Avvo Review Score

4.7 /5.0

50 Client Reviews

Filter Avvo Reviews (50) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.

Showing 11 - 15 of 23 reviews | Professionalism

Posted by anonymous | March 06, 2021 | Hired Attorney

Highly recommend

I highly recommend Mr. Rosenthall, he is very professional and very good at explain things in detail. Also, thanks for keeping us abreast through the entire process. I can’t thank you enough for helping my son with is criminal case because this could have gone in a different direction.

Posted by David | September 16, 2020 | Hired Attorney

Fantastic COVID courtroom results

Mr. Rosenthal handled an unsusually tense courtroom scenario with remote prosecutors and made his points concise and passionate. I would definitely use him again.

Posted by anonymous | August 04, 2020 | Hired Attorney

Excellent Criminal Defense Representation of a Fellow Criminal Defense Attorney

As an attorney myself, I can only offer exceptional plaudits for Faraji's performance throughout the course of my defense. Without going into specifics, I can just say I was impressed by Faraji's ability to communicate and focus on the issues at hand, while expertly avoiding pitfalls I would have fal...len into if I had represented myself. He had a clear strategy as the trial unfolded, and knew how to appropriately cross examine my accuser in order to get what he needed in order to deliver an acquittal following the defense case-in-chief. He is smart, efficient, and confident in the courtroom. Further, his pre-trial advice and expectations were clear, and I never felt that he did not take my case seriously. I hope I never have to hire him again, but I guarantee if another issue comes up in my life in this regard, Faraji will be the first person I call.

Posted by anonymous | July 22, 2020 | Hired Attorney

Dealt with multiple felonies and misdemeanors

I contacted Mr. Rosenthall after my daughter was charged with multiple drug felonies and misdemeanors after they were found in her car, though not all were my daughter's. She also was charged with another felony as well. I left a message and he immediately responded on a Sunday and walked us throu...gh the process that would be unfolding over the next several months. He was calm, took his time with us and communicated clearly to both myself and my teenage daughter. We hired Mr. Rosenthall and he counseled us through multiple court visits, the changes happening in the courts with the new election, various prosecutors, and explained our options at each step. In the end, my daughter had 1 felony and misdemeanor dismissed and the others will be dismissed after successfully completing two programs. I cannot be more thankful for the guidance and skill he provided and for providing my daughter with the opportunity to move forward in life with a new slate but one based on the knowledge and responsibility of her actions. I would highly recommend Mr. Rosenthall to anyone faced with the his areas of specialization.

Posted by Jznae | August 30, 2019 | Hired Attorney

worst first experience

My lawyer was negligent when it came to my case. I was forced to take a plea I really didn’t want to take. I was informed multiple times that I wouldn’t be going to jail at all, and I ended up getting sentenced to 3 months. It was my first offense, I’m full time in college and had a full time job. Mr.... Rosenthall charged me $7,500. I’ve never hired a lawyer before, but he told me this was a normal amount. The prosecutor offered me and my 2 co-defendants (whom had priors and public defenders) the same plea, without looking at any evidence. They offered 4 months jail time or 2 felony convictions. Mr. Rosenthall STRONGLY advised me not to take either of those. I informed my lawyer I did not want jail time or any felonies. My lawyer had the evidence for 2 months, and despite my many requests, he never allowed me to view the footage or any evidence he had in his possession. He told me repeatedly that I was safe, I had nothing to worry about, I wasn’t going to jail, he would get me off completely. I figured for that amount of money he charged me, I should have a successful outcome. 2 months later we went to court again, and he told me this was the last court date, we’d get no more continuances, I’d have to make a decision today. He stated that they changed the prosecutor at the last minute, and it was someone brand new who knew nothing of my case. He then told me they were offering 3 months jail time, or the felonies. I asked him what did he think I should do, if I should take it to trial. My lawyer told me, it’s up to me, whatever I decide, but we wouldn’t win at trial so I need to take the 3 months. I didn’t understand how for $7,500 my lawyer only negotiated a 1 month difference plea, than what was originally offered with a public defender. I asked if he could negotiate probation, restitution, house arrest, anything other than jail time. My lawyer said I’d have to take the felonies if I didn’t want to go to jail, he said the jail time wouldn’t be that bad, I’d be out in no time. Only had to do 6 weeks. I was afraid of getting a worse conviction or a higher jail sentence as mr. Rosenthall told me I would get if I didn’t take the plea, so I took the plea. I strongly believe my lawyer did not fight for me to the best of his ability as she should have, I trusted him 100%. As a result, I lost my job, my home due to not being able to afford my rent and I have to drop out of college until I’m able to afford it. I used my financial aid money in order to pay him, I went to jail and lost everything. My 3 co defendants deals they received were probation, another got a 2 month jail sentence, and the 3rd one got community service with no jail time, all with public defenders. I got sentenced to 3 months on just one misdemeanor petty larceny with a $7,500 lawyer. I fired my public defender in hopes of a better outcome, and I wish I kept him. I received a warrant during court, and he stated he was going to come down with me to the magistre, Mr. Rosenthall never showed up, nor was able to bond me out or contact my family to post my bond. I feel like I was just a simple transaction to Mr. Rosenthall. He rarely answered my phone calls, and didn’t provide me with any of my case information. Long story short, please hire at your own risk. I got the same plea for $7500 that could’ve been gotten with a public defender. There was no fight or concern for my case.

Faraji Rosenthall

Replied last April 18, 2019

Ms. Lyons, There appears to be a significant misunderstanding about what happened in your case and what options were available to you. Please feel free to contact me at your convenience. As you are aware, you were facing several felony charges related to multiple incidents. The plea deal I negotiated allowed you to avoid becoming a convicted felon in that all felony charges were dismissed or reduced. My office is, and always has been, open to you anytime Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday (without appointment) to view the security footage, police reports and witness statements from every store involved in your cases. At that time, i will also be happy to show you the record from the cases of the other individuals charged and demonstrate that you clearly received a far better outcome than the others. The only person facing charges as extensive as yours pled to multiple felonies. The others were only implicated in a fraction of the charges you were facing. I’m sincerely disappointed the six weeks was so disruptive to your life. Jail is by definition a jarring and awful outcome that I seek to find every possible way to avoid for all of my clients. When someone hires me I fully understand that they are trusting me with their freedom, future and health and I in no way ever trivialize that responsibility. I would absolutely never minimize my efforts or do anything to allow any of my clients to suffer unnecessarily. Anytime I advise a client to take a plea deal that will result in jail time it is only after every possible other option has been exhausted and when the plea deal presents the best possible opportunity for the client moving forward based upon the evidence in the case. Please let me know if Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday is not convenient for you and I will happily schedule an appointment outside those hours to review the files.

See All Client Reviews