Can a long term disability company (Hartford) deny a claim if you have been approved for SSDI?

Yes. The definition of disability is generally different. The award of SSDI, however, is compelling evidence in support of disability.

Your boyfriend will likely have to appeal the adverse benefit determination.

Do I have to pay taxes on income from long term disability that I am now repaying?

You should request an amended w-2 from the insurance company since the earlier disability payment was taxable.

What type of an attorney do I need to file an appeal with a Private Disability Claim (employer insurance)?

You should consult with an attorney that focuses their practice on ERISA disability claims. ERISA is very specific about timing, information to...