Skip to main content

How do I make my workers comp case as valuable as I think it is?

Gainesville, FL |

I want to close my case so I can control what I feel needs to be done but the insurance company doesn't think it is worth very much. I hurt my back almost a year ago. It's an aggravation of a pre-existing condition but I don't need surgery. I do need continuing chiropractic and maybe deep massage or PT. As it is they won't approve these treatments anymore. The insurance co. has only approved a with revolving care staff for pain mgmt + rehab. Will going back to the walk-in clinic for a referral for any of the above help with the value of the case? I’m seeing my WC lawyer soon but he has been very bad about giving me straight answers. And, any idea what this case might be worth?

+ Read More

Attorney answers 8

Best Answer

Even though I agree with Barry Stein, I'm going to give you a very unscientific rule of thumb for valuing a non-surgical case like yours: your case, for settlement purposes, is worth about 15-20% of the carrier's exposure, which is the total of every penny that the carrier is ever likely to have to spend on your case over the remainder of your life. So, if you think that all that medical care you described will eventually add up to $50,000, don't expect the carrier to offer you more than $10k to settle, if that much. Carriers settle claims to buy off risk (e.g., complications from surgery). They simply have no incentive to write settlement checks now when they could keep relatively low-risk claims open and just pay out little dribs and drabs over time (to your providers, btw; not to you directly) that might never amount to the estimated exposure.


Without more information it is difficult to evaluate your case. What is the cost of your medication, if any? How much therapy do you require? How much is related to your pre-existing condition? Also, recent case law has made it much easier to get coverage for pre-existing conditions if they were also a result of a work accident. I suggest that when you sit down with your lawyer, find out how he is evaluating your case and the basis for his evaluation. The insurance company may not agree, and never can be forced to settle, but you can at least find out your options.


As you are represented, your attorney is the one you need to address this question with. In general terms, a carrier does not have to settle your claim, nor do you for that matter. Unfortunately, changes in the law have greatly weakened the injured worker's bargaining power when it comes time for a washout. I can promise you this, you will never be rich from a WC settlement, especially post 2003 date of accident. I am sure your attorney will do all he can for you, remember he gets paid a percentage of what he gets you so he is going to maximize the amount as best he can.


A worker's compensation case is valued by virtue of the potential for future lost wages and medical expenses being incurred. That is what the carrier is buying themselves out of if they settle. You have to show them with documentation that they will be incurring either or both of these in the future. It is impossible for someone to give an opinion on your case without seeing your medical records.

The answers given are limited to the facts as given and presumed by the answer itself. Without seeing actual written documentation or having a conference to more fully explore the issues, this short answer has only limited application. Make sure to seek legal counsel and provide all documentation to get assistance in making informed legal choices., 305 377 1505


There are not many "straight answers." Most of it falls into gray areas. I am sure your lawyer will get you the best deal he can.

This answer is intended as general information and not as specific legal advice. If you want to have a free consultation with me, please contact me through AVVO.


If you don't trust your attorney's advice, why is he still your attorney? I'm certainly NOT suggesting you fire him. Perhaps you need to have an in-person conversation about what you can expect.

If this information has been helpful, please indicate by clicking the up icon. Legal Disclaimer: Mr. Candiano is licensed to practice law in Illinois and Indiana. The response herein is not legal advice and does not create an attorney/client relationship. The response is in the form of legal education and is intended to provide general information about the matter within the question. Links:


The main way to make your case worth more money is to hire the right lawyer in the first place. Great cases don't just takes a great lawyer to do so and this begins as soon as possible after the accident.
Bob Shapiro


Most people with claims have heard stories of what others received and most of those are not true or are grossly inflated. Keep in mind that case evaluation is different in every case. Trust your atty or switch attorneys.