Allstate v. Pacific Speciality
Sep 11, 2013OUTCOME: Defense verdict
Allstate and Mercury defended a mutual insured in a nasty neighbor dispute. PSIC declined a defense on the basis that the insureds conduct did not constitute an accident and thus it did not have a dut ... y to defend. Allstate sued PSIC for contribution of defense fees of over $200,000. Following a bench trial the trial court ruled PSIC did not have a duty to defend because the insured's conduct was not accidental.
