Follow your attorney's advice. This is just a tactic by Kohls and other department stores to put a chilling effect upon theft. It is not necessarily enforceable, but they sure do make it sound that way, don't they?
Speak to your attorney again about the letters you're getting and ask him/her to write them back that you already were arrested and paid your debt to society an they have no right to seek any further payments directly from you.
You may call our office at 516-248-6600 or send an email to us at Ted@Thelawteam.com. This answer does not form an attorney/client relationship with anyone and any answers do not constitute direct legal advice and should not be followed unless and until you have spoken with an attorney of your choice.
This is a matter of state law. Ask your attorney what can happen if you do not pay and whether there is any authority to demand this amount. Some states allow companies that are the object of shoplifting to obtain a civil penalty on top of the damages done by the shoplifting.
Mr. Goldstein is a Virginia-licensed attorney only. The information is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation. Answering this question does not in any way constitute legal representation. Contacting Mitchell Goldstein or the Goldstein Law Group does not constitute legal representation, nor is any information you provide protected by attorney-client privilege until otherwise advised.