If its truly a Small Claims court (vs. District Court) then your judgment is for money ONLY. If you had filed in District Court, then you could have sought an order for return of the motorcycle (Detinue Action) as well as damages. In any event, the next step is to file a Writ of Seizure and request that it be served by the Etowah Co (Gadsden) Sheriff upon all property of Defendant in the county. A better alternative would be for you to hire a Gadsden collection attorney such as Bradley Cornett (he's listed here on Avvo) and pay him a percentage of what he recovers for you. Using an attorney is much less hassle than doing it yourself.
No attorney-client relationship exists or is created by the answering of questions on Avvo or by any email communications resulting from Avvo unless and until a written contract creating such a relationship is executed by both the attorney and the client.