support and spousal support, child custody and parenting time. Also assist clients after their divorce in modifying their court orders and agreements.

33 years

20%

Fees and Rates

Cost

Free Consultation

$0 first 15 minutes


Payment Methods

  • Cash
  • Check
  • Credit Card

Awards

Silver Client Champion

Licenses

Licensed in Ohio for 31 years

State: Ohio

Acquired: 1994

Active

No misconduct found

Location

Barron, Peck, Bennie & Schlemmer

3074 Madison Road, Cincinnati, OH, 45209

www.513divorce.com

Jimmy Jay Lefton's Reviews

Avvo Review Score

4.6 /5.0

11 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (11) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 1 - 5 of 5 reviews | Communication Style

Posted by Karl | October 22, 2020 | Hired Attorney | Divorce & Separation

First Class Experience

What can I not say about the guidance Jimmy provided me during my 4 year long debate/divorce. Things weren't going well in my marriage and a friend suggested I reach out to Jimmy and I did. We had previous history together, but not under these circumstances. He invited me to his office and spent ...well over an hour with me explaining the entire process. Jimmy was patient, as I attempted to save my marriage time and time again, till I knew it wasn't going to work no matter what I did, as it takes 2 people to make a marriage work. Jimmy offered to represent me and my interest and suggested for me to reach out to my wife to address all legal proceedings to use him to cut out court and legal representation fees as much as possible. Jimmy's goal is wanting the best for both parties during this trying time in our lives. She chose her own counsel which is fine. The thing that sticks out the most to me was his guidance throughout this process. Paraphrasing: "Tempers are going to flare and ugliness may come out at any point. You need to be in control of your response/reactions as best as you can, always! You only have one divorce and how will others remember it? It's important not only for you, but for your daughter. The both of you will be forever connected because of your daughter. Watch what you say and if you need to leave before you do something you'll regret, do it and call me, anytime. Your daughter and her mother will thank you when she gets older." Jimmy represented me well throughout the entire process when I was unable to attend court on certain occasions. I would recommend Jimmy to friends, family and even strangers who want to have a great aid/advisor during a challenging time. My divorce is complete and my Ex and I have a great respect for one another. We communicate regularly and openly as we put our differences aside and give our attention to our young daughter who needs both of her parents. Forever grateful to Jimmy Lefton Esq.

Posted by Cynthia Catron | February 19, 2016 | Hired Attorney | Divorce & Separation

Professional, efficient and empathetic

I highly recommend Jimmy Lefton as an attorney. He listened to what I wanted and advised me on what was possible. He did not just tell me what I wanted to hear. Divorce can be costly. Jimmy made sure he was efficient with billing time and his response time to any questions I had was quick. At a tim...e when my life seemed so out of control Jimmy provided me with these words " It is going to be okay, we will get through this". I cannot tell you the immense relief I felt hearing those words. He was right. Not only did he help me get through the legalities of it all he represented me with knowledge and integrity. Although I know I was not his only client I always felt as if I was.

Posted by Merle | December 21, 2012 | Divorce & Separation

Great support during a very difficult time

My ex-husband and I were fortunate in that our decision to separate was mutual and amicable. However, working our way through the detailed negotiations raised complex issues, and our top priority was that we resolve them in a way that maintained our relationship and the calm environment that was help...ing our children adjust to the big changes that had happened in our family. Unfortunately, the first attorney I hired seemed determined to create tension and conflicts where none had existed, and I was devastated. As I searched for a different lawyer Jimmy Lefton was recommended to me, but after my previous experience I was understandably apprehensive. However, it only took a few minutes during our first meeting for me to be completely reassured. Jimmy is the perfect combination of professional, knowledgable, thorough, compassionate, objective and supportive. Most importantly, he truly listened to my priorities and respected them, while still ensuring that I understood every aspect of the issues we were negotiating. As an added bonus, he is a warm and friendly person, and a pleasure to work with. As a result of Jimmy's considerable efforts, my ex-husband and I finalized our divorce with us both feeling like we reached a fair and equitable agreement. And we are extremely grateful that Jimmy helped us maintain the amicable family relationship for our children that is so important to all of us. I am very happy to highly recommend Jimmy Lefton.

Posted by Matthew | September 07, 2011 | Divorce & Separation

Divorce/Family Law - Look No Further than Jimmy Lefton

I hired Jimmy Lefton upon a referral from a trusted colleague and friend. I was just starting into what I knew would be an extremely contentious divorce and wanted the best representation possible. To say I found the best person for the job in Jimmy Lefton is an understatement. Jimmy is the absolu...te best. My divorce has been described by multiple attorneys as "the worst case possible" for any divorce. The fact of the matter is that my divorce was the worst case possible - false police reports filed, false domestic violence charges filed, conspiracy to commit criminal acts, purgery, court ordered psychological evaluations that showed my spouse had severe emotional and personality disorders - pretty much the works. My spouse wanted full custody of our children, all of the marital and premarital property, and even my parents' trust fund. In her words, "You can have the kids every other weekend and maybe Wednesday evenings for dinner, otherwise we will just litigate." Not an easy situation to deal with when you are an exceptional parent, your kids love you to pieces, you love them more than anything in the world, and your spouse is attempting to re-write history, and attempting to take criminal legal action against you on fabricated charges. Jimmy kept me grounded through it all. One of his greatest attributes is staying calm, taking the emotion out of it (as much as possible), and making sure you achieve your end goals in the divorce. Although it was a difficult road, in the end, we ended up settling out of court - agreeing to exactly, to the letter, everything that I had proposed months earlier, and all fabricated criminal charges were voluntarily dropped by my spouse. Nobody involved in this case thought it would be possible to settle out of court. Everybody was sure it would be litigated. My ex-spouse and I are now even friends. I sometimes go over to her house and watch our kids while she's at work. All of the hate and contention and all of the miserable tension are almost all gone - which is a big benefit to both us and our children. An amazing turn of events on all accounts. I have found that divorce lawyers generally come in two flavors: cheerleaders and those who keep you grounded and tell you like it is, whether you want to hear it or not. Jimmy is the latter. He will tell you the realities of your divorce from the start, whether you like it or not, and do absolutely everything he can to do the right thing for you and your family. My divorce ended exactly where Jimmy told me it would months earlier. My divorce was "the worst case possible" and it ended in "the best case possible." Hiring Jimmy Lefton is a complete no-brainer.

Posted by anonymous | November 06, 2025 | Hired Attorney | Divorce & Separation

Underprepared, Dismissive of concerns for physical safety

Like all divorce lawyers he over promised and under delivered. Not a good choice for a woman dealing with mild physical abuse as he dismissed my concerns about my physical safety. No I’m not the most abused woman in history, but Jimmy literally told me there was no way to divide property other than w...alking through the house with a man who had hit me multiple times and broke down a locked door to get to me. I repeatedly said that I could not do that and please stop suggesting that. He got very angry at me and told me to get another lawyer, so I did. Side note: It is absolutely possible to divide property without putting your physical safety at risk. But not with this attorney. I think he was overworked and underprepared for court.

See All Client Reviews

Jimmy Jay Lefton's Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse Jimmy
Holly Patricia Regoli headshot
Holly Regoli

Divorce and separation lawyer | Jan 03

Relationship: Other

"Mr. Lefton is highly respected in the community and I recommend him to take care of your legal needs."

David Wade Peck headshot
David Peck

Divorce and separation lawyer | Oct 12

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"Jimmy is an excellent family law attorney, both in the courtroom and with superlative collaborative skills when matters can be resolved outside a courtroom setting."

Chad G. Koop headshot
Chad Koop

Divorce and separation lawyer | Oct 01

Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter

"Jimmy is a smart, creative, and reasonable attorney when working in a collaborative manner. He works in a very respectful way while at the same time pushing his client's interests to the forefront. I have seen his ability to skillfully negotiate outside of court; however, I am also very aware of his ability to zealously litigate in the courtroom when necessary. Jimmy is an excellent attorney that I highly recommend."

Jacob Michael Kaufman headshot
Jacob Kaufman

Family lawyer | Jul 15

Relationship: Opposing Counsel on matter

"Jimmy is on my "A" list of attorneys to have cases with as opposing counsel. He zealously represents his clients and their best interests, but he is fair and will settle a case when it is in the best interest of his client and/or their family. He is not afraid to litigate a matter if a fair settlement is not on the table. Jimmy will listen to both sides and do his best to come up with a resolution that works for everyone because he truly cares for the overall well being of the family. Not many family law attorneys take this approach. As an attorney, my favorite quality of Jimmy is that he is an honest and no non-sense lawyer! He is one of the good guys that gives attorneys a good name!"

David Hershel Lefton headshot
David Lefton

Divorce and separation lawyer | Jun 11

Relationship: Family member

"Jimmy is my brother and law partner. Jimmy is an excellent attorney, loving family man, and an upstanding member of the legal and civic communities. Jimmy brings a caring, compassionate, genuine concern to all matters he handles. As reflected by his AVVO client comments, he truly loves and cares for clients and their objectives. Not only is Jimmy conscientious and timely in his work product, but he is also interested in making sure all of the details are handled. You cannot go wrong if you choose Jimmy to be your attorney for divorce or separation. I refer divorce matters to Jimmy without hesitation and highly recommend him."

Mark L. Newman headshot
Mark Newman

Divorce and separation lawyer | Jun 09

Relationship: Friend

"Jimmy is a childhood friend of mine and for the past several years one of my law partners. Jimmy is an excellent attorney, who truly cares about the needs of each of his clients. He is a great communicator, incredibly friendly, compassionate, and an excellent advocate for his clients. If you have a family law matter I highly recommend you call Jimmy to represent you."

View All Endorsements
Zachary David Smith headshot
Zachary Smith

Divorce and separation lawyer

Chad G. Koop headshot
Chad Koop

Divorce and separation lawyer

Jacob Michael Kaufman headshot
Jacob Kaufman

Family lawyer

Nancy Jane Dameron-Frazier headshot
Nancy Dameron-Frazier

Divorce and separation lawyer

Experience

Rating:  10.0 (Superb)

Honors

2025

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2024

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2021

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2020

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2019

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2018

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2017

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2017

Peer Review Rated, Martindale-Hubbell

2016

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers

2016

Peer Review Rated, Martindale-Hubbell

2015

Super Lawyer, Super Lawyers Magazine

Work Experience

2001 - Present

Partner, Barron Peck Bennie & Schlemmer

1999 - 2001

Partner, Katz & Lefton Co., L.P.A.

1997 - 1999

Attorney, Richard L. Katz, Co. L.P.A.

1995 - 1997

Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, Hamilton County Prosecutor's Office

1994 - 1995

Associate Attorney, Thomas A. Jackson & Associates

Associations

2012 - Present

Cincinnati Academy of Collaborative Professionals

Member

1994 - Present

Cincinnati Bar Association

1994 - Present

Ohio State Bar Association

Sample of Legal Cases

Islamic Marriage

Trial

Long Distance Parenting Time

Decision by the court

Grandparent Parenting Time

Settlement reached prior to trial

See More Legal Cases

Education

1993

Thomas M. Cooley Law School

Juris Doctor - Cum Laude

1990

Ohio State University

Bachelor of Arts

1986

Walnut Hills High School

Speaking Engagements

2011

In-House Seminar

How to Handle Divorce Cases in Ohio

Publications

2012

513Divorce.com Divorce Webstie

Languages

English

Activity

Avvo Rating

Our Rating is calculated using information the lawyer has included on their profile in addition to the information we collect from state bar associations and other organizations that license legal professionals. Attorneys who claim their profiles and provide Avvo with more information tend to have a higher rating than those who do not.

What determines Avvo Rating?
  • Experience & background Years licensed, work experience, education
  • Legal community recognition Peer endorsements, associations, awards
  • Legal thought leadership Publications, speaking engagements
  • Discipline Disciplinary information may not be comprehensive, or updated. We recommend that you always check a lawyer's disciplinary status with their respective state bar association before hiring them.
Avvo Rating Levels
10.0 - 9.0 Superb8.9 - 8.0 Excellent7.9 - 7.0 Very Good6.9 - 6.0 Good5.9 - 5.0 Average4.9 - 4.0 Concern3.9 - 3.0 Caution2.9 - 2.0 Strong Caution1.9 - 1.0 Extreme Caution