The breath testing devices are not admissible in court unless the device is among one of the types approved by the Pennsylvania Department of Health AND the device was properly calibrated. The case dealing with this issue is Commonwealth v. Brigidi, which you can find here: http://caselaw.findlaw.com/pa-superior-court/1290135.html
Your answer says that you are in Bedford. I am from the area, and I do take cases from Bedford occasionally. If you have a more or less contemporaneous blood test from the hospital that clears her, it certainly helps things.
You cannot expect to simply go to the MDJ's office and present the blood test from the hospital and expect to win. There are complicated evidentiary issues in play here, and it is not reasonable to expect that a layperson could manage those alone. You really should hire an attorney to represent her on this case.
I do not represent you. You should hire an attorney. Only after meeting you and talking to you during a review of your case can a solid assessment be made of the case and any likely outcome. Do not rely on my advice unless you hire me.
Contact an experienced criminal defense lawyer immediately. There are far too many issues to be answered in this forum. Hall's cough drops should not affect any brac reading; Nyquil may, depending on its composition. Good luck!
You are probably referring to alcohol trapping from over the counter medication that can affect breathylizer results... The good thing is that your daughter did not refuse to cooperate with police investigation...
Now , you can help your daughter to contact an attorney who can help your daughter...
Of course my answers are not the only source that you should rely on. Furthermore, its best to contact me about your Legal or Medical issues at my office number 215-240-7565. Licensed to Practice Law in PA and NJ. Medical PA license.
I agree with my colleagues who recommend that you seek the advice of an experienced criminal defense attorney to avoid adverse consequences to her license. The pre-breath test administered to your daughter is notoriously inaccurate. Even more so when administered incorrectly. The blood tests performed at the hospital are much more accurate. Good luck!
Your daughter has a valid defense, and the blood and urine test results should be compelling evidence. The PBT results should not be admissible at the hearing pursuant to a 2010 PA Supreme Court case that your attorney can describe for you. So it seems to me the question is not whether cold medicines can affect the PBT results, but rather whether the officer can testify to any other physical indications of impairment, e.g., glassy bloodshot eyes, odor of alcohol, swaying, slurred speech, etc. If not, I don't see how the Commonwealth can meet its burden of proof. Make sure you have an attorney.
This is a response to a general question and is not legal advice and does not constitute legal representation. You should contact an experienced DUI attorney in your area. Thanks.
DUI DUI as a criminal offense Breathalyzer test for DUI Refusing a DUI test DUI charges DUI and driver's license penalties DUI and civil lawsuits Underage DUI Driving under the influence of drugs Criminal defense Criminal charges Burden of proof for criminal charges Crimes against society Defenses for criminal charges Criminal court Lawsuits and disputes
Sign up to receive a 3-part series of useful information and legal advice about DUIs.