Avvo Review Score

4.7 /5.0

50 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (50) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 1 - 5 of 11 reviews | Responsiveness

Posted by Bree | October 25, 2025 | Hired Attorney

Criminal Justice At Its Best!

I highly recommend Attorney Rosenthall for anyone in need of a skilled and dedicated criminal defense lawyer. He handles cases with professionalism, compassion, and an impressive command of the law. He believes in your innocence and works tirelessly to prove the truth. Thanks to his expertise and per...sistence, our case was dismissed. I’ll always be grateful for his integrity, responsiveness, and commitment to justice.

Posted by Gagan | October 18, 2022 | Hired Attorney

Overpriced and Incompetent - Worst experience ever

I hired Mr. Rosenthall because of his previous experience as a prosecutor. This was one of the worst mistakes I ever made. It was my first charge and initially I had consulted a different practice who straight off the bat told me they would get it reduced for a "lesser charge" for $3500. Instead, I p...aid Mr. Rosenthall $7500 because I thought he was more qualified and would fight harder for me. He was very lazy and avoidant after I cut him the check for $7500. I E-mailed and called him constantly for weeks and he only returned my E-mail a week before my court date. He never even attempted to obtain video tape of the incident, which is easily available. I had 2 meetings with him, the consultation and the follow up meeting when I gave him the check. He never returned my calls or E-mails up until a week before the court date. He literally just showed up to court, offered me the plea bargain and that was it. The plea bargain, you ask? My charge was reduced to the same "lesser charge" the first practice guaranteed. Since my defamation, I've dealt with serious financial and social hardships, which led me to become severely depressed. Do yourself a favor and hire somebody that actually cares.

Posted by John | August 23, 2022 | Hired Attorney

John

Not a competent attorney. Poor representation. $2500.00 up front and was he was more interested in speaking to his former colleagues at my arraignment. Did not return my emails nor telephone messages to his office during the process. I was on twelve month probation and never heard from him at all dur...ing that time. Wouldn’t return my telephone messages nor emails. Should have chosen a court appointed attorney. Would not recommend him.

Posted by Charles | August 31, 2021 | Hired Attorney

Got all charges dropped. Highly recommend

I had a need to hire an attorney to fight bogus criminal charges filed against me. Faraji was very patient in explaining the legal process to me and set up a payment arrangement. His flat fee is very reasonable with appeal included if needed-I didn't have to use appeal since the charges were droppe...d. He was very responsive with questions I had and acted professionally in court to get the bogus charges dropped.

Posted by anonymous | March 06, 2021 | Hired Attorney

Highly recommend

I highly recommend Mr. Rosenthall, he is very professional and very good at explain things in detail. Also, thanks for keeping us abreast through the entire process. I can’t thank you enough for helping my son with is criminal case because this could have gone in a different direction.

See All Client Reviews