Avvo Review Score

4.5 /5.0

65 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (65) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 1 - 5 of 65 reviews

Posted by anonymous | July 10, 2026 | Hired Attorney

Don't use

I used him in Rockland County for my divorce. He was awful. Dropped me for no reason and referred me to an even worse attorney Eric Thorsen. Good ole boys.

Posted by anonymous | June 22, 2026

He's not what you think.

'll give you a REAL review since that's apparently a concern for you. You completely broke my heart and this is something you just shrug off. I have spent YEARS of my life offering literally all of myself to you, at your feet and it is never enough. And if you never wanted it to begin with all you ha...d to say was "NO." For those reading this that are not JS, I please know that this man has caused an insurmountable amount of emotional pain on a young woman who just simply wanted to know him and share beautiful things with him, such as her love for dogs, literature, all that is deeper. I flew to NYC for a day last year with finances I didn't have just to finally meet him because I had been trying for so long and every time we attempted to, it was always met with some excuse, over and over and over again. I got to see him for about thirty minutes. I first conversed with him on my 30th birthday. I am now almost 33. I will never understand why you couldn't have just told me you were interested. But instead, you fed into everything I shared, but refused to give your all. And it completely messed with my head and I will never be the same after that. I want the world to know the other side of you; everything that is not the attorney.

Posted by anonymous | August 27, 2025 | Hired Attorney

More chaos than!

More Chaos Than Clarity I regret hiring James Sexton for my divorce. His own website describes him as “the sociopath you want on your side,” and I should have taken that as a warning. In my experience, his style was aggressive to the point of being overwhelming, and it felt like he thrived more on... stirring conflict than on finding resolution. At $750+ an hour, I expected clarity and strategy. Instead, I often felt drained — emotionally and financially. His approach may work for people who want a fight at all costs, but if you’re looking for compassion, calm guidance, or someone who will de-escalate a difficult situation, I would strongly recommend looking elsewhere.

Posted by Rubina | May 27, 2025 | Hired Attorney

Exactly Who You Want Representing You

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I was honestly flabbergasted after reading through all the reviews—both good and bad—because my experience with James has been nothing short of excellent. He has been incredibly gracious, mindful of costs, and an absolute pleasure to work with during one of the most difficult times in my ...life. I hired James because I wanted a bulldog in my corner—and that’s exactly what I got. He’s proven in so many ways that he is not greedy, not impatient, and truly cares about doing right by his clients. That said, don’t waste his time or yours—he’s direct, focused, and great at what he does. Try to get to know the guy, and you’ll find a huge heart beneath the tough exterior. He is genuinely grateful for clients who care about him in return—and he gives that energy right back. I feel confident and prepared as we approach the final act of my divorce, and I’m grateful to have James leading the charge. I wouldn’t want anyone else!

Posted by anonymous | April 08, 2025 | Hired Attorney

Start with Jim

I cannot recommend Jim Sexton highly enough! Navigating a delicate custody situation with a narcissist is an overwhelming and emotionally taxing experience, but Jim handled it with absolute professionalism, expertise, and unwavering support. From day one, they made me feel comfortable and confident, ...ensuring I was informed and empowered every step of the way. What truly sets Jim apart is their ability to balance strength and strategy while maintaining positive relationships with opposing counsel and judges. Their reputation, integrity, and deep knowledge of family law made all the difference in achieving the best possible outcome. If you're seeking an attorney who will advocate fiercely for you while keeping the process as smooth as possible, look no further. Thank you, Jim, for your dedication and for making an incredibly difficult situation manageable. You are truly one of the best! - KMB

See All Client Reviews