Avvo Review Score

4.9 /5.0

38 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (38) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 26 - 28 of 28 reviews | Advocacy

Posted by Dennis | September 12, 2011

Clayton Simms saved our son

Clayton Simms Saved our Son Our son was charged with a bizarre kidnapping and was facing three aggravated felony charges of 15 years to life each. A week later he was charged with an equally bizarre robbery and kidnapping that added another five charges of 15 years to life each. He was incarcera...ted without bail for 14 months and lost 30 pounds while suffering through the jail diet. In the first case the investigating detective and prosecutor coached and coaxed the plaintiff to testify, and offered the co-defendant pre-trial release if he would testify against our son. The detective was then honored by the police department as Officer of the Month for “putting a violent felon behind bars.” In the second case the investigating detective tried to get a confession by claiming he had two eye-witness victims who positively identified him as the bandit. The following month this detective was also honored as Officer of the Month. Clearly a desperate situation. Our son was looking at a lifetime in prison and the loss of any opportunity to raise his beautiful children. We called Clayton Simms for help. During the first trial Clayton demonstrated his exceptional mastery of the criminal law courtroom environment by painting a picture of the plaintiff as a willing participant in an event that was little more than a family fight: she willingly got into the car; she got back out and went back to the apartment to get her phone and cigarettes; she argued with the two people in the front seat while the defendant got out of the car and went into a restaurant to get a soft drink. He painted a picture of the authorities hardly believing her story; the plaintiff contributed to the air of unbelievability by showing up from prison to testify, wearing prison garb and constrained by leg irons and handcuffs. Thanks to Clayton efforts, the felony charges were thrown out and our son received a “hand slap” of two misdemeanor convictions. During the second trial Clayton aggressively went after the two plaintiffs, leading to the admission by one of the two plaintiffs that he could not identify the robber as our son. Clayton argued that the identification had been tainted by observation of the defendant’s mug shot on the internet. Additionally, two alibi witnesses testified that the defendant was with them the entire night of the supposed robbery. Clayton introduced the two alibi witnesses and walked them through the confirmation that they were indeed with the defendant the entire night of the supposed robbery. The jury deliberated and returned NOT GUILTY verdicts on all counts. Thanks to the determined efforts of Clayton Simms, our son is now a free man. We owe a great debt of gratitude to this outstanding attorney.

Posted by R.Manz | June 17, 2011

Clayton Simms is the defense attorney you need!

I recently was found not guilty in jury trial of DUI and other serious charges including causing a car accident, fleeing the scene and failure to control my vehicle and failure to leave my information at a sonic in West Valley City. Without Clayton Simms I would of not have won my case. This man work...s in only one gear, and that is AGGRESSIVE CRIMINAL DEFENSE! I recommend his counsel and expert legal advise to anyone serious about having a chance in winning their case or getting you the best result possible. If you are struggling financially and have considered obtaining a public defender to handle your case, I recommend that you NOT trust your future and good name for an attorney that is not interested in defending you at all. I can't say that all public legal defenders are bad to work with, but the ones that I had mishandle my case for 10 months was the worst expirience i ever had! They are not there to save you money! They are there to save the courts money by convincing folks to give up their rights! IF YOU DO NOT KNOW YOUR RIGHTS, YOU HAVE NO RIGHTS AT ALL!!! Talk to Clayton about your case. I am so thankful that i had him in my corner. West Valley Prosecuters will have to change the way they persue certain cases because of Clayton Simms!!!

Posted by Beth | April 24, 2011

Criminal Case Defense for a Sensitive Situation

Our family pooled funds to hire Clayton to represent our brother who got himself into some "trouble" online. Other than do some curiosity-based searches for some stuff online that we (and he) are embarrassed to admit, my brother is a fantastic man, a great father, a wonderful uncle, and a hard workin...g citizen. His out-of-character online indiscretion was flagged during a federally-funded, internet sting operation. Due to the high-profile nature of the sting operation, and the media attention that the prosecution was enjoying for their pathetic "crack-down" efforts, we don't believe that the prosecution ever had the intention of seeking "justice" in this case. They weren't interested in the punishment fitting the crime in this case. They completely ignored the fact that that their extensive investigation into his family and activities yielded ZERO improprieties of any sort. They grand-standed and flat out lied about the details of the case in the courtroom. They wanted to throw the book at one case in an attempt to hide the fact that their expensive, publicly funded attempts to thwart unsavory online activities aren't effective at catching the REAL perpetrators of heinous online crimes. Clayton did an admirable job defending our brother in court, and managed to convince our judge that our brother did not deserve the maximum (15 yr) sentence in a maximum security facility. All things considered, we believe that Clayton fought for and got us the best possible result. Clayton is adept at handling cases of a sensitive nature, and also delicately handled a "high maintenance" family-of-client. We very much appreciated his patience with us, and his work on our brother's behalf. Clayton isn't the kind of lawyer they make jokes about -- he will really do the job you need him to do. We can recommend him wholeheartedly.

See All Client Reviews