Four Years of Trust, Only to Be Met with Disrespect, Poor Communication, and Unexpected Settlement Deductions
I am extremely disappointed with my experience with Dino J. Domina and his law firm. After more than four years of trusting this office with my personal injury case, I never expected to be treated with such disrespect, especially by the owner himself.
My accident occurred on May 26, 2022. As a ful...l-time dental office manager, college student, and single mother of two young children, I made significant sacrifices throughout this case. I attended physical therapy, occupational therapy, chiropractic appointments, and neurological evaluations. I traveled from Middletown Road to Fordham Road three times a week, frequently leaving work early and paying for Uber transportation out of my own pocket. I followed instructions, provided medical documentation, and participated in court proceedings.
Communication with the office was frustrating from the beginning. I experienced unanswered messages, delays, and difficulty reaching staff. When Dino contacted me again in 2025, he acknowledged that the previous receptionist had mishandled my case and that it had essentially been lost or overlooked. I trusted his explanation and continued cooperating.
In September 2026, Dino discussed a $17,500 settlement with me. My understanding from our verbal conversation was that the attorney’s 33⅓% fee and approximately $500 in additional expenses would be deducted, and that my medical treatment had been covered through no-fault insurance.
Based on that understanding, I signed and notarized the settlement release and returned it on October 1, 2026.
On November 11, 2026, Dino informed me that I had supposedly missed a medical examination years earlier and that medical expenses would now have to come out of my settlement.
When I questioned why this had never been explained before I signed, he denied our previous conversation as I remembered it. I asked where I would have gotten those specific figures if they had not been discussed.
Rather than offering a clear explanation, he raised his voice, interrupted me, and repeatedly addressed me by the wrong name. He initially called me Jennifer and admitted he had contacted the wrong person.
When I questioned the medical deductions, his response was essentially, “This is coming out of your portion, and that’s that.” He also stated, “You don’t want to pay your medical expenses? No problem. I’ll let them know.”
I NEVER refused to pay legitimate medical expenses. I simply asked for an explanation and supporting documentation.
When I explained the time, money, and sacrifices I had invested, he responded, “What did you invest?”
That was incredibly insulting after years of paying transportation expenses, missing work, arranging childcare, and attending appointments.
I requested an in-person meeting to review my documents and settlement breakdown. He told me it would happen on his time, when he was available, and ultimately hung up on me.
I had barely spoken directly with Dino throughout this case, which made his behavior even more disappointing.
I want to acknowledge that Melanie, the attorney who helped prepare me for proceedings, was helpful. My complaint is primarily about Dino’s communication, dismissive attitude, and handling of my settlement questions.
As of this review, I have not received my settlement funds or a complete itemized breakdown explaining the disputed medical deductions.
I have emails and documents dating back to 2022 demonstrating my cooperation throughout this case.
I am not asking for special treatment. I am asking for transparency, accountability, and basic professional respect.
Clients should never feel intimidated or disrespected for asking questions about their own money. After more than four years, I expected much better.