Matthew M Thomas

Born and raised in Vero Beach, Florida, Matthew M. Thomas built his career on a simple premise: preparation is respect — for the client, for the courtroom, and for the craft.

Matthew is a Florida Bar Board Certified Civil Trial Attorney, a distinction held by approximately one percent of lawyers in the state. He is AV® Preeminent™ rated by Martindale-Hubbell and has been recognized as a Super Lawyers Rising Star for five consecutive years (2017–2021) before being continually recognized in this capacity and one of the most notable litigators throughout Florida. Early in his career, he was named the first partner of the firm founded by Joseph H. Graves—at age thirty.

Credentials, however, tell only part of the story.

Matthew’s practice is trial-focused and strategy-driven. He represents individuals and families in complex, high-stakes litigation involving wrongful death, catastrophic injury, motorcycle crashes, trucking and commercial vehicle collisions, traumatic brain injuries, premises liability, negligent security, product liability, nursing home negligence, insurance coverage disputes, and bad faith litigation. He has personally recovered nearly one hundred million dollars for his clients and has obtained significant verdicts throughout the state of Florida.

He is admitted in Florida state courts and the United States District Courts for the Southern and Middle Districts of Florida and has been admitted pro hac vice in multiple jurisdictions nationwide.

What distinguishes Matthew in the courtroom is not volume—it is discipline. He approaches each case as both a challenge and a responsibility, often accepting matters other lawyers deemed too difficult or too uncertain. His method is grounded in three principles: preparation, competitiveness, and creative strategy. In practice, that means mastering the record, anticipating the defense, and identifying the overlooked issue that changes the trajectory of a case.

Clients often come to Matthew after feeling unheard or underestimated. His approach is direct: listen carefully, evaluate rigorously, and litigate without hesitation when justice requires it.

Long before law school, Matthew’s instinct was to stand up for others. He served as varsity captain of his high school soccer team and received the Hugh O’Brian Youth Leadership Award. Throughout college and law school, he sought diverse professional and academic experiences, earning Dean’s List honors and recognition for his writing. Those early lessons in leadership and accountability continue to shape his practice today.

Many adversaries have entered the courtroom confident in their stature as Goliaths of industry—only to find that in trial work, scale gives way to preparation and disciplined advocacy.

Matthew believes trial work is both analytical and human. The law is technical; injury is personal. Effective advocacy requires fluency in both.

When asked for a quote that reflects his philosophy, he often cites Theodore Roosevelt:

“The unforgivable crime is soft hitting. Do not hit at all if it can be avoided; but never hit softly.”

In the courtroom, Matthew does not strike often. But when he does, it is deliberate.

He is an active member of the Indian River County Bar Association, The Florida Bar, the American Bar Association, and the Florida Justice Association, and remains committed to serving his community and advancing the standards of civil trial practice.