Greenidge v. NJM, et al. (Docket No. A-0602-19T3)
Nov 16, 2020OUTCOME: Reversed and remanded in favor of the Appellant
Our firm represented the Plaintiff-Appellant in the matter before the Appellate Division. This case involves litigation commencing after the settlement of a personal injury lawsuit. Plaintiff appeal ... s from a September 27, 2019 order granting defendant New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Company's (NJM) motion for reconsideration and dismissing her complaint with prejudice. Defendant failed to make a proper motion to dismiss the complaint for failure to state a claim—as the Rules of Court require—and cannot do so informally in a brief supporting a motion for reconsideration; the judge failed to state findings of fact or conclusions of law; and plaintiff was not given the opportunity for oral argument. We therefore reverse and remand to allow defendant to file a motion anew. Outcome: The Court held that the trial judge abused her discretion by failing to provide findings of fact or conclusions of law, as required by Rule 1:7-4(a). The link to the Per Curium opinion can be accessed here: https://njcourts.gov/attorneys/assets/opinions/appellate/unpublished/a0602-19.pdf
