In the absence of a written agreement it could be argued both ways.
Your "partner" may claim that your guaranty was part of an agreement you had. You would argue that you have a right to equitable contribution. This is not something usually covered in the off the shelf operating agreement I suspect your LLC has.
While you are straightening this out, make sure you also get a buy-sell agreement between you. There is no public market for your shares if one of you dies, wants to retire or becomes permanently disabled. You want somthing that sets a formula for the buyout (not a number, a formula) before the event (otherwise you will never agree) and compels the LLC or your "partner" to buy you out. Usually there is also a right of first refusal in case your "partner" wants to sell to the "future partner from hell".
The above is general legal and business analysis. It is not "legal advice" but analysis, and different lawyers may analyse this matter differently, especially if there are additional facts not reflected in the question. I am not your attorney until retained by a written retainer agreement signed by both of us. I am only licensed in California. See also avvo.com terms and conditions item 9, incorporated as if it was reprinted here.
If your LLC's finances are being properly and separately managed (i.e. nobody uses the LLC as their own personal piggy bank), then the lessor would only be able to recover from the LLC and the partner signing the guaranties. With that said, the partner who signed the guaranty will likely be willing to try anything and everything, including alleging side-agreements, promissory reliance, etc. in order to the other partners contribute to his liability. If you haven't already, please consider going to an attorney to make sure that you have an operating and/or membership agreement that completely outlines your understanding with your partners.
In a typical LLC setting the member is not responsible for the liabilities of the LLC beyond the agreed capital contribution, ergo there is no imputed responsibility of a member to assume some level of additional contribution unless expressly agreed to in writing. Consequently, absent a written indemnity agreement between the lease guarantor and the other member to assume equal responsibility for any default damages being assumed personally, then you are out of luck.
My answer is not intended to be giving legal advice and this topic can be a complex area where the advice of a licensed attorney in your State should be obtained. Please click "helpful" or "best answer" if my answer added any value or add a "comment" if you have more info for me to help you get a better answer.
I recommend that you have the other Member guarantee the lease. At the very minimum I recommend that he or she signed an indemnity agreement for your benefit. The indemnity agreement is irrelevant with the landlord, but it may benefit you down the road if you need to be reimbursed for any funds you personally guaranteed.
The above is not legal advice. It is an illustration of options that can be used in certain situations. I have not examined all of your facts, if I did I might provide a different response.
You will want someone to take a look at the operating agreement for the limited liability company to determine your liability to each other. As far as the lease goes, only the parties that are signatories to the lease would be responsible. However, I think you could possibly make an argument for liability from one partner to another (although it would be a stretch.)
You should consult counsel on this issue and have someone review your operating agreement.
An LLC is a type of business entity that provides limited liability for its members (owners), which means that they are not personally liable for any contract, tort, or other obligation of the LLC by virtue of solely being a member. However, pursuant to Corporation Code Section 17101(e), a member can waive this protection and agree to be personally liable for any or all of the debts, obligations, and liabilities of the LLC as long as the waiver agreement is set forth in the Articles of Organization or the Operating Agreement. Another way for a member of a LLC to be held personally liable to a 3rd party is by personally guaranteeing a contractual obligation of the LLC.
To answer your question, if the LLC is a party to the lease and one member is also personally guaranteeing this contractual obligation, if there is a default, then the lessor can seek recovery from both the LLC and that member to recover unpaid funds due under the terms of the lease agreement. Hope this helps.
The information and materials provided by SARVEY ASKARIEH on this Website are for informational purposes ONLY and should NOT be relied upon as legal advice, legal opinion or any other professional advice and nor do they constitute legal advice, legal opinion or any other professional advice.
Nor does the transmission and/or receipt of information contained on this Website from SARVEY ASKARIEHh FORM or CONSTITUTE an attorney-client relationship with Yevras Law Group (YLG), or its attorney(s) partner(s), associate(s), or consultant(s). Simply contacting SARVEY ASKARIEH via a contact form, email or otherwise will not establish an attorney-client relationship between you and SARVEY ASKARIEH.
Also, any transmission of information between you and SARVEY ASKARIEH is NOT intended to, and will NOT create an attorney-client relationship between you and SARVEY ASKARIEH and does not and should not give you a reasonable basis for belief that such a relationship has been established. An attorney-client relationship between YOU and any attorney(s), partner(s) and/or consultant(s) of YEVRAS LAW GROUP (“YLG”) can ONLY be created by the signing of YLG’s written representation agreement.
SARVEY ASKARIEH does not guarantee the privacy or confidentiality of any communications sent by you by electronic methods via use of e-mail or contact form on this website. You shall be solely responsible for the security, confidentiality, integrity, and use of all communications that you transmit to SARVEY ASKARIEH via this Website. Without a signed written representation agreement with SARVEY ASKARIEH, unsolicited communications by you to SARVEY ASKARIEH will not be treated as confidential or be protected by any Attorney-Client Privilege and/or offered any protection, regardless if the content is deemed to be privileged, sensitive or confidential. SARVEY ASKARIEH does NOT agree to accept and/or maintain the secrecy of any unsolicited communication you send to HER unless an attorney-client relationship currently exists between YOU and HER.