This is VERY difficult to answer. The court GENERALLY looks to equity - or fairness - under the circumstances. If you show an estimate to replace the door is $1250 (and why you NEED to replace BOTH doors) and a new refrigerator is only $1000, then it makes sense. However, there are issues with depreciation, but this is where you would need to craft an argument. Clearly, you could, on your own, figure out a way to pro-rate it, e.g. charge $750, but it will ultimately be up to the court to determine what is fair.
If you can prove that the refrigerator was new when the tenants moved in, and they do not have photos to prove it was already damaged, the facts are in your favor. Just try to think this through logically and come to a self-determination of what is fair. This is OFTEN what the court will decide.
If you have further questions, be sure to speak with a lawyer that knows Small Claims and landlord/tenant law.
-Adam Jaffe Law Office of Adam Jay Jaffe PO Box 2437 Camarillo, CA 93011-2437 (805) 504-2223 www.smallclaimsappeals.com Adam@SmallClaimsAppeals.com This posting is provided for “information purposes” only and should not be relied upon as "legal advice". Nothing transmitted from this posting constitutes the establishment of an attorney-client relationship. Applicability of the legal principles discussed here may differ substantially in individual situations or in different states.
Such scratches are clearly above and beyond normal wear and tear. Assuming you have proof it was a new fridge or was in normal condition, I think you get to choose the cheaper of replacing it with another 2-year-old fridge or replacing the doors. It sounds expensive but you have a right to the fridge in the condition you provided it (less normal depreciation).
Responses to Avvo questions are based on a general discussion of the law and in no way constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created, and you should not take or fail to take actions based on my answers. Consult an attorney in your area. Time is often of the essence. Act quickly!
If you still have an invoice showing how much you paid for the fridge and how old it is, but the tenant cannot prove that the scratches were on the fridge when they moved in, you could probably ask for half the value of the fridge minus normal depreciation. Fridges last more than 10 years nowadays, and if the fridge is still working, half of the value minus depreciation should "make you whole".