If your agreement said the house is worth $160,000 and she is buying you out for $25,000 (nevermind what the mortgage balance was at the time) and you transferred title and she paid you, it is a done deal unless for some reason you were to have your amount recalculated in the future (highly unlikely). Just ask her if she sold the house for $200,000 would she be sending you some extra money....I think not. It is what we call the risks of changes in value in any investment...stock, house, business, etc.
If my response has been "helpful" or the "best answer" please indicate it. It is rewarding to know that my answer has helped.
As Mr. Kuhn stated, you have been paid out and she has no more claims against you.
I am an attorney with over a decade of experience in Matrimonial and Family Law with offices in Brooklyn and Manhattan. I have experience in all five boroughs as well is Nassau and Suffolk County. The opinion expressed in this ad based upon the limited information provided and do not indicate an attorney-client relationship
Based upon your question, your ex bought you out at the market value at the time. That she did not sell at that time is her fault and she has no basis to ask you for return of any monies.
This advice is not meant to create an attorney-client relationship and is a general anwer to the question posed.
Sign up to receive a 10-part series of useful information and legal advice about the divorce process.