Sheldon W. Boyce Jr.'s Reviews

Avvo Review Score

4.8 /5.0

12 Client Reviews

Showing 1 - 1 of 1 review | Arbitration

Posted by Scott | February 24, 2026 | Hired Attorney | Arbitration

Disappointed

Nearly 5 years after my cycling accident, the case against NYS is finally settled and closed. Opting for an arbitration settlement vs a trail was both frustrating and disappointing. While very impressed with the firm’s paralegal who clearly knows her stuff, (hence the reason for the 2 stars) my exper...ience with counsel soured. I ultimately decided to settle through arbitration. Unfortunately I was unpleasantly surprised to learn, after the fact, there was one significant factor that would negatively impact the final settlement. A factor that was NEVER properly communicated to me by counsel, which counsel later denied (basically calling me a liar). Glad to be alive, case closed, time to move on….

See Full Review Collapse Review

See All Client Reviews

Sheldon W. Boyce Jr.'s Lawyer Endorsements

Endorse Sheldon

Richard Dever

Personal injury lawyer | Nov 10

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I strongly endorse Sheldon Boyce. He is a highly skilled personal injury attorney. He is dedicated to his clients and personally handles each case."

Stephen Bird

Personal injury lawyer | Oct 06

Relationship: Worked together on matter

"I endorse this lawyer. He is not only an exellent attorney but, as is critical to me, also a really good person. When another attoney referred Sheldon to me on a personal [family] matter, we had never met. Nevertheless, Sheldon put aside his work, answered my questions and then commenced working on my case. Despite the settlement of my case having involved a large reward for my client, and my consistent efforts to fully pay Sheldon for his work, he would not accept a penny. Contrary to my thoughts on the settlement amount, Sheldon said the reward, of which neither he nor I had any involvement in obtaining, was not so big considering the severity of the injuries and my client's young age. I had never before experienced such a level of "professional courtesy," while my ciient's life was made much better by Sheldon's professional knowledge and personal integrity. I have since referred many cases outside my area of expertise to Sheldon, always my first choice."

Michael Waddington

Personal injury lawyer | Jun 03

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse Sheldon. He is a highly skilled attorney that is well respected in the legal community."

Edward Fiandach

Personal injury lawyer | Mar 07

Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

"I endorse this lawyer. Shelly is one of the stars of our community."

Robert Brenna

Personal injury lawyer | Jan 21

Relationship: Co-worker

"Throughout 34 years of practicing law, I've shared my Firm letterhead with only two attorneys- my father, and Shelly Boyce. I am amazed at his ability, and humbled that he is my partner. His integrity is unparalleled. I am admittedly biased, but I cannot in good conscience pass up this opportunity to state how I truly feel about this man. I proudly endorse this lawyer."

See More Lawyer Endorsements See Less Lawyer Endorsements View All Endorsements

Martin Philippone

Real estate lawyer