United States v. Air Force E-7
N/AOUTCOME: Retirement Saved
Osan AFB, Korea: Air Force E-7 – June 2011 Charges: Resisting apprehension, Assault on a commissioned officer (x3), Drunk and disorderly conduct. Maximum Sentence: Dishonorable Discharge, 10 ... years and six months in confinement, total forfeitures, reduction to E-1, Federal felony conviction, Loss of military retirement. The allegations in this case surround misconduct on an ITT sponsored wine tasting tour around Korea. Our client, a male Air Force MstSgt with 18 years of service, became heavily intoxicated after drinking too much wine and got into an altercation with two Air Force officers on the bus ride home while suffering from an alcohol induced blackout. Unfortunately for our client, this altercation lead to him punching the chief of justice (female and senior prosecutor at Osan, AFB) in the face, assaulting a registered nurse who was attempting to break up the fight, and then resisting apprehension when OSI agents attempted to arrest him as the bus arrived at Osan, AFB. This was a very difficult case from the onset, beyond the fact that the victim was a female, an officer and the senior prosecutor at Osan, AFB, there were nearly a dozen witnesses who saw the altercation. Even against the odds, we refused to roll over and plea the case. After interviewing all of the witnesses and conducting a thorough Article 32 hearing, the defense learned that the senior prosecutor might have actually started the fight and assaulted our client first, after losing her temper and yelling at our client. This provided not only provided us with a self-defense claim but also a divestiture defense against the senior prosecutor (that she divested herself of her rank because of her actions). To further this defense, we had an expert in pharmacology brought on as a member of the defense team to testify regarding the affects of alcohol in order to negate the specific intent aspects of the charges. This case ultimately went to trial in front of a jury and we utilized the self-defense defense, divestiture and also alleged that the OSI agents used excessive force on our client when arresting him (they broke out his front two teeth). At the end of a week long trial, our client was found not guilty of resisting arrest, not guilty of assault on a commissioned officer (the chief of justice), but guilty to the lesser included offense of assault consummated by battery, drunk and disorderly conduct and the assault on the registered nurse who was attempting to break up the fight. During the sentencing portion of the trial, we assembled extensive materials in extenuation and mitigation in order to save our client’s retirement. The government asked for extensive confinement and a dishonorable discharge. Based on the evidence we put on at trial and the sentencing case, the panel only sentenced our client to a two-grade reduction and 30 days confinement. No punitive discharge was given and our client will be permitted to retire. By trying this case and litigating to mitigate, we were able to save this senior NCO’s retirement, which was calculated to have a value of over one million dollars.