It's been a few years, but I had a case like this. My client was in your position. The guy who he had the internet-based problem with was in a western state. We sued the our-of-state guy successfully in Florida, and the Florida court had jurisdiction. Without having done the research to answer your question today, I can only say that I would be very surprised if the law has changed. Find a lawyer who knows what to do and sue them in Florida, make them come to you. Good luck!
If you think my response is the best response, it would help me if you would indicate that. Also, please note that my responses to question(s) are NOT legal advice from me to you because I am NOT your lawyer, you are NOT my client, and we do NOT currently have an attorney-client relationship. Thanks!
Luckily, the lawyer above in your state has handled a case like this before, so best bet is to call him to discuss representation.
The website is immune from suit under the Communications Decency Act, a federal statute, unless you can prove that it has control over the editorial content of what's posted on the website. This is doubtful. Therefore, your cause of action lies against those persons or entities that are posting the defamatory statements. You'll need to show that the court has "personal jurisdiction" over them by the fact that they purposely posted the defamatory statements that reached viewers of the statements here in Florida.
I am not seeking to represent you based on the response to this question. The answer given is for general information purposes only. No attorney-client relationship is hereby intended.
Sign up to receive a 3-part series of useful information and advice about personal injury law.