Overall Rating
This is an aggregated review score of Avvo and Lawyers.com reviews.

5.0 /5.0

392 Client Reviews

Avvo

5.0

(388)

Lawyers.com

5.0

(4 )

 See client reviews from Lawyers.com
Filter Avvo Reviews (388) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.
Star rating
5 stars 382 4 stars 5
3 stars 0
2 stars 1
1 star 0
Practice Areas
Speeding & Traffic Ticket (194) Criminal Defense (166) DUI & DWI (105) Lawsuits & Disputes (34) Car Accidents (13) Drug Crime (8) Expungement (7) Immigration (6) Administrative Law (4) Domestic Violence (4) Juvenile (4) Litigation (4) Appeals (2) Violent Crime (2) Insurance (1) State, Local And Municipal Law (1) Trucking Accident (1)
What Clients Mention
Case Results (338) Advocacy (198) Recommendation (178) Practice Area Knowledge (119) Professionalism (113) Responsiveness (91) Cost of Services (84) Communication Style (82) Character & Conduct (58) General Knowledge (57) Trustworthiness (49) Staff & Support (37) Compassion (35) Punctuality (11) Payment Plans (3) Free Consultations (2)

Showing 51 - 55 of 84 reviews | Cost of Services

Posted by anonymous | December 01, 2014

Highly Recommended Lawyer

I was falsely charged with Burglary not to long ago and so I knew I had to get a lawyer that had experience in these matters. I went to a couple of lawyers before meeting Thomas, however, I just did not feel like they would represent me well as they showed no care. Meeting Thomas was a godsend as he ...looked me in the eye the whole time , asked the right questions, went through what can be expected and more importantly believed in me. I also liked how he charged only a flat fee rate for the duration of the case. And the fee was very affordable. The same day I met him I made my decision. From then on, we mostly communicated by email. And yes, he does reply very promptly. The only thing that kind of bothered me was that I had to be the one who had to request for updates and any changes in court dates. I actually wasted a day off from my job because Thomas and his secretary failed to notify me earlier. Another little tidbit that frustrated me was that Thomas did not show up in the first court hearing but instead his associate (which I had no idea until I called). He did show up in the second and last court hearing. Yet, the results of the case overshadow any little complaints I mentioned. He made a deal with the other lawyer to reduce the burglary charge to just an ordinance which is basically just a ticket/fine. I could not be happier with this result. Thanks Thomas!

Posted by anonymous | November 26, 2014

A True lifesaver!!

Getting charged with a DUI is the most embarrassing and scary ordeal which scars you for the rest of your life(background checks in my line of work are very common). it really humbles you and calls for a rude awakening to make better lifestyle changes. I reached out to Thomas Carroll on a Sunday m...orning during labor day weekend and explained that i had been charged with a DUI and he explained patiently about the things he can expect once I engaged his services(one flat rate). His staff was very cooperative in communicating effectively the needs and expectations as a client. I had two summons to appear on court(in NJ) but did not have to be present in both the occasions(as i was out of state and would have been a big hassle for me to miss work for it). Thomas was very patient and professional in explaining every documented question I had for him both via email (replies from him were in less than 20 minute duration and directly answered my questions) and phone conversations and there was no extra fees for any of this. these conversations made me and my family very comfortable in spite of the sediousness of the situation as it is very easy to be anxious about the forthcoming's. we engaged the services of DUI consultants (Gil) who gave an expert opinion based on the case findings and was willing to testify if need arise. Gils report was very elaborate (7 pages),encouraging and positive. By the time of the second summons, Tom was able to reach out to the DA and a plea to drop the DUI altogether and a guilty plea for a far lesser moving traffic violation. I was in tears when I heard this and felt I was given a second chance which is all i wanted. my family and I were extremely thankful and happy with the results of the case and I expressed my gratitude to Tom on what a wonderful and professional job he had done.Thank you again Tom. I will never forget the help of your services for the rest of my life and for giving me the second chance in life! I will highly recommend Thomas Caroll and his for any legal matters if you think you deserve another chance in life at a very nominal fee and a satisfaction guaranteed result.

Posted by anonymous | November 19, 2014

Just call him for your DUI needs already - or read below and decide

I was a NY Driver pulled over for a DUI in Sayreville, NJ by NJ State Police. I performed 5 FST's before being placed under arrest and taken in where I blew a .13. I was facing probable 7 month suspension (which would transfer to NY as well) and high fines. In NJ there is ZERO plea bargaining for ...DUI. I called 7 lawyers, received 7 consultations and never once felt like I found the "right" lawyer, just bored people looking for an easy check in their pocket. I found Tom via this website and honestly thought it was a scam site since he had so many good reviews. I actually called one of the lawyers listed as an endorser and he said "you are choosing the best of the best - tell him I say hello". I called Tom and he told me how he loves State Police cases since they tend to overlook things. The thing with DUI's in NJ is you need to find the hole in the case - and pick away at it until there's nothing holding your case firm - then you get the prosecutor or Judge to cut back the charge or at best, dismiss it. No one else told me this. I asked him how much. His cost was so much more reasonable than the others that I actually called back and asked if that was only half. Throughout the case, I had a ton of questions - Tom would email me back sometimes within minutes of my emails - if not than within the hour. I had THREE different phone numbers to contact him at. He led me through step by step what his plan is, and what his backup plan is. He didn't mind repeating himself to me or explaining it to me more deeply so I could understand it better. This man is passionate about what he does - he knows the law like no other - he knows how to find the hole in the case and pick away at it until it falls apart. This man is good - real good. My DUI was dismissed due to lack of evidence - State Police never provided requested evidence. Tom took that base hit turned it into a Home Run. Your mileage may vary - there may be a rock solid case against you and for that no lawyer in the State can help you. But if you want the best shot, Tom is the one you want.

Posted by jim | September 26, 2014

the bow tie, knows law

If your looking for a top notch, well respected , professional lawyer, well I have to say you shouldn't look any further. I can only speak from my experience, of which is heart wrenching enough, tom was with me every step of the way. Not knowing the legal system I had a lot of questions. As I searc...hed for a lawyer, I heard war stories of how lawyers acted towards clients and I was very cautious. I met with a few, and the bottom line was, I have to trust my freedom with this man. Tom was the last I met, he was forth coming, honest, and by far the most reasonably priced. Granted his office isn't the best, he was late, and later found out has to drive very fast all day. I also found out its because he has a pretty good work load. This man has a passion, and its the law, he knows it in and out and believe me, I had a strange case, if he doesn't know it, he finds out very quickly. When in the court house, tom is very well respected, and my particular judge thought the world of him, although that is important in a criminal case the respect came from how thorough he is. The bottom line is tom dots his i's and crossing his t's..do yourself a big favor, stop looking, you've found the lawyer who will guard your freedom in the most professional way possible.. jim

Posted by Dave | August 07, 2014

Highly Responsive & Effective. Very Impressed

Extremely responsive and attentive. Hired him for 4 point traffic case. Resolved painlessly for zero points without even having to go to court (affidavit after he negotiated plea). After court made mistake reporting DMV points, he instantly responded to our email and helped us resolve in less tha...n 24 hours...at no charge. Very impressed.

See All Client Reviews