Avvo Review Score

4.7 /5.0

23 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (23) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 1 - 5 of 9 reviews | Lawsuits & Disputes

Posted by Craig | September 08, 2025 | Hired Attorney

Exceptional

Michael is truly exceptional. From start to finish, they handled my case with professionalism, compassion, and determination. They took the time to explain every step of the process, always keeping me informed and making sure I felt comfortable. Their attention to detail and commitment to achieving t...he best outcome for me was clear from day one. Thanks to their expertise, I was able to get the settlement I deserved. I highly recommend Michael Carestia to anyone in need of a personal injury attorney—you will be in the best hands possible.

Posted by Amy | August 04, 2025 | Hired Attorney

Wonderful Experience

I had a great experience working with the Law Office of Michael P. Carestia on my case. They were professional, responsive, and clearly knowledgeable in their field. The team kept me informed throughout the process and worked diligently to maximize my financial outcome. I truly appreciated their atte...ntion to detail and commitment to my case. Highly recommend.

Posted by Zachary | October 17, 2018 | Hired Attorney

Lawyer For Life

Mr. Carestia started with six or seven cases and has grown it into a very large firm with over 1,500 cases. Despite that, I had access to his cell phone number and he was willing to meet with both myself and my husband in person on a Saturday to explain the details of my case as his attitude has bee...n that no matter how large his law firm grows, he does not want to lose the personal touch with respect to customer service and that each individual should feel that they are important because they are. We were more than happy with the results that he achieved but more importantly, both my husband and myself were amazed by the fact that he would make time for us on a Saturday given the size of the practice and the hours that he works. He is my lawyer for life

Posted by Steven | July 09, 2018 | Hired Attorney

Honest & Benevolent

My family and I were devastated after a serious injury to my son. I instructed Mr. Carestia that one of the insurance companies had indicated that they would pay $100,000.00 which was this insurance company’s policy limit but there were two other companies who had coverage for the accident. Mr. Ca...restia indicated to me that if the insurance company put in writing that they were intending to pay the $100,000.00 to me, he would get the money from the insurance company and only take a fee on any settlement money over the first $100,000.00 and the full $100,000.00 was ours to keep. There are very few honest people like that in the world and to find one that was an attorney and willing to give up $33,333.33 in fees on the first $100,000.00 of the case amazed my family even more.

Posted by Chris | July 02, 2018 | Hired Attorney

Best of the Best

I am reading these older reviews and can not believe they are for this office. I was referred to Mr. Carestia from one of his prior clients (my best friend) after my run-in with an 18-wheeler. From the initial call to receiving my settlement check, I was treated with respect and professionalism. My c...ase manager went above and beyond to keep me in the loop the entire time. They also sent out someone to meet with me since I was having issues locating a vehicle to come to their office. I highly recommend the Law Office of Michael Carestia.

See All Client Reviews