A person's home is their castle. This is an oversimplified but true characterization of the 4th amendment law. Law enforcement can only enter your home under certain circumstances including your consent. Absent your consent, they need a warrant or a narrow set of exceptions.
These scenarios are very fact specific and you need the advise of local counsel who can properly advise you of your rights and strategies for your defense. There are a number of qualified DUI defense attorneys listed on this website. Call one for a consultation.
Best of luck.
Yes. This is definitely something you want to fight. Both whether the witnesses bias due to the fight taints their testimony that you were driving DUI and the officer's entering your home without a warrant or consent.
Edward J. Blum
Yes. Virginia law prohibits an officer from arresting a person for DUI without a warrant if the officer did not observe the person driving. This is referred to as the Warrantless Misdemeanor Arrest Rule, which essentially says that officers can arrest suspects, without a warrant, for misdemeanor offenses committed in the presence of the officer. There are exceptions to this general rule, but none of them seem to apply to your situation. Therefore, assuming none of the exceptions apply, if an officer comes to your house to arrest your for a DUI which was not committed in the presence of the officer, the arrest is illegal.
This does not mean that the case is automatically thrown out, but it should be helpful in mounting a defense to the DUI charge. I recently got a "not guilty" verdict in a case where the client was essentially pulled over by an off-duty officer and then arrested by a different officer. Like in the facts of the question presented, the arresting officer never saw the client drive and that was an important fact during the trial.
T. Kevin Wilson, Esq.
The Wilson Law Firm
DUI & Criminal Defense…When Results Matter
9300 Grant Avenue
Manassas, Virginia 20110
For a FREE copy of the Virginia DUI / DWI Arrest Survival Guide: The Guilt Myth, a consumer guide written by a nationally recognized Virginia DUI Defense Lawyer, visit www.TheWilsonLawFirm.org.