LEHR V LIVS
Feb 12, 2026OUTCOME: The jury found that Long Island Veterinary Specialists departed from the standard of care.
Background of the Matter This matter concerns Oscar, a 14-year-old Border Collie mix owned by Harold Lehr. Oscar had longstanding osteoarthritis and underwent successful total hip replacements in 2016 ... and 2017. Despite his age and orthopedic history, he remained ambulatory and active. MRI Procedure and Extended Anesthesia On October 22, 2018, Mr. Lehr brought Oscar to Long Island Veterinary Specialists (“LIVS”) for evaluation of a right forelimb limp. Dr. Catherine Loughin recommended a Dual-Zone MRI of the cervical spine and shoulder, which was performed on October 29, 2018. During the procedure, Oscar remained under anesthesia for approximately four to five hours, significantly longer than the typical 60–90 minutes, according to plaintiff’s expert. Post-Procedure Decline Following the MRI, Oscar developed severe hind limb paraparesis, tetra-ataxia, decreased anal tone, and urinary incontinence. On November 4, 2018, he was transferred to The Animal Medical Center, where a neurologist concluded his condition was likely related to a vascular event or spinal hypoperfusion associated with prolonged anesthesia. Oscar never regained the ability to walk and was euthanized on November 17, 2018. Mr. Lehr thereafter commenced this veterinary malpractice action. Emotional Impact Medical records reflected Mr. Lehr’s distress following the procedure, including complaints that Oscar appeared worse after admission and frustration over communication with LIVS staff. Trial Posture Plaintiff testified on his own behalf and presented testimony from a veterinary expert and a representative of the pet care service that assisted Oscar in his final days. Defendants presented testimony from Dr. Loughin and a defense veterinary expert. Pre-trial litigation included multiple motions in limine, including the unsuccessful defense motion seeking to preclude plaintiff’s expert testimony.
